Reviews

Thicker than water by Brigid Kemmerer

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781743318638
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. This book was impossible to out down.
'Stan was at work when she died. I was in my own bed. I don't know which is worse.'
Thomas Bellweather lived with his mother and her new husband Sam. Sam is a policeman. The story opens with Thomas preparing for his mother's funeral. She was murdered in the house, while he was sleeping. There was no forced entry and no sign of a struggle. What happened?
Thomas is a suspect, in a small town where stories run wild and police hold grudges. At the funeral he meets Charlotte Rooker and they are attracted to each other. Her three brothers are policemen and they are certain that Thomas is guilty. They are just as certain their sister should have nothing to do with Thomas.
Complicated family relationships are explored and reveal the cracks beneath the surface. Blood is, of course, thicker than water.
The reader will be pleased to find the story is not at the mercy of a romance. The scene has been set for a thrilling mystery, and this book does not disappoint. It is a wild ride that has the reader angry with many characters in turn and very undecided as to the guilt of the main players. Told by Thomas and Charlotte, this is a book that grips the reader and provides a tantalising twist towards the end.
Linda Guthrie

The Siren by Kiera Cass

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780008157937
(Age: 14+) Recommended. "You must never do anything that might expose our secret. This means that, in general, you cannot form close bonds with humans. You can speak to us, and you can always commune with the Ocean, but you are deadly to humans."
If you enjoy romance and reading about the power of love, then this is the book for you.
Kahlen is a siren and immortal. When humans hear her voice they are compelled to drown. With her 'sisters' (Elizabeth, Miaka, and Padma) Kahlen answers the bidding of the Ocean to lure humans to feed the Ocean's hunger. Kahlen and her 'sisters' move house frequently to hide the fact that they never age or become ill.
Akinli is a kind, handsome boy who is a genuinely nice person.
'I was meant to kiss this boy, designed to be held by him.'
Kahlen falls in love with him, and this is dangerous for both of them. While this is the focus of the book, the real strength of the story is the powerful bond between the sirens. Their support, generosity and love for each other is the reason they can survive being sentenced to immortality.
A romance and a fantasy, this is the perfect book for a lazy read with a box of chocolates.
Linda Guthrie

Mango and Bambang: Tapir all at sea by Polly Faber

cover image

Ill. by Clara Vulliamy. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406361476
(Age: 5-8) Recommended. Themes: Animals; Friendship; Humour. This is essentially a collection of short anecdotal and gently humourous stories involving a young faithful girl, Mango Allsorts, and her friend Bambang. Bambang is a tapir (not a pig!) and with Mango's support and friendship he grows in confidence while getting into interesting situations. He survives a ballet class, despite having four ungraceful legs and eventually becomes a flamenco dancer; falls out of a tree - collecting something very valuable on the way; is chased across the city; is involved in a tapir-napping and the potential loss of his companion. Faber has written in an uncomplicated style and the charming Mango is an excellent role model as a friend - never demanding the limelight and always supporting Bambang even when others don't.
Illustrations by Vulliamy are uncomplicated and cute, and the styling of the book is quite delightful - with a predominantly red, black and white colour palette and red and white striping indicating chapter breaks. Vulliamy is the daughter of renowned Author-Illustrator Shirley Hughes, and there is a recognisable hint of a familial style in the illustrations. In the manner of good picture books, sometimes the illustrations add detail beyond the written text.
This would also make a good read-aloud book for teachers or parents to share with those not yet demonstrating independent reading. (First: show a picture of a tapir so that this is understood.)
Recommended for aged 5 - 8
Carolyn Hull

Passenger by Alexandra Bracken

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9781460752043
(Age: 16+) Etta was 'Classical Music's Best Kept Secret.' She is an eighteen year old violinist set to make her debut on the concert scene. Her mother is also talented, but aloof.
'She's never going to care, no matter how much you kill yourself to be the best. Are you even playing for yourself any more, or just in the hope that one day she'll decide to listen.'
The reader may relate to the sacrifice needed to excel in your chosen field or the challenge of striving for the attention of a seemingly uninterested parent. Etta has sacrificed her social life and pleasures in life to be the best.
On the night of her debut her life knocked off track through an act of violence and revenge and Etta is transported to 1770. She meets Nicholas and together they race across time and space in the vain hope Etta can save her mother and make her way back to her home. From World War II London to Damascus in 1599 they encounter threats of violence and ruthless characters, while the extravagant descriptions of clothing and scenery show the reader travelogue across history.
Romance develops between Nicholas and Etta. The intensity of this relationship adds little to the story, and moves the recommended age to 16+.
Linda Guthrie

Everyone brave is forgiven by Chris Cleave

cover image

Sceptre, 2016. ISBN 9781473618701
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. When England declares war on Nazi Germany, Mary North - a privileged young woman from an influential family immediately offers her services to the War Office. Imagining a posting in espionage, she is surprised to find herself assigned a teaching role at a school in a poor area of London.
Education administrator Tom and art curator Alistair are best friends who share a comfortably disordered flat until Alistair enlists in the army and Tom is left feeling displaced and uneasy after the change of circumstance.
Mary and Tom are brought together by her posting and a relationship develops. Mary shows great character, throwing herself into her new role, doing her utmost to teach and care for the unwanted and disabled students left behind after their peers have been evacuated. Tom struggles with his civilian status living in a city being destroyed by endless bombing, whilst his best friend and most able bodied men are in the services, fighting the Germans.
During the Dunkirk evacuation, Alistair proved himself to be a highly competent Army officer who did his best to ensure the survival and welfare of his men. His world view is dramatically altered by the unimaginable violence of war and he feels uncomfortable and insecure when catching up with Tom when on leave - to meet his new girlfriend Mary and her best friend Dora.
The novel focuses closely on these characters and it is pleasing that the familiar theme of Blitz ravaged England, starved by U-boats and threatened by armies massing across the Channel, can once again form a first rate, interesting tale. Jazz culture is one aspect which is presented differently, with African American performers being treated abominably by society whose ignorance and galling arrogance produces a powerfully confronting style of racism.
Whilst this could be described as a romance, there is great depth in terms of drama and historical detail which should make this appeal to a wider readership. The war is seen to be a great leveller and when aristocratic pretensions are stripped away, decent, likeable and even heroic individuals emerge to do their best to help others traumatised by the conflict.
Similarly, the siege and bombing of Malta - so extreme that it might be considered bordering on exaggeration if it were not completely true, is presented with great attention to detail. The reader appreciates how brave and enduring the Maltese were in resisting an unending attack under almost impossible conditions and how close the allies came to losing the war.
This is an excellent book which suits readers 16+.
Rob Welsh

Introducing Teddy by Jessica Walton

cover image

Ill. by Dougal MacPherson. Bloomsbury Books, 2016. ISBN 9781408877630
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Transgender, Being yourself, Friendship, Acceptance. When Thomas the teddy is feeling low, his friend Errol asks him what the matter is. Thomas is usually happy to play and have picnics and go for rides on the bike or scratch around in the garden. Thomas is unsure of what to say and asks Errol to be his best friend no matter what he says.
Thomas reveals that he has never felt like a boy inside but feels like a girl. He would prefer his name to be Tilly. Errol hugs teddy to him, reassuring her that he likes her no matter what, they are still best friends, and Errol calls her Tilly.
Errol decides to call their friend, Ava to come and play. She comes over to the park where Errol introduces her to Tilly, and the two discuss their bows. Tilly no longer wears a bow tie, but uses it to tie her hair, while Ava discards her tie around her hair, wanting her hair to be free. They play all morning, doing the things they have always done, and later go home to play in the garden go for rides on the bike and when they plan a picnic call Ava to come over with her new friend, a robot she has built.
This is a wonderfully subtle story of inclusion, of remaining friends no matter how the circumstances change. Ava and Errol's acceptance of teddy's change of name is unconditional, they all remain friends no matter what happens. When Thomas becomes Tilly nothing changes between the group, Tilly simply states that she has never felt like a boy teddy and so now wishes to be known as Tilly not Thomas. Their friendship remains resolute.
It is also a tale of bravery, as teddy is concerned that when he tells Errol about his worry, Errol will no longer be his friend. Nothing is further from the truth. Errol's response is overwhelmingly positive and supportive, giving a model for others to follow which is reiterated when Ava joins them.
The mixed media illustrations are lovely, showing a young boy and his teddy doing the things mentioned in the text. They are inseparable, the crayon outlining the boy and his teddy against a spare background. I love the repetition of the activities at the start and end of the book, bringing the illustrations in a full circle, showing nothing has changed after teddy's announcement.
Both author and illustrator are from Melbourne, the transgender theme close to the author's heart and this book will become a book of choice when discussions arise at home and in the classroom about issues of gender.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: There is a Friendship Activity pack available.

Mutant rising by Steve Feasey

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408855720
(Age: 15+) Recommended. This book follows on from the first novel Mutant City.
Scorched Earth: 'Grey. The place hadn't always been so; once it must have been a multitude of colours and lights, but not any longer. Now everything was grey and lifeless.'
This is a story about five mutants: Rush, telekinetic; Anya, shapeshifter; Jax, mind reader; Flea, time-stopper; and Brick, healer. They are honing their skills and learning to use them to defend Scorched earth from the evil government of President Melk. They are evading capture and are in hiding.
The Pure who are living well in the Cities and are oblivious to President Melk's resolution to the 'mutant problem'. There are interesting comparisons to be made here with the holocaust and the role of bystanders. Further discussions around the decisions to stay or go/fight or retreat lead the reader to compare moments in this book with events in history.
'Although a long time had passed since the exodus, the memories of so many Mutes leaving the Blacklands to find 'a better place' still played on the minds of many who had chosen to stay behind'.
This book is an action-packed thriller. The violence is strong and the betrayals are devastating. Anya presents an opportunity to consider the consequences of emotions overpowering rational thought and the power of the desire for vengeance. The writing is strong and the scenes ready for translation into the movie version of this book.
Linda Guthrie

The Wolf Wilder by Katherine Rundell

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408872352
(Years: 8-10) Themes: Wolf behaviour; Friendship; Injustice; Alliances; Scheming; Family bonds; Destiny. Set in the western wilds of Russia a hundred years ago this novel tells the story of Feo (Feodora) and her mother who tend to wild wolves. It is tend and not train as wolves are their own masters.
Many of the aristocrats of the time like to keep the wolves as pets but when this does not work out they are sent to Feo and her mother for rehabilitation back into the wilds. Their neighbours do not like this practice as the wolves threaten their livelihood by eating wildlife that will be their food for the winter.
The army intervenes and threatens Feo and her mother that if they continue to care for the wolves then there will be consequences. A watch is put on their house and eventually Feo's mother is taken to St Petersburg for 'questioning'.
The guard who was sent to watch their house was a young boy who deserts the army to travel to St Petersburg to help Feo find her mother.
Thus begins an adventure involving the new friendship and alliances made along the way.
Wendy Rutten
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available.

Crenshaw by Katherine Applegate

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780007951185
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Crenshaw is a cat, a large black and white cat who just happens to be Jackson's imaginary friend. Jackson's family has gone through some problems in the past and, as he is about to start year 5, the problems return. Mum and Dad don't have enough money, belongings are being sold and the family might have to live in the family minivan for awhile. Crenshaw appears when Jackson needs a friend. Jackson doesn't need to keep secrets from Crenshaw because Crenshaw already knows. Crenshaw understands. It is this friendship that supports Jackson as the eldest child who wants to know the problems and not be kept in the dark. Crenshaw helps Jackson talk to friends so that he doesn't feel alone. Crenshaw helps Jackson talk to his parents. Maybe the family will be okay after all.
Crenshaw consists of 2 to 3 page chapters, making it fast moving but not allowing it to lose the descriptions needed to help readers connect with Jackson and his problems. It is an emotional story of friendship and heartbreak, of loving families and good things coming to good people. Children will connect with Jackson and his desire to be seen as old enough to handle the truth and the problems. Highly recommended for readers aged 9+, this book would make a great class novel, supporting students to understand the structure of imaginative texts as well as supporting them in writing about themselves. It would also be a great book for a parent to read to their child as some sensitive themes could be close to home for some children.
Kylie Kempster

Fizzlebert Stump: the boy who did PE in his pants by A.F. Harrold

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408853399
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Fizzlebert Stump is a fun read and will engage readers with its quick wit and comedic events. Fizzlebert Stump is part of the circus and is learning to be a strongman. He finds himself lost in the woods after his parents accidentally leave without him. Fizzlebert is mistaken for a girl, mistreated by a very mean teacher and trapped in a net. He tries to escape but is unsuccessful. Meanwhile, a nasty girl named Piltdown is impersonating him at the circus and causing all sorts of bother. Will Mr and Mrs Stump realise they have the wrong child? How will Fizzlebert get home? What do freckles have to do with it all?
This book is highly recommended to readers aged 8+. The author has created a descriptive and eventful tale all the while conversing with the audience. This interaction makes it twice as hilarious as the author loves keeping the readers in suspense and readers will not be able to wait to get to the end.
Kylie Kempster

The dog, Ray by Linda Coggin

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471403194
(Years: 7-9) Bereavement. Grief. Reincarnation. Friendship. New beginnings. Homelessness. Family separation. Daisy is involved in a car crash with her father and dies as a consequence. When she reaches heaven she takes a wrong turn and is reincarnated as a dog with her old memories.
During her initial few months she copes with confusion and frustration as she tries to make contact with her parents who, obviously, do not recognise her. She meets a homeless boy, Pip, and they become friends and begin on a journey to find Pip's father.
It is a heart-warming story about love, loss, friendships and new beginnings.
The language is easy to read and sensitive in nature.
Wendy Rutten

Twenty questions for Gloria by Martyn Bedford

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406363531
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Thriller, Running away. Twenty questions make up the chapter headings as we sit in on a police interview. DC Ryan is talking with fifteen year old Gloria, missing for nearly two weeks with a boy of the same age from her school. Her mother is also in the room. Initially disdainful, even rude, Gloria answers DC Ryan's questions briefly, needing further questioning to draw out more exact answers. Reticent Gloria cannot tell why they ran away, but over the several days reveals how their relationship began and proceeded. Uman from a private school came to live with his grandmother after his family's death from a deliberately lit house fire. He is witty and urbane, clever and impulsive, thoughtful and thought provoking. Gloria has not seen anyone like him, his disdain for the conventions of school, his ability to see that she is bored and unsettled with her life. He questions her ideas, her beliefs about life, her dissatisfaction. Intrigued, she becomes drawn to him. From there they decide to run away, she thinking it for only a night or two, but as they become more engrossed with each other, time away stretches into weeks.
Their idea of freedom grows as well: they throw away their mobile phones and decide to go somewhere 'happy', a holiday place known to Gloria from family trips in the past. They thread their way towards Penzance, but find themselves out of money. Here Uman is attacked by a group of drunk men and they end up in hospital, but leave before Uman is ready. Their attempt to follow their dream starts to unravel.
The story gives a clear idea of what motivates both children, although Gloria's parents and the police officer find it hard to forgive Uman and constantly give hints that Uman had a motive of which Gloria was unaware.
This is a page turner, a thriller, the reader wanting to know how they survived on the run, what Uman wanted and where he is now. The bald questioning by DC Ryan contrasts with the flow of the narrative as Gloria tries to convince the police officer and her mother, and even herself, of why they did it. At first she appears to be a very selfish young girl, but over the length of the novel, the reader is drawn to both characters as they learn more about them and their relationship in what is a most engrossing read.
Fran Knight

Under water by Marisa Reichardt

cover image

Macmillan 2016. ISBN 9781509818006
(Age: Teens) Highly recommended. Themes: Post-traumatic stress, School shootings, Psychology, Family breakdown, love. Living in a small apartment with her mother and little brother, Morgan was like any other Californian 17 year old, keen on swimming, boys and hanging out at the beach with a few close friends. However a mass shooting at her school six months before has left her uninjured but traumatised and she is now unable to leave her apartment. Life has been tough for the family, her father, a soldier, served multiple tours of duty in Afghanistan and post-traumatic stress has led him to seek solace in alcohol with resulting violent outbursts. Morgan's mother left him for the sake of the family's safety and she now works hard as a single mother to make ends meet. Morgan knows she is further burdening her mother but is powerless to control her fear of leaving the apartment and she carries a secret guilt that she has told nobody. Brenda, a psychologist, comes to the apartment to help Morgan deal with the trauma. Her comparison with how a child learns to do things helps Morgan realise that she needs to take baby steps to work though her problems. She sets herself the goal of attending little brother Ben's pantomime performance and when surfer Evan moves in next door and persists in getting to know her, Morgan has the incentives she needs to face her fears and work through the trauma.
This first novel is beautifully crafted, the characters live in a real world with familiar problems and the dialogue is well handled. Fundamentals of guilt and forgiveness are attractively wrapped in a love story with a brave protagonist caught up in life events that allow her to discover her inner strength. Year 10 girls will love this book and either fall in love with the boyfriend or decide on a career as a psychologist.
Sue Speck

Out of the ice by Ann Turner

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2016. ISBN 9781925030891
(Age: 16+) Recommended. Thriller. Antarctica. Friendship. Women. Viruses. Laura Alvarado is an environmental scientist based in the Antarctic. When she is sent to a remote area to report whether Fredelighavn, an abandoned whaling station, could be used for tourism or stay as a pristine environment for the wildlife, she finds disturbing evidence that it is being misused and the wildlife behaving strangely. When the normally placid penguins and seals attack, Laura knows that someone has been interfering with their way of life. On a dive at the station with her friend Sara, she glimpses a young boy screaming for help through the ice and as more and more strange things begin to happen she finds herself in danger. What is going on at the Research Station? Why is she seeing eerie things and being shunned by the scientists at the base?
This is a tense and engrossing thriller and the setting of the ice of Antarctica sets it apart immediately. The reader is swept into the life of people living in its cold environment, and the initial chapters describing the animal life, the penguins, seals and whales give a fabulous background to the thrilling story as the suspense unfolds. Fredelighavn, an abandoned whaling station is depicted in great detail. The Norwegian buildings, portraits of the people who lived there, the Scandavian furniture and even an abandoned cinema, are all brought to life against the background of the terrible slaughter of the whales that were the mainstay of the settlement.
Although Laura could perhaps be 'toasty', a condition of seeing things after spending too much time in Antactica, she is a strong and determined woman, who rationally analyses what has happened and is convinced that she has seen a young boy screaming for help. With the assistance of her friend Sara and boss Georgia, a detective stationed nearby, they investigate Fredelighavn. Continuing the search, Laura goes to Nantucket, pursuing the elusive scientist Snow and uncovers more of the mysteries surrounding the abandoned whaling station.
There are many questions for the reader to pursue, including the theme of strong women in a predominantly male environment, the strength of friendship and the preservation of wildlife. Add these to exciting action, suspense, some very unexpected twists and turns and moments of heartbreak and the reader is in for a real treat. I will certainly be picking up any more books by Ann Turner.
Pat Pledger

Grayling's song by Karen Cushman

cover image

Clarion Books, 2016. ISBN 9780544301801
(Age: 10-13) Recommended. Fantasy. Magic. Adventure. Self-confidence. Middle Ages. Grayling is horrified when her mother, wise woman Hannah Strong, starts turning into a tree, 'her feet rooted into the earth. What had been toes were now spreading roots, and what had been soft skin was as rough and brown as a tree trunk'. Her mother sends her off on a quest to find 'the others' who she says will help Grayling retrieve her grimoire and break the spell. Grayling is a shy girl, but is determined to rescue her mother and gradually finds the others, a motley assortment of minor witches, who were not strong enough to gain the attention of the evil being who is turning all wise people into trees and stealing their grimoires. Assisted by a talking, shape shifting mouse named Pook, Grayling becomes the leader of the group and faces kidnapping, imprisonment, tiredness, and the strain of travelling with strange companions.
A compelling coming of age story finds Grayling, away from the influence of her strong willed mother, taking charge and finding the strength of character and determination to follow her quest to regain the grimoires and rescue those turned into trees. Cushman, who won a Newbery Medal for her wonderful novel, The midwife's apprentice, brings the alternative medieval period to life with vivid and lyrical prose. As she recounts in her fascinating notes at the conclusion of the story, the Middle Ages were a time when wise women, wise men or those commonly known as hedge witches, used herbal potions and made prophecies.
As well as some exciting adventures, when Grayling must use all her wits and courage to keep going, there are many moments of humour as the companions learn to travel together. Each of the characters, from Auld Nancy to Pansy, are fully developed, with their own funny idiosyncrasies, and strengths and weaknesses while Pook, the little mouse, is a delightful creature that readers are sure to love. A slight hint of romance with the young paper maker is also a welcome touch.
This delightful coming of age story, with its themes of courage and determination, of gaining self confidence and finding ways to be a leader, will appeal to middle school students and all who enjoy historical fantasy.
Pat Pledger