Reviews

The Legends series by Michael Panckridge

cover image

Ford St, 2016.
Chasing the break. ISBN 9781925272482
Against the spin. ISBN 9781925272499
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Sports. School. With the upper primary reading group such a hard batch to satisfy with good books, it is great to see the republishing of Michael Panckridge's exciting series, The Legends. This is most welcome, with the series repackaged with an up to date cover and blurb, designed to appeal to this difficult group of the reading public. Each of the eight novels in The Legends series are very school based using day to day encounters to develop the plots, involving sports which are part of the school's competitions.
Chasing the break involves a surfing competition at Sandhurst Primary School. One boy, Travis Fisk, won the competition at last year's annual beach camp and intends to win again, but he is challenged by the new boy at school, Mitchell Grady. Told in short, easy to read chapters, the characters are well developed and identifiable, and the integrity underlining the story is easily in reach of every reader. They will cheer the hero as he strives to win despite the odds, overcoming the antagonism of the antihero of the story.
Against the spin has a similar plot line, with Travis nursing his wounds and Mitchell shining on the cricket field as well. But this involves more of Travis' undesirable bullying coming to the fore, and Mitchell and his friends having to deal with his antics both on and off the sporting field.
Exciting, fast paced and easy to read, each of these stories is about one hundred pages long with scores and quizzes at the end for further excitement. The whole set will rarely be left on the shelf.
Fran Knight

Animalia by Graeme Base

cover image

Penguin, 2016. ISBN 9780670079131
Thirty years ago in 1986 an armoured armadillo avoiding an angry alligator appeared from the pen of one of Australia's most iconic illustrators. It was followed by beautiful blue butterflies basking by a babbling brook and a host of other creatures including eight enormous elephants expertly eating Easter eggs; horrible hairy hogs hurrying homeward on heavily harnessed horses; meticulous mice monitoring mysterious mathematical messages; and even zany sabras zigzagging in zinc zeppelins.
For this was the magical, mystical, marvellous Animalia - an alliterative alphabet book and which, after selling more than three million copies worldwide and spawning a television series, is now celebrating its 30th birthday and a whole new audience is set to wonder at its creativity, its detail, its colour and try to spot the tiny Graeme on each page. It is indeed a feast of vivid visual literacy. And underneath the familiar dust cover which so cleverly hints at what is inside is a glamorous golden cover AND a fabulous poster of the lazy lions lounging in the local library. (Great role models for reading!!!)
Since Animalia's original publication we have come to associate Graeme Base with intriguing stories woven around the most scintillating illustrations and if this is your first introduction to his work, you will be on the lookout for his other works.
Congratulations Graeme - thank you for bringing us these superb creatures and creating such riches for our young readers.
Barbara Braxton

His Bloody Project. Documents relating to the case of Roderick Macrae by Graeme Macrae Burnet

cover image

Text, 2016. ISBN 9781925498257
(Age: Capable senior students) Recommended. Shortlisted for the Man Booker prize 2016. His Bloody Project is clearly subtitled as a novel, which is a useful guide as the book has the authenticity of a historical investigation. It has also been described as a 'crime story', that is, a story about a crime and not a 'crime novel'. The text is comprised of a number of sets of documents, including reports from the crime scene, the accused's thoughts written in prison, an account from a psychiatrist engaged to assess the accused and press reports written during and after the trial. The accused is Roderick Macrae, the son of a poor crofter living in a remote village in the Scottish Highlands in 1869. The reader learns that Roderick, aged 16, has admitted to brutally murdering the constable of the village. The crime scene documents detail events seen by a number of villagers who are all shocked and some of whom are sympathetic to Roderick. They agree that he was seen walking to the constable's house with several agricultural implements and returning covered in blood. However, attitudes to the boy differ. The school teacher attests that Roderick was a clever student, a neighbour that he was treated too severely by his father, but the minister that he was wicked and retarded. Roderick's statement is written in gaol at the behest of his lawyer. The reader is given a clear picture of the hardship and deprivation that was part of Roderick's life, though Roderick does not acknowledge that his own circumstances are any more difficult than anyone else's. Roderick's father is a dour, punitive man who seems to accept and administer hardship with a religious zeal. He is a poor farmer and father, and sends Roderick to work for the laird despite the teacher recommending further education. Roderick is dismissed as unsuitable and so is unable to help with the family's finances. Motivation for the murder is provided when the constable harasses the family and finally deprives them of their land. Roderick's lawyer is moved by the statement and hoping for a verdict of insanity engages a psychiatrist. The psychiatrist's report illustrates the nature of psychiatry at that time more than the character of Roderick. Doctor Thompson is supposedly an expert in the criminal mind. He has no interest in Roderick himself and little in justice but rather is concerned with proving his own theories about the criminal physiognomy and the criminal class. He is unimpressed by Roddy's writing though to the reader it seems thoughtful and humble. Doctor Thompson travels to Roddy's village and reinforces his theories by categorizing the villagers as stereotypes of the lowest class. Finally, the newspaper accounts relay the trial and its unsurprising conclusion.
The book is convincing and is a disturbing look at poverty and victimisation. It also, with its use of multiple voices and viewpoints, powerfully illustrates the impossibility of truly understanding the minds of others. It is recommended for capable senior readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Three sisters, three queens by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781471133022
(Age: secondary) Recommended. English history, Tudors, Henry VIII, Status of women, Scottish history. When Katherine of Aragon comes to the Tudor court to marry Arthur, his younger sister, Margaret looks on with petulant disdain. This woman will be her sister in law, but Margaret is in no mood to be charitable. She will have to take second place to this foreigner who cannot speak English, and Margaret above all else, wants to be first.
However, she must be on her best behaviour at their wedding, as an ambassador is there to confirm her as the wife to be of James IV of Scotland. She is thrilled to be betrothed at twelve hardly able to wait until she marries at fourteen to be a queen.
Her younger sister, Mary is initially betrothed to the Spanish emperor, so the three sisters are to become queens and are all related through Henry. Katherine of Aragon becomes Queen of England when she marries Arthur's brother, the future Henry the Eighth, Margaret is Queen of Scotland and Mary, Queen of France, and their fictionalised lives make fascinating reading. Gregory's research is obvious in the huge amount of detail providing a solid background to these women's imagined lives. Details like James' metal belt worn next to his skin to remind him of his killing his father or Katherine's pregnancies and hair shirt, the progress made by the kings surveying their lands, the clothing and jewelry and extravagance of Henry's court are intoxicating. And the details of court behaviour, the differences between the three courts, the intrigues behind the decisions to declare war and the hapless lives of these women dependent upon the men in their lives, are absorbing to read. Margaret's petulance does not subside, she is ever comparing herself with the other queens, sometimes their solicitous friend, other times disgruntled and critical.
Her life going between Linlithgow, Holyrood, Edinburgh and Stirling Castles, carrying six children and losing all but one, is magnificently retold, ensuring the reader knows all there is to know about Margaret of Scotland and her part in the Stuart succession to the throne of England two generations hence.
She is self absorbed, but her life, always bound but her brother's ambition and political game playing, or that of her husbands and any people currying her favour, made her a more sympathetic creature, tossed around in a world where a woman's voice was seldom given credence.
A wonderful historical novel for those who love reading of Tudor times, and are particularly interested in the role of women in this society.
Fran Knight

Ida, always by Caron Levis

cover image

Ill. by Charles Santosa. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781742761909
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Polar bears, Zoos, Cities, Death and grieving, New York, Friendship. Based on the true story of two polar bears at New York's Central Park Zoo, this emotional story will have all readers sniffling by the end of the tale. Ida and Gus have lived a long while at the zoo, where they are seen by the many visitors, and are looked after by the keeper, Sonya.
The two bears wait for each other in the morning, ready to feed together, swim together, play with the ball, sit on their island and watch the city around them. They listen to its sounds, and watch the skyscrapers reach into the cloudy sky. They are inseparable, and always there to be with each other. But one day Ida does not appear, and Gus must do all the things they did together, by himself. Sonya comes to tell him that Ida is unwell, and so the keeper and Gus look after her, making sure she is comfortable and in no pain. They remember the things they did together, reminding each other that they will always be there, always. She eventually dies and Gus misses her, all alone doing the things they did together. But when he listen to the sounds of the city, he knows she is with him, always.
This wonderful story of death and grieving will have resonance for many children who have had a death in the family. They will recognise the process of death, some times knowing that it is imminent, and see the way people deal with the process of dying. They will see too that although that person has died, things live on to remind them of that person, there will be memories that keep that person alive.
The soft illustrations will entrance the younger readers who will look at the bears and their lives in the zoo with fresh eyes. They will see the images in the clouds, and the skyline of New York, the depiction of what these huge animals get up to in a zoo, and perhaps ponder how different their lives would be in the wild. This will be a lovely read aloud, but have the tissues handy.
Fran Knight

Space: Seek and find activity book ill. by Emiliano Magliardo

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408870037
(Age: 5-7) Recommended. Themes: Space; Seek and Find. This is a simple 'Seek and Find' concept book with a Space theme. Each double page contains a simple factual paragraph and then humourous cartoon-style illustrations which are crowded with fun and sometimes ridiculous detail for a young reader to search and investigate. A single text question on the featured page gives instructions for something to find, but also each double page includes 10 smaller pictures to locate from within the larger complex illustration.
Recommended - as a book to share with pre-readers or for early independent readers. It will fill those moments when adults need a bit of focused quiet time!
Carolyn Hull

An artist's alphabet by Norman Messenger

cover image

Walker Studio, 2016. ISBN 9781406346763
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Aptly named An artist's alphabet, the stunning illustrations make this a stand-out picture book. Ranging from drawings of fabulous animals, beautiful flowers and stylish buildings the reader is taken through the upper and lower case letters of the alphabet each on a double page spread. Starting with Aa, there is a wonderful acrobat standing on top of a horse and another curled up to make the small letter a. The illustrations for the letter Bb are a little more difficult to work out, but beetles and a butterfly can be seen. From this beginning the reader would expect to see a traditional alphabet book, with the pictures matching the letters - but this is not always so. When the page is turned to the letter Cc, beautiful waves are drawn, but the reader is left wondering how the waves represent a Cc. This trend continues throughout the book - a very round grey cat is on the Dd page, but the Gg page has subtly patterned goldfish. Hh is easy to identify with its wondrous multi-storied houses with archways and bridges, but the trees and tree trunk for Rr is much more difficult to work out.
The strange and fantastic drawings will also pull the individual into the wonderful world of the imagination, providing so many stimulating pictures that the reader will want to look at again and again, not just to try and work out the associations with the letters, but for their beauty and delicacy of colour. It is a book that begs to be shared with other people, leading to discussions of what the illustralions could refer to and coming up with different solutions.
This is a book that I can see becoming a classic, one that people who appreciate the surreal and beautiful will want to keep on their book shelves.
Pat Pledger

Burn baby burn by Meg Medina

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2016. ISBN 9780763674670
(Age: 14+) Recommended. 17 year old Nora Lopez lives in New York during the terrible year of 1977. The heat is scorching and there is a killer on the loose. But that's not all Nora has to face - her family is spiralling out of control, with her mother having difficulty paying the rent and brother Hector becoming uncontrollable and befriending drug dealers.
In a story of resilience set against a fascinating historical backdrop, Medina brings to life the difficulties that Nora faces with courage and thoughtfulness. With her father only interested in his new family and not paying his way, it is she who must interpret for her mother, and try and avoid the increasing violence of her younger brother. When she meets a cute boy at the deli where she works, she and her friend Kathleen know that Sam the Man, the serial killer, is murdering young couples, and they both wonder if it is safe to go out on dates. Her teachers are encouraging her to go to college but all Nora wants to do is reach the age of 18 when she can leave home and become independent, without the family worries that are so overwhelming.
I enjoyed the thread of feminism that weaves its way through the story, with Kathleen's mother an ardent believer in going to rallies for women's rights. She takes the girls along with her on marches. Nora too is clever with non-traditional skills of woodwork and these skills will ultimately help her in a resolution to her problems.
Friendship plays an important part of the story, and the relationship between Nora and Kathleen will leave readers asking questions about when it is right to tell family secrets and seek help from friends.
There are some big themes here: not only is there the simmering heat that erupts in violence in the city, and the threat of a serial killer on the loose, but the family dynamics are dire. In the author's note at the back Medina talks about her theme of juvenile domestic violence that is rarely touched on in young adult novels and the novel being a 'celebration of people who find their strength even in the worst circumstances'.
This would make a great literature circle book, with lots of themes to be discussed.
Pat Pledger

Twelfth night by William Shakespeare, retold by Terry Deary

cover image

Terry Deary Shakespeare Tales series. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472917836
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Theatre. Another in Deary's retelling of Shakespeare's plays will help introduce this play to a new audience. One of his best loved plays, Twelfth night is often presented on the stage around the world and has been made into countless film adaptations.
Here it is presented as a story and stripped back to its bare essentials. John and Jane are at Richmond Palace to watch Master Shakespeare's latest play, 'Twelfth night'. Through their eyes we see the court and its splendour, Queen Elizabeth, now coming towards the end of her life, the courtiers pressing their advantage and the play set out before them. Their story and observations make a fascinating backdrop to the play which tells of deception, just as Lord Essex deceives the Queen. The two children could see that Essex and his armed men, were up to no good and using the suit of armour in the hall were able to defuse the plot by Essex's guards.
So the play continues, the parallels between what is actually happening and the play's plot gathering speed. Both come to a satisfactory conclusion and readers will have a sound grasp of the play, while infusing some details about Elizabethan life. A postscript about Essex's true attempts to overthrow Queen Elizabeth rounds off the short book. This is one in Deary's series presenting Shakespeare's plays in an abridged story version which will acquaint younger readers with an outline of each play. Behind the play presented is a story of young people involved in some way with the play, giving a perspective which will appeal to the readers.
Fran Knight

The Sisters Saint-Claire by Carlie Gibson

cover image

Ill. by Tamsin Ainslie. Allen & Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760291563
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Themes: Animals, Cooking, Family, Rhyme. The youngest mouse in the Saint-Claire house is a magnificent pastry baker and cook . . . but is too little to leave the house and go to the market to sell her wares. Then one day she is able to convince her family that she is big enough to go with her siblings, even though she is small. Despite initial poor sales, eventually a Royal patron proves that her culinary skills are worthy of attention, despite her small size.
This is a gentle rhyming tale with a French twist and mousy characters illustrated in a naive style by an experienced illustrator (whose work is reminiscent of the style shown in Angelina Ballerina; but whose skilful work also appears in other works eg the covers of the Matty and Bill novels for Young Readers).
Carolyn Hull

Fright club by Ethan Long

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781681190433
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Halloween, Ghost and ghouls, Monsters, Humour, Board book. In the midnight hour, Vlad has called a meeting of the Fright Club, designed to get his friends run through their scariness for Halloween. His friends include Frankenstein, a witch, a wolf and a mummy. There are three things they need to practise before Halloween: ghoulish faces, scary moves and chilling sounds. Unfortunately, their faces wouldn't even scare a daddy long legs and Vlad is extremely disappointed. A knock at the door reveals a rabbit intent on joining their club. Rabbit is sent away and Vlad returns to his teaching role. Just as Mumford's eyes are boringly popping out of his head, there's another knock at the door and the rabbit has returned, this time with her lawyer Frances Foxx. Vlad shuts the door in their faces and tries to get his monster friends to focus. But rabbit returns with her critter friends complete with banners and lots of noise. They pound on the door and show their amazing scary steps and frightening screams, scaring the Fight Club to bits. A compromise is reached and Operation Kiddy Scare is set to be the best Halloween yet.
This is a wonderfully dark and devious story, designed to have readers laugh out loud at the implications of Vlad and his club refusing entry to rabbit and her friends.
A wonderful read aloud, full of information about Halloween which seems to be gaining more interest in Australia, but also giving an underlying lesson in compromise and working together.
The funny illustrations help make this board book a joy to read.
Fran Knight

Fox and Goldfish by Nils Pieters

cover image

Book Island, 2016. ISBN 9780994128218
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Picture book for older readers. Themes: Adventure, Friendship, loss, remembrance, pets. As soon as this book is opened, the reader knows that there is a different journey to what would be expected from the cover illustration. The opening words by Nils Pieters, a Belgium author, sets the scene:
Oh Goldfish, my friend
Maybe your time has come,
But I just can't let you go like this . . .

It is obvious that Goldfish is unwell and Fox is distraught for his friend, so he takes him on a quest to see the wonders of the world. They fish off tall rocks and splash in the sea, ride a motor bike through the desert of Utah, view fabulous mountains, trek through a tropical forest, and even catch a rainbow. Fox drags Goldfish behind him on ski trip and together they look at earth from outer space. Then it is time for Fox to let Goldfish to go:
Okay, my friend,
Now you can go.

The joy of discovery that Fox and Goldfish experience is expressed without words through the vivid illustrations painted in bold, bright colours. There are only the six lines of narrative in the book and it is the strange memorable drawings that make such an impact. The theme of friendship shines throughout the book. Fox is such a good to make sure that Goldfish's last days on earth are so memorable. He has also make some wonderful memories for himself to treasure as he sits in front of Goldfish's memorial stone. The theme of impending loss is handled so positively that it will be an inspiration for many not to be overwhelmed by grief but to do wonderful things and make happy memories to last.
This is a moving book that will appeal to all ages.
Pat Pledger

Botanicum by Katie Scott and Kathy Willis

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781783703944
(Age: 8+) Museums, Evolution, Plants. As with Historium and Animalium this beautiful book will make an excellent library book which some children will chose to use. Students will need to be shown this book and when they dip inside will be amply rewarded.
As with any museum, each double page is like a gallery, inviting students to look closely at the detailed illustrations by Scott and then read Willis' words.
Again, reminiscent of wood block prints of the past, the highly detailed illustrations beg the eyes to look closely and deeply, lingering over the intricacy of the pictures shown, taking int he text and all it offers. Some illustrations, like the Giant Sequoia are pictured across the double page, increasing its interest to readers, its placement underlining it size. Information about its size, plant group if belongs to and where it can be found is given underneath along with references to the illustrations. Kids will be amazed at the information and pictures given in this book. Seven chapters are given in all, starting with The First Plants, moving on to Trees, Palms and Cycads; Herbaceous Plants; Grasses, Cattails, Sedges and Rushes; Orchids and Bromeliads and finishing with a chapter on how plants have adapted to the environment. All in all a fascinating book to read or dip into, to use as a reference or just gathering information. A detailed index is given at the back between the most glorious of endpapers.
Fran Knight

Here comes Mr Postmouse by Marianne Dubuc

cover image

Book Island, 2016. ISBN 9780994128201
Recommended. Themes: Picture Books; Animals. The winning feature of this book by French-Canadian author Dubuc is the detailed pen and ink style cartoon illustrations which show the homes of the animals to which Mr Postmouse delivers his parcels and letters. The text accompanying these illustrations are printed in a very tiny font which signposts that they are to take a 'back seat' to the quirky and cute illustrations that show the cross-sections of the animal homes, revealing lifestyles of the families inside - for example, the 7 level bunny bunk bed.
Young readers (particularly pre-readers!) will love browsing the illustrations for the quirks of family life revealed both above ground, behind closed doors and under water.
Carolyn Hull

King Flashypants and the Evil Emperor by Andy Riley

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781444929591
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. King Edwin is a kid and a king. He rules Edwinland and is loved by everyone. (especially on Fridays when he spends his pocket money on chocolate and shares it with everyone). Minister Jill helps King Edwin run the country while evil Emperor Nurbinson continually plots to steal Edwinland from them all. How will a cow disguised as a dragon be the downfall of the kingdom? Will the people of Edwinland be easily swayed? How does shaving 2 sheep help Edwin hide his crown? Can Edwin become a guard in Nurbinson's army and spoil Emperor Nurbinson's plans? By the way, his people call him King Edwin. You will have to read the book to find out why he is called King Flashypants in this story.
King Flashypants and the Evil Emperor is a hilarious read and highly recommended for readers aged 9+ . Thanks to funny events like itchy bums and characters with crazy names, reluctant readers will be laughing all the way to the end. The text is descriptive and moves quickly. It is scattered with funny cartoons and readers will be hanging out for the next King Edwin adventure.
Kylie Kempster