Reviews

Coffin Road by Peter May

cover image

Quercus, 2016. ISBN 9781784293093
(Age: Senior secondary to adult) Highly recommended. Crime fiction, Scotland, Bees. Washed ashore on the island of Harris, a man has no idea of who he is or why he is where he is. He can recall being in the sea and knows that he has a head wound, but beyond that, nothing. He struggles up the beach and heads towards a cluster of houses, and realises that one is his. Here he searches the place for some clue of his identity and finds nothing. A woman who comes into his house and later into his bed, obviously knows him intimately and when they follow the dog the next day up the hills from his house, they stumble over a group of beehives. He finds small pieces of information grabbing his attention but none is able to create a proper memory of who he is and why he is there.
When a body is discovered on the island off shore, an island he has been seen at, DS Gunn takes him in for questioning, but he stalls, not willing to say that he has no memory. Meanwhile in Edinburgh, a young girl works out that her father, believed to have suicided two years ago, is alive and sets out to search for him. She knows that his research student is near Harris and thinks she may be able to find her father through him. Along the way she meets her father's old friend who tells her about the research that her father was involved with before his 'suicide'. He and several others were researching the effect of neonicotinoids used in crop sprays upon the bee populations around the world, linking their decline to the effect of these sprays on their memories. Without remembering where to find pollen, the bees die, which means that the pollination of our major food sources will not occur and so we will die.
This research is being undermined by the global spray manufacturers and so several men, after losing their positions in laboratories funded by these companies, have decided to do the research in secret.
Karen in searching for her father stumbles into the secret research and so the strands come together, of Karen looking for her father, of the secret research, of the death on the island.
DS Gunn is a wonderful ploy to the amnesiac, asking questions, liking the man but aware that he could be a killer, giving him the opportunity to work things out. The exciting last chapter where all the threads come together on a bleak night off Harris, is mesmerising as May's description of the weather and the surrounds grabs attention. His presenting of the theme of the suppression of data by big companies is mind boggling, and a short trawl using Google will add to the readers' knowledge.
Fran Knight

This is where the world ends by Amy Zhang

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780062417879
(Age: 14+) This is where the world ends by Amy Zhang is a vibrant and brilliant novel full to the brim with relatable emotions and situations. Although the novel has some more sombre themes to it, there are many aspects of this book that speak to teens and how they are coping with everyday life and any tragedy within their lives. It is a story about Janie and Micah and their nearly opposite personalities. They are best friends and have been since they were children, even as they grew up and apart, they still had a strong connection to each other.
The story is not set in the traditional linear fashion of novels, but rather, each character tells the sad story from their own stance in the timeline, all to unravel the truth of what really happened one deep dark night (just like in the setting of one of Janie's fairytales) and the outcome of such a sad event. The story line of the novel follows both Janie and Micah in their everyday experiences separate to each other at school and at home and includes their inner-monologues and thoughts about themselves and each other. Amy Zhang has included another way of telling the thrilling and powerful story by including excerpts from The Journal of Janie Vivian. These pages include drawings and designs relevant to the character and display another means of character expression throughout the novel.
This book would be better suited to readers 14+ due to sexual and violent themes found within the story.
This is where the world ends is a strong and fierce novel that captivates readers, relates to readers and gives them another perspective on life through the collective eyes of Janie and Micah, two very strong and memorable characters.
Sarah Filkin

The mystery of the clockwork sparrow by Katherine Woodfine

cover image

The mystery of the clockwork sparrow bk. 1. Egmont, 2015. ISBN 9781405276177
(Age: 11-14) Recommended. Mystery. Thriller. Fabulous for fans of mysteries and adventure this sparkling story set in the beautiful rooms of a gorgeous new department store will tantalise with its plucky heroines, brave young boys and evil villains. Sophie and Lil both work in Sinclair's which is going to open with a grand fanfare and a wonderful collection of jewellery and artifacts, including a clockwork sparrow that plays tunes at random. When it is stolen, suspicion falls on Sophie and with her friends Lil, Billy and Joe, she sets out to find who has stolen it.
This is a ripping adventure story, with some breathtaking moments as the four friends face the most dastardly villains in London. The setting of the Edwardian store Sinclair's, with its clothing departments and restaurants, courtyards and basements, provides a grand background for the youthful sleuths to track down clues and face enormous danger.
This is a fun and compelling read, and is sure to please readers who want some excitement and adventure in their reading or those who enjoyed Murder most unladylike by Robin Stevens. It is followed by The mystery of the jewelled moth, and I am sure our intrepid detectives will once again face the danger of the criminal underbelly of London.
Pat Pledger

Introducing Teddy: A story about being yourself by Jessica Walton

cover image

Ill. by Dougal MacPherson. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781681192116
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Diversity. Gender identity. Young Errol's life is filled with enjoyment, together with his best friend Thomas the teddy, they ride their bike, plant vegetables and share lunch in the tree house. One sunny day Errol wakes up ready for another play-filled day. Thomas, however, is feeling very sad, and even swinging at the park doesn't help.
Errol and his teddy, Thomas, are best friends who do everything together. Whether it's riding a bike, playing in the tree house, having a tea party, every day is enjoyable. The mood changes when the teddy gathers enough courage to share his deepest feelings. 'In my heart, I've always known that I'm a girl teddy, not a boy teddy. I wish my name was Tilly, not Thomas.' Errol's heartwarming response is one of acceptance, he just wants his teddy to continue to share playtimes together and continue to be his best friend.
Author Jessica Walton's easy to read narrative was written from her personal family experiences. Her father transitioned into becoming Tina, and she saw the need of writing a story to help her young son develop an understanding of gender identity and the process of transitioning. Dougal MacPherson's ink-and-watercolour illustrations are emotionally engaging, the stark grey playground asphalt adds to the mood of the story. The teddy's transformation cleverly drawn with the bow-tie transitioning into a hair bow. Light and shade, the important use of white space, background washes of blue and yellow draw the eye to focus on the engaging Errol, Thomas/Tilly and their friend Ava at play.
Accepting diversity and gender identity are the key messages in Introducing Teddy.
Rhyllis Bignell
Editor's note: There is a Friendship Activity pack available.

The truth according to Arthur : a book about fibbing by Tim Hopgood

cover image

Ill. by David Tazzyman. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408864999
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Lying, Honesty, Accidents. With the sub title, a book about fibbing the reader knows from the start that this book will be educative. But it does so in a highly entertaining way. At first a little reluctant to read a didactic tome, I was surprised at the way the story is presented and the illustrations serve a level of humour which is infectious, and the layout of the book, with its different sized fonts, made the reading a pleasure.
Arthur has ridden his brother's bike, something he has been told not to do, and as a result, scratched his parents' car and damaged the bike. He is at a loss to decide what to do. He practises many stories on his friends: he tries bending the truth, and stretching the truth, of hiding the truth or just ignoring it. Each attempt at not telling the truth leads him to another mess which is not believed by his friends. The truth, a gray blob that accompanies him but is often ignored, stands by him, reminding him of what he should do. When the time comes he owns up to what he has done, and now the truth and Arthur are the best of friends. Mum's predicted response was not what he expected and telling the truth gained him admiration not punishment.
The line and colour wash illustrations are deceptively simple, adding humour to the story. Readers will laugh out loud at the consequences of Arthur's attempts at distorting the truth, recognising their own efforts at covering their tracks. This book will initiate much discussion within classes and with children at home.
Fran Knight

Remade by Alex Scarrow

cover image

Macmillan, 2016. ISBN 9781509811205
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. 'It hasn't liquefied all of this person yet.'
This book is a real seat of the pants ride through the unthinkable.
'Replication was the highest priority. Very soon it had 'fathered' a copy of itself, and now both of them were working hard on replicating again.'
Are you intrigued?
'He poured out his Weetos and drenched them in milk, little realising that this was going to be the last 'normal' breakfast time he was ever going to experience.'
Alex Scarrow has crafted a book that has the reader compulsively turning the pages, hoping that what looks to be happening will somehow not happen on the next page. The writing creates an atmosphere of tension, dread and horror that make this book impossible to put down.
The scene is a previously unidentified virus erupting in several locations across the world at the same time, and then taking hold of the planet. At each stage the reader is lead to feel hope that disaster will be averted.
What sets this book apart from others is Scarrow's skill in expertly releasing this virus into the world. The story unfolds in such a believable way, the reader can feel as if this event is actually unfolding. The scenes between Leo, his younger sister Grace and their father are poignant. Despite the distance that separates them, there is an overwhelming drive to help each other. Leo's courage in taking on the virus and working to save his family has the reader urging them on to safety.
This is not a book to read right before going to sleep, and haunts the reader well after the book has closed for the last time.
Linda Guthrie

A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare, rewritten by Terry Deary

cover image

Shakespeare Tales series. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472917775
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Shakespeare, Elizabethan times. As with Macbeth, this story is told through the eyes of Molly, a servant with a troupe of players who tour England presenting Shakespeare's plays to whatever audience comes along. One of the actors, Richard Armin, is the fool employed in many of the plays. Molly tells us that Shakespeare even wrote comic scenes in some of the sadder plays to include Armin. But she and Armin do not like each other and he treats her badly.
The background tale of Molly and her place within the troupe is lively and informative and will give readers an idea of just how children their age survived in these perilous times. This book is set in a Nottingham Market and readers will see for themselves the lifestyles of the people in the town in Elizabethan times.
Against Molly's story is that of A Midsummer Night's Dream, with a precis of the play given between Molly's tale. Deary gives the reader a brief but satisfyingly ample outline of the tale with the fairy Oberon making his wife love the first person she sees when she wakes after being given a love potion. The comedy has her seeing a donkey while the other characters, Hermia, Demetrius, Helena and Lysander are also given the love potion and much confusion arises as two of these people are supposed to marry each other and two are planning to elope. Confusion ensues from all directions, but is it all a dream?
The series of books now includes four plays, Macbeth, A Midsummer Night's Dream, Romeo and Juliet and Twelfth Night, designed to bring Shakespeare to a new audience.
Fran Knight

Fenn Halflin and the Fearzero by Francesca Armour-Chelu

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406363128
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. In Fenn Halflin's world, the sea has been taking over for as long as he has been alive and before. The landborn, who are lead by Terra Firma, hunt and banish the seaborn from the land, keeping the safe, land areas for themselves. They kidnap children to be slaves and to build walls around the land. Fenn is 13 and has been hidden by his grandfather, hidden from Terra Firma who are always looking for boys. Unknown to Fenn, he is the lost child of two resistance leaders who were killed by Terra Firma. One night, the warship is seen and Fenn's grandfather organises for Fenn to leave. They are separated. Fenn is smuggled out on a ship but halfway through the journey, fear encourages the captain to abandon Fenn in a shanty town located in the middle of the sea and from which, escape is impossible. Will Fenn and his new friend escape this place of despair. A place where food is scarce and you have to fight to survive.
Fenn Halflin and the Fearzero is the first in a series about the end of the world. The heroes are all children, showing readers you can make changes and be brave no matter your age. The writing is suspenseful in places, making it highly engaging. The author uses descriptive writing to immerse the reader in the happenings in this watery and scary world. Highly recommended for boys aged 10+ but anyone who likes an adventure story will definitely be hanging out for the next instalment.
Kylie Kempster

Macbeth by William Shakespeare, rewritten by Terry Deary

cover image

Shakespeare Tales series. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472917805
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Shakespeare, Macbeth, Elizabethan times. In this lively series, a character is introduced who becomes a narrator presenting the play within the confines of that person's life and times. With Macbeth we meet potgirl, Mary as she cleans up the blood on the stage after another performance of Macbeth. She tells us about the pig's blood used for the killing scenes, and between her talk about her life and work, the author presents the play.
Mary is a sympathetic character, a young girl taken into the harsh service of a tavern owner, a person who treats her badly, yelling at her in front of customers, beating her when she does things wrong, and paying her very little. She must take the jug of ale around to the customers while they stand in the yard watching the play, and she learns the play well. She talks to some of the actors, showing the reader how these men exist going form town to town, and she meets William Shakespeare. After one particularly nasty scolding from her employer she hides in one of the stage baskets and gets away, joining the troupe.
All the while the play is going on, and we read a summary of the plot and characters in text designed for the younger reader. The story is well written for a younger audience and the series will add to the growing interest in Shakespeare's plays for this audience. At the end of each book is given several pages of lively information about the play.
Fran Knight

Circle by Jeannie Baker

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406338010
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Natural world. Birds. Inter relationship. Environment. The circle of life is reprised on every page in this beautiful new book from illustrator/author Jennie Baker. Her story of the godwits, the birds which amazingly wing their way from Alaska to Australia and back each year, will stun the readers. The story itself is a powerful reminder that we are all interrelated, that what humans do has an impact upon the rest of the planet, and from the perspective of this one small bird, that our interference with the coastline seriously degrades their habitat. Linked with her glorious collage illustrations the book reflects the environment in which we all live and makes a spine tingling imperative that we do much more to protect it.
The life cycle of the godwit is shown through one bird, one with white splashes on his wings, and we follow him throughout the book. He flies from Alaska to Australia, a journey of 11,000 kilometres and on the return journey he finds a mate, they build a nest together and raise their chicks. Each arm of their journey is fraught with danger as their environment is degraded, places they once stopped to rest are gone, buildings dot the coastlines, land clearance has put their feeding places at risk and foxes search for their chicks.
Every page greets the inquiring reader, intriguing them with hints of just how each picture is made, astonishing them with information about this amazing bird, revealing just how we have made the environment so difficult for these birds to survive. Each page impels the reader to stop and think about why our earth is now in such great peril. Our interconnection is repeated throughout the book, no reader can miss the powerful message being offered.
The circle motif is repeated throughout the book with the curvature of the earth shown in many of the illustrations. The reader cannot escape the image of the reserve where the boy watches the birds at the beginning of the book, compared with the reserve at the end: degraded, overused, with industry encroaching on its borders. Readers will easily spot the impact of man on this environment, the lights of the city seen from on high as the birds fly north, the increasing rubbish seen on the beach, the degradation of the waterfront, the number of buildings seen in the background, planes in the sky. Further inspection of each wonderful image will enhance the readers' interpretation and awe. And readers will ponder the image of the boy, at first disabled and in a wheelchair, dreaming of flying, at the end leaving his crutches behind and running onto the beach, and later still dreaming of flying with his crutches beneath his bed. The bird and the boy have been on impressive journeys, causing the reader to stop and speculate on each of them, and wondering how the boy, a bird watcher, can use his knowledge to make a change. This book throws the question back on the reader, and will create much discussion in classrooms and libraries.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available at the publisher's website.

Flawed by Cecelia Ahern

cover image

Harper Collins 2016. ISBN 9780008126360
(Age: 14+) Is there anything worse than imperfection? In a world that champions perfection should your flaws be laid bare for the world to see? With a system that is inherently flawed - how can it be overthrown? From within? Or from without, could the Flawed rise up and begin a revolution? How? Who would lead them?
When the system fails and you become the most flawed person in existence what do you do? Sentenced to five brands (foot, hand, heart, head, and tongue) for the simple act of compassion towards another human being, Celestine North finds herself the reluctant emblem of a revolution she never had any intention of fighting. She put her trust in one man, her boyfriend's father, Judge Crevan. A fearsome man, but a man just the same. With Crevan and her family pressuring her to lie in the courts when she is on trial for being flawed, Celestine begins to question a system that would judge her flawed for simply helping an old, sick man who just happened to be flawed. Even though he was flawed, he, like Judge Crevan, was just a man. For her compassion and her honesty Celestine's life is forever changed - she can never go back to her life of utter perfection. Her dreams, her plans, and her future are all ruined-forever.
Sitting in the same class as Veronica Roth's Divergent series, Flawed is certainly recommended for girls aged fourteen and up who like dystopians. While the first few chapters are questionable, the book improves and mellows out into an easy read with a great and terrifying concept. Certainly something to make the reader appreciate our society.
Kayla Gaskell (University student)

The girl who raced Fairyland all the way home by Catherynne M. Valente

cover image

Atom, 2016. ISBN 9781472112835
Recommended for fantasy lovers. Fantasy. Adventure. Fairies. Magical world. This is unlike anything I have read before, although there is an essence of Alice and a looking-glass world, a hint of a crossover with a Wardrobe world, and a dose of psychedelic fairy-tale adventure within its idiosyncratic style. My desire is to write a review that reveals a little of the cloudburst that has occurred within me as I read. This is a book with a magical maelstrom of characters that are woven in a kaleidoscope of fantasy magic, adventure and mystery, mixed with a pandemic of inscrutability. The windstorm of characterisation of features and follies is at first very difficult to follow, and the ultimate fantasy 'Race' to sort out who deserves to be the current reigning Royal takes the reader to places that no one knows or can fathom. The confusion of plot and characters at first floored this reader - it was hard to create a mental image of all that was exploding onto the page in this unique fantasy creation. However the idiosyncrasies and inherent humour of the language used, and the quirks of expression were so unique that they had an irresistible charm that created a desire to keep reading. (I am not so sure that this would be enough for some younger readers, who would find the worlds and wordsmithery confusing.) Note the following early descriptive example to describe the world in which we find the central character, September.
'A vast and hungry country takes tea somewhat differently than you and I. Fairyland's teatime consisted of a dollop of rain in the Autumn Provinces, a particular delicate icing of clouds over the Painted Forest, a healthy squeeze of blazing sun in the Hourglass Desert, and a fresh, green wind blowing wild through the streets and alleyways and secret corners of Pandemonium.' (p2)
The winner in this incredibly unique telling is the language use; metaphor, simile, word-play, personification and a general licking of alliteration at every turn. The characters are also given exceptional features, costumes and skills by the author Valente, who obviously has a very verdant imagination. Each chapter has a Dickens-like preamble to guide the reader into the next panoply of wonder.
This can be recommended to those who love fantasy deeply, but who also are inspired by words and wordplay. It might be confusing for those who lack persistence or who devour books in small bites! This is the last of the Fairyland series... but the first I have read. It may be that those who already love this world would not be as likely to be confused.
Carolyn Hull

Fizz and the dog academy rescue by Lesley Gibbes

cover image

Ill. by Stephen Michael King. Fizz series. Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760112844
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Dogs. Police. A second book in this wonderful new series about Fizz the police dog, see the animals at their training academy. Gibbes has fun having the dogs arrive in vehicles which bely their size and breed. They are first checked over by a vet and here we see that Amadeus, the burly German Shepherd is still as dictatorial and rude as ever.
At the academy they are given tasks to achieve and as the story proceeds, it is obvious that someone is sabotaging their efforts. The balance bean collapses, trapping Apollo beneath it and he must go to the clinic for help. But the teeth marks on the beam seem to impel Fizz into action as he puts all of his skills into place to suss out the saboteur. He amasses a number of clues before he is able to expose the problem and a funny conclusion is reached which will surprise the reader.
Again the humour is evident as Amadeus is up to his old tricks of belittling the other dogs, while Fizz is able to make friends with some new faces. Kings's illustrations are a treat, giving an image for readers to concentrate on as they read, and giving another level of humour for children to laugh at.
These will be sought after in schools, libraries and bookshops, and another two are available as well, Fizz and the show dog jewel thief, and Fizz and the handbag dognapper. With short, easy to read chapters and a contents page, these will be a hit with new readers.
Fran Knight

Fizz and the police dog tryouts by Lesley Gibbes

cover image

Ill. by Stephen Michael King. Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760112851
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Dogs. Police. Employment. A laugh out loud story of Fizz, desperate to be a police dog, and help with the running down and capture of criminals, but hampered by his breed. He is a fluffy little lap dog, destined like his parents and siblings to be a show dog or a companion dog, not a working dog like the bigger dogs, Rottweilers and German Shepherds. He is booked in to see Ms Trunchon from the Dog Employment Agency and is determined not to go.
His friend, Tom suggests he go along to the police dog tryouts the next day, so determined and bold, he goes. He is astonished to find that many dogs have lined up at the gates, and all very different from him. There are German Shepherds and Rottweilers, Bulldogs and Labradors, all large and powerful and some full of bravado.
One German Shepherd, Amadeus, the son of a police dog, bullies other dogs around him to ensure that he wins the competitions.
Three tests are given to the dogs and as each fails the test, so they are told to go home. The tension is palpable and despite Amadeus and his entourage baiting Fizz, calling him names and belittling him, he carries on. Readers will be surprised that he does not win the main competition but relieved when he is taken along to be a different sort of police dog, one where his skills can be put to better use.
This is a lovely opener to a new series about Fizz, leading the reader into the scenario where he is a police dog, working with the police to sniff out crimes and criminals. The series has a lot which will endear it to a readership as it promotes standing up for oneself, working for a goal that everyone says is beyond you and standing up to bullying. All the elements are there for a successful series of books, and Fizz is a delightful character with many other minor characters just as endearing. King's lovely illustrations add to the humour of the tale, as each dog is given their own characteristics, and Sergeant Stern is a treat. King obviously enjoyed adding to the humour of the book through his illustrations and they suit the story admirably.
It's great to see an early chapter book series with a contents page and short, easy to read chapters, just right for newly arrived readers.
Fran Knight

Thanks for the trouble by Tommy Wallach

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2016. ISBN 9781471146121
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. 'Take stealing, for example. My Dad taught me that our society punishes people who only steal a little, but it rewards people who steal a lot.'
Parker Sante is a creative spirit who doesn't speak. He writes. He truants school and spends his time in the foyers of hotels. He watches guests and steals.
The day he meets a silver haired girl his life changes forever. She thinks he has a 'deranged form of graphomania' and he thinks Zelda is throwing her life away.
'Well, I'll make you a deal. I'll go to college if you don't jump off the Golden Gate Bridge.'
Would you want to live forever? This book explores the compromises made when life is without end, contrasting this with a life not lived, but avoided.
'Young people feel things so deeply, don't they?' she said quietly, almost to herself. 'Everything's happening for the first time.'
These two well developed and engaging characters affect each other deeply, but the life of only one of them will be transformed. The short stories written by Parker add another layer of depth to an already intriguing narrative. Is Zelda who she says she is? Can you ever become tired of life? There is an exploration of friendship that reveals many home truths and quiet understandings about the nature of humans and the grace of kindness.
Wallach has created scenarios that resonate with the world of the young adults and reinforces the value of believing in and remaining true to yourself.
Linda Guthrie