Reviews

The boy at the top of the mountain by John Boyne

cover image

Doubleday, 2015. ISBN 9780552573542
(Ages: 10+) Recommended. The Boy at the Top of the Mountain follows protagonist Pierrot, a young boy who is sent to live with his aunt Beatrix in Germany during World War II. Hailing from Paris and being only seven years old, Pierrot knows little to nothing about the Nazis, but this all changes once he discovers that his aunt is a servant for Adolf Hitler, and his new home is the Berghof. Pierrot is quickly taken under Hitler's guidance, and Pierrot must decide not only whether he agrees with Hitler's motives, but whether he is strong enough to reject them.
When Pierrot arrives at the Berghof, he is stripped of everything he has ever known. He is told not to think of his old life, of his best friend that he left behind . . . he is even stripped of his name. All that remains with him is a single storybook and his memories.
Boyne has weaved together a powerful, heartbreaking and disturbing tale. Reading about Pierrot as he is growing up under Hitler's watchful eye, reading about his confusion as he struggles to make friends because of where he resides, and reading about his eventual choosing of which side he is truly on is hard to read due to both his naivety and his age (Pierrot ages from 7-16 during the course of the novel).
The only faults of the novel were that it was hard to connect with Pierrot as he sometimes seemed distant from the reader. Often, his voice at seven sounded more like he was of age thirteen, and this made it hard to believe the story at some points.
Boyne took many risks with this novel, and they certainly paid off. Pierrot is not a particularly likeable character, but the reader is compelled to continue the book nonetheless. The Boy at the Top of the Mountain is no doubt a spectacular read for children aged 10 and above who are beginning to learn about world history.
Breanne Foster (Student)

I'll never let you go by Smriti Prasadam-Halls

cover image

Ill. by Alison Brown. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408839010
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Bedtime, Love, Family. Reassurance comes with every page as the mother tells her offspring that she will always be there. In simple rhyming sentences, the message is clear: that no matter what happens the mother will be around. Turning the pages the young child will see a variety of animals in different settings with their babies. In one the pair of bears are on a swing, in another over the page, picking brambles. These are followed by a pair of dogs in a house where the pup has drawn on the walls with crayon, but the mother dog does not scold, simply tells the pup that he knows what to do. Over the page a mother crocodile watches as her baby has a small tantrum, but he is reassured that she will wait for him to finish. An excited kangaroo leaps around with Mum there by his side, while a mother koala brushes away her baby's tears. At the end each of the mothers and babies are shown together on one double page with the line of the title, 'I'll never let you go'. This is a wholly comforting story, one that will reassure younger readers that someone is there to watch over them no matter what they do.
The simple rhyming sentences will be easily repeated by the reader, and the illustrations of the animals and their environment will be recognised by many.
Fran Knight

Game on! 2016

cover image

Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9780545850315
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Game On! 2016 is a book by gamers for gamers. This means it should be enjoyed by all gamers and is highly recommended for game fans aged 8+. Readers can find out the facts behind the most popular games, the top hoaxes and the coolest secrets. Read about MarioKart and how many were sold or how Al in Minecraft glitches sometimes (and why). Gamers can also read about the top 10 game bosses and the hardest achievements and trophies to win.
The book is bright and colourful, relying on the well-known game images and small segments of texts to engage its readers. Game On! can be read a few pages (or a topic) at a time and would be a great book for children to keep in their tray at school or to read in the car. Readers will need to be independent to read the text but they can also look at the images for enjoyment.
Kylie Kempster

Quentin Blake's A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

cover image

Ill. by Quentin Blake. HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9781843653035
A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens is one of the most enduring Christmas stories of all time. It has been described as "the book that defines the Christmas spirit" as Ebenezer Scrooge, a mean-spirited miser, is visited by three ghosts one Christmas Eve. They show Scrooge the true value of Christmas: charity, good humour and love for his fellow man and turn his attitude around.
Since its publication in 1843, it has been available in many different editions and formats that it would seem superfluous for there to be yet another one. But - while this one is an unabridged version it has been illustrated by Quentin Blake and that is the special drawcard. When Miss 9 was here recently, she saw it in the pile and immediately recognised his unique style through her familiarity with the Roald Dahl stories she loves and sat down to read it, even though Christmas was well past.
Suddenly the story that I've had in a leather-bound, tissue-paper tome given to my grandmother over 100 years ago became accessible to this current generation of the family. When there were questions to be asked because at that stage she was unfamiliar with the England it was set in, we had fun exploring the answers and her reading repertoire expanded to historical fiction! Now, as her school studies open up the world of the England that spawned the First Fleet and Australia's early European settlers, she has a basic understanding that is making it all make so much more sense to her.
Last Christmas I was in a school library and I instituted the Christmas Countdown which involved a guest reader sharing a new Christmas-based book each day, an activity which proved to be a very popular lunchtime focus. But this version of this classic, read as a chapter or two a day, would prove a worthy alternative. Or you could suggest it to a teacher to share with their class on a similar basis.
Christmas is abound with stories to share but there is a reason that A Christmas Carol has stood the test of time. Well-written and now perfectly illustrated in a style that is familiar to many, there is a whole new generation able to appreciate it.
Barbara Braxton

The expatriates by Janice Y. K. Lee

cover image

Little, Brown, 2016. ISBN 9781408706862
(Age: Adult - Mature YA readers) Recommended. Dislocation. Relationships. Hong Kong. Identity. Maternal role. Family. Like the central characters in this book, the reader becomes a traveller into another land as the author deftly deposits us in the experience of the contemporary expatriate living in Hong Kong as we eavesdrop on the internal dialogue and emotional state of three women. The main characters have left America and are in Hong Kong - for a time. This dislocation and temporary residence state impacts their relationships and their identity. For the married expat women this means an almost 1950s blissful experience of domestic and social life, with the added bonus of hired help, while their husbands climb the ladder of success. Margaret though suffers from a heart-breaking loss and grief response that impacts both her family and Mercy, a young Korean-American woman who has her own personal identity issues. Another of the women, Hilary, is saddened by the loss of identity and family because of infertility. In the unique social setting of the expatriate woman, this too brings amplified heartache.
The poignant journey of relationships that are put under pressure by isolation and also enriched by the expatriate experience is the basis of this intriguing and captivating narrative. It also highlights the bizarrely unique nature of cross-cultural experience from the perspective of the wealthy expats. The author manages to communicate the sense of loneliness and the false connectedness that occurs as people are enmeshed, for no other reason than that their journeys began from a similar first-world experience.
This book can be recommended for its ability to move the reader, and the gentle and yet profound way it deals with the emotional struggles of the main characters. Lee stirs empathy as we watch these women and get inside their skin to view a different world, forever changed by their expat experience. This is essentially an adult story, but mature Young Adult readers could also connect to the postgraduate world of work far from home. For anyone who has ever felt like they didn't belong, or has had to reimagine themselves in a new context, this story will resonate powerfully.
Carolyn Hull

A beginner's guide to bear spotting by Michelle Robinson and David Roberts

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408845554
Picture book. If, like the child in the story, you are planning on going on a bear-spotting adventure, then this is definitely the must-have guide to have with you. You mustn't venture into bear country without knowing the difference between the black bear (ursus americanus) and the brown bear (ursus horribilis); your backpack full of anti-bear gear such as pepper spray and bubble gum; and your trusty teddy for company. And as you are repeatedly told throughout the story, you need to pay attention, focus, take note and heed the advice. For only with it will you be safe.
Even though the chances of coming across either one or the other is pretty unlikely, nevertheless it can happen and the strategies to be applied vary depending on the species. Don't climb a tree if it's a black bear because it can follow you, whereas a brown one can't. Play dead if it's a brown one, although that might be an invitation to dinner if you've confused them because black bears can be a little bit brown and brown bears can be a little bit black.
This is a heart-warming adventure with beautiful illustrations with exquisite line-work that bring all the characters to life and add lots of humour so the reader can be brave and safe at the same time.
Little children love stories about bears, real or not, and this is another one to add to the collection that will bring delight and pleasure and reinforce the idea that stories and reading them are fun. And the next time they go on a bear hunt they will be well-prepared!
Barbara Braxton

Rebel of the Sands by Alwyn Hamilton

cover image

Rebel of the Sands bk 1. Faber and Faber, 2016. ISBN 9780571325252
(Age: 13+) Recommended. Fantasy. Desert. Western. Amani lives in the desolate town of Dustwalk and she loves the desert sands. She is convinced that there is more to life than the stifling attitudes to women and marriage that her family practises and decides to enter a shooting contest, disguised as a young man. When the contest falls into chaos, she has the chance to run with a foreigner, but life is full of danger and the Sultan's soldiers are on the prowl.
Hamilton has used an intriguing combination of the Western genre, with its sharp shooting and wild frontier and desert life, where nomads struggle to bring camel laden supplies across the desert. Add mythical half human and half magic people with amazing powers, a rebel prince who is trying to bring peace and prosperity to his people and some amazing adventures and the book is a winner.
Amani is a wonderful protagonist. Told in the first person she brings a wry commentary and vivid descriptions of the landscape and the main characters. Her wry sense of humour is very engaging and her amazing skill as a sharpshooter grabs the reader as she struggles to better her life, while engaging in thrilling adventures - including a battle on a moving train and fights against a magical creature. Jin, the foreigner, is also very appealing, and the slow burning romance is sure to be popular.
Rebel of the sands ends with a satisfying conclusion, but there is plenty of scope left for more in the series, and I look forward to reading them.
Pat Pledger

The Fairy Tale Matchmaker by E.D. Baker

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781619638006
(Age: 11-14) Recommended. Themes: Fairy Tales; Adventure; Relationships. This is a delightful and simple Fairy tale for older readers who like the addition of a little 'essence of romance' in a magical story that has fairy tale characters that are beyond school age and finding their way in the world. The story begins with Cory recognising that she cannot continue in her work role as Tooth Fairy any longer as it brings her no joy, and not much income! She thinks that any job is better than a job she despises, despite being raised and trained to fulfil the role. The family tension this creates is nothing compared to the forces that are unleashed by the Tooth Fairy Guild as they seek to return her to their fold. Cory has a wonderful cohort of interesting friends, and as she seeks to explore new career directions she meets an abundance of quirky and recognisable characters from the world of fairy tale and nursery rhyme. She also moonlights as a drummer in a band that is experiencing growing success! The increasing attempts of the Tooth Fairy Guild to return her to the role from which she has resigned unleash a flurry of disastrous events. Amidst this drama, she also begins to take on the role of Matchmaker for her friends and acquaintances, attempting to fix their dating life while also discovering her own future and the power of a kiss.
This can be recommended for readers who like more grown-up Fairy Stories. Suited for readers aged 11 - 14. This is an exciting, but gentle adventure that allows the reader to rediscover affection for Fairy tale characters in an uncomplicated narrative. In some ways this is not unlike Emily Rodda's Rondo series in the way it weaves the back stories of traditional fairy tale and Nursery Rhyme characters into an adventure. The cover image tends to suggest this book is for a child, yet the inferred age of the characters is that they are post-school age. The simplicity of the narrative though will make it accessible for readers who are just beginning to consider a future beyond childhood.
Carolyn Hull

Yogscast: The Diggy Diggy Book

cover image

Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781407163994
(Ages: 9-12) For those unfamiliar with the gaming world, Yogscast create and broadcast videogame walkthroughs via their YouTube channel. They have a huge worldwide following. This book is not about a certain videogame, nor does it give game tutorials. It is about the Yogscast itself (profiles of each creator) and includes funny content based on their popular videos. This book is not likely to be understandable to anyone who is not a Yogscast fan (don't be misled by the Minecraft references). It has a very specific target audience but based on their large following, that target audience is probably very large. While the Yogscast videos are not targeted specifically at children, the book definitely is and so it is child friendly in content and appeal. It contains lots of colourful artwork with textual elements often on the minimal side. There are also a few activities for children to complete. Young fans of Yogscast will love this, but it is most definitely a fad book with a time limit on its popularity.
Nicole Nelson

Witch Switch by Sibeal Pounder

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408852675
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Witch Switch is book 2 in the Witch Wars Adventure series. It starts with a recap of the previous stores so readers who are new to the series can catch up. In book 2, readers will find the main characters, Tiga and Fluffanora, holidaying until they hear about Peggy, the ruling witch, leaving her position and leaving two gruesome witches in charge instead. Surely Peggy would not abandon her witch friends. Did she really go away with the fairies? Tiga and Fluffanora try to sneak into the capital city but due to unforseen circumstances and the appearance of gruesome witches, they are discovered. As the witches find shelter, they discover other witches are also starting to disappear. Why are these witches disappearing? Who would need them? It is up to Tiga and Fluffanora to discover the truth.
Witch Switch is a quirky novel about an amazing make believe world of witches. It is highly recommended for girls aged 9+. They will giggle at the spells and behaviours of Fluffanora and enjoy the adventure as the truth is uncovered. The text is descriptive and easy to read, encouraging readers who are new to novels. The chapters are also short and quick moving and the black and white cartoon-style illustrations only add to the quirkiness of the characters in this witch world.
Kylie Kempster

A tangle of gold by Jaclyn Moriarty

cover image

The Colours of Madeleine bk 3. Pan Macmillan, 2016. ISBN 9781743533239
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Magic. Colour. Coming of age. After a short stay of only two weeks in Cambridge, Elliot is swept back into the Kingdom of Cello with his father. He is taken prisoner by the Hostiles and Princess Ko and Samuel and Sergio have been arrested and face execution. Cello is facing a crisis and bitter colour storms are raging through the land.
Back in Cambridge, Madeleine is increasingly lonely. Her nose bleeds often and her mother is not well. She has lost communication with Elliot and fears that when the remaining Royals are sent back to Cello she will lose him forever.
This is a stunning conclusion to a truly unique, clever and memorable trilogy. There are many unexpected surprises and twists and turns as Madeleine and Elliot try to work out the mysteries in Cello and bring back equilibrium to their country. Ably assisted by Keira, Princess Ko and the other fully realised protagonists, the reader is swept along on a mighty adventure that is sprinkled with references to Isaac Newton, the science of colour and the poetry of Lord Byron. Some philosophical ideas and some heartbreak all made an appearance to complete a wonderful story.
This is an outstanding series with a superb final book that weaves all the tangles together in a creative, complex and utterly satisfying way. I highly recommend all three books for both upper primary and secondary readers and all who love fantasy.
Pat Pledger

Little lunch: triple the treats by Danny Katz

cover image

Ill. by Mitch Vane. Black Dog Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925126907
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Humour, School, Recess time. Three stories in one volume is what awaits those kids hooked on the television series, Little lunch, along with those already familiar with the books released since 2001.
This volume includes The milk bar, The cake stall and The grandparents day, all concerned with the six students in Mrs Gonsha's class pictured on the cover. The hilarious stories will bring gales of laughter as recognition sets in. Each is simply based around everyday happenings of children at school: forgetting to pack your lunch, having to invite your grandparents to school or being concerned about homeless animals. Each story is easy to read, about forty pages long and copiously illustrated by Mitch Vane and designed to bring a smile and laugh to every reader. Photographs of each of the students and teacher at various positions around the school add to the fun of reading the tales. The milk bar across the road from the school beckons when Atticus again, forgets to pack his lunch. Of course the milk bar is out of bounds but he and his friends develop ingenious methods of getting there un-noticed, that is unless Deborah the dobber doesn't dob.
Grandparents day is an annual day in the life of this school, one that last year turned out to be a disaster. This year Battie has a huge problem. His grandfather is not coming but Mrs Gonsha has knitted the man a lime green scarf. He devises a series of plans all of which come to nothing and he must confess.
The cake stall shows Melanie baking cakes for a cake stall to raise money and awareness of the plight of homeless puppies. Each story is well illustrated and uses different fonts and print size to emphasise main points, while the stories, although brief always have a neat resolution which can teach the readers something about how they interact with other people. All in all a very satisfying group of stories, nicely presented which will have wide appeal.
Fran Knight

Maresi by Maria Turtschaninoff

cover image

Trans. by Annie Prime. The Red Abbey Chronicles bk 1. Pushkin Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781782690917
(Age: 13+) Recommended. Finlandia Junior Award 2014. Fantasy. Women. Nuns. Abbeys. After the Hunger Winter, Maresi came to the Red Abbey to escape death from malnutrition. In the Red Abbey she is safe and has ample food to eat and a treasure chamber of books to learn from. Then Jai arrives on a ship. She has scars on her back and has been cruelly treated by a father who considers his wives and daughters to be worthless. Jai knows that his honour has been threatened by her escape and believes that he will pursue her, harming everyone at the Abbey. Maresi and the other women must call on the powers of the Mother in all her forms to save Jai and the other women and children.
This is a gripping story in many ways. The setting of the Red Abbey, where men are forbidden and women grow strong in body and mind is beautifully described as are the inhabitants of the island. Maresi is a wonderfully caring young girl, who looks after the youngest children, and takes the terror stricken Jai under her wing, helping her to heal and gain confidence. Sister O looks on Maresi as her protege and teaches her how to read the stories of the seven women who originally came to the island. Mother, the nun in charge is wise and tolerant and other characters are also fully developed so the the reader gets a great sense of the community spirit that pervades the Abbey.
Jai's ordeal and the way that women are treated in the society that she flees has a familiar feel, reminiscent of some modern day countries. There is a calm sense of underlying feminism, with women and girls being empowered at the Red Abbey, but it is never strident, and the themes of friendship, of sacrifice and of terror and magic are the ones that captivate the reader as the tale of whether Jai and Maresi can survive the wrath of Jai's father takes over.
Maresi's story seems complete and comes to a satisfying conclusion, so it will be interesting to see where the next in the series, Naodel, takes the reader. Maresi is a book that will appeal to lovers of fantasy, who want something a little more than a dystopian quest. Its themes of coming of age, women's rights and community living could make for a interesting book to discuss in a literature circle.
Pat Pledger

Near, far by Silvia Borando

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406363180
(Ages: 3-7) Wordless, Perspective, Near and Far, Animals, Imagination. This is an English translation of a 2013 Italian publication and part of the Minibombo series (little book buzzing with a big idea). The website www.minibombo.com has information, activities and games related to the books that could be used or adapted for the classroom. The big idea in this book is perspective. We see bits of an animal from close up: two green mounds. Children might start guessing now what it is they are seeing, (grassy hills or the ears of a frog?), then we get another view zoomed out a little more and we see many spiky ridges. Then it zooms right out and we see that it is a crocodile and we were looking at the spiky ridges of its back. Children will love trying to guess which animal is being shown before they see it in its entirety and it will encourage and stimulate imagination. It will also be a challenge for many children to work out which zoomed in part of the animal was being shown. One of the concepts of the minibombo books is using simple shapes to create animals and the books in the series use the same animals (a lot of the animals in this title are the same as in Now You See Me, Now You Don't).
While the book may have limited scope and children might not want to go back for repeated readings, it is a useful concept book for teachers working on perspective and near/far. It could be used as a starting point for perspective activities and artwork and to kick start discussions about how different people can see different things when looking at the same thing.
Nicole Nelson

Hacks for Minecrafters series by Megan Miller

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015
Hacks For Minecrafters: Combat/Builder. ISBN 9781408869635
Hacks for minecrafters: Master builder. ISBN 9781408869628
Hacks for Minecrafters: The Unofficial Guide to Tips and Tricks That Other Guides Won't Teach You. ISBN 9781632204400
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Themes: Gaming, Survival, Building. These books would be enjoyed by all people who enjoy playing computer games and in particular Minecraft. The three books are about 'Hacks and Tips', 'Combat' and 'Building' in Minecraft. The books have tips from: how to build glass domes, to how many times you have to hit a creeper with an iron sword to kill it.
The books are titled Hacks For Minecrafters yet after reading all three I discovered that there is only one hack between all the books, and that hack is common knowledge to most PC Minecrafters. Although there are no hacks in the books almost every piece of information they contain is very helpful. I may not be an avid Minecrafter but I found the books very interesting. These books would not make very good gifts but for people new to Minecraft they would be very helpful given the amount of information they contain.
I would recommend the books for people who play Minecraft at about 9-12 year olds. For those who struggle to read, they may be a little difficult as they contain a few complex words.
Reuben Schumacher (Student, aged 13)