Reviews

Two sisters by Asne Seierstad

cover image

Little, Brown, 2018. ISBN 9780349009049
(Age: Senior secondary) Highly recommended. Two Sisters is a compelling read which fascinated me from the moment I read the first paragraph. Not only is Asne Seierstad's book an enticing piece of literature but it's partnered with realism and a form of education based around the territory of the Islamic State, extremism and the fear of radicalisation in the human population. Choosing this book, my initial thoughts were that it'd only be an interpretation, a fictional story of the journey to join Islamic State. This was until I found out that Asne Seierstad is not only an author but a freelance journalist with over two decades of war correspondence under her belt who partnered up with the support of the Juma family which this story is based on and I realised my assumptions of this book, its narrative and the author couldn't have been more wrong.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading Two Sisters simply because I was able to understand and become informed of a family whose life has been changed since these two sisters, two daughters, friends and family members chose to leave their life in Norway on the 17th of October 2013, to join the Islamic State in war stricken Syria to help Muslim people who have become under attack and in need of critical aid. Reading this book, something clicked in my brain, if you have the ability to help someone, then why wouldn't you help? Maybe the fear of being hurt yourself is what sets human beings back but the strength and utmost bravery these two girls have is admirable and understanding this from a report of sorts is what kept me reading. Asne Seierstad has created an intense, enticing and furthermore investigative book, one that has sparked questions and conversation within myself but internationally to all people who read this piece.
I highly recommend Two Sisters by Asne Seierstad and am looking forward to reading more of Asne's work in the future.
Rylee Bogisch (Student)

Simon Thorn and the Shark's Cave by Aimee Carter

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408858059
(Age: 9-14) Recommended. Simon Thorn is an Animalgam which is a secret race who can each shift into animal form. There are 5 Animalgam kingdoms, birds, insects, reptiles, mammals and the underwater world.
Simon has a secret, he can shift into animals from any kingdom. He has to keep this rare gift a secret, for the leaders of the five kingdoms would destroy him. This is the third book in the series but the first I have read, so it was a little confusing at times. The author does her best to succinctly fill in past information from previous novels but I recommend that the books are read in order to gain a better understanding of the plot.
Each book is dedicated to a different world and this novel is set underwater as the title suggests. Simon, his twin brother and other shape shifters are grudgingly allowed to visit the underwater kingdom.
Simon's evil grandfather, Orion is planning on taking over all the kingdoms and needs the scattered pieces of a terrible weapon to achieve his aim. One of the pieces is hidden in the underwater world. Simon needs to find the piece before his grandfather but this is difficult to do in the militant, guarded sea kingdom. Aimee Carter has portrayed the underwater kingdom as being very regimented with the creatures behaving like soldiers in the army and schools of fish are compared to parading military.
These fantasy stories take the reader into different focus worlds, where Simon has to face danger and solve difficult problems. He is a young hero who has to overcome extreme odds, similar to Percy Jackson in his mythical world.
Aimee Carter has written young adult novels before embarking on this 5 five book series. I would recommend these books to students aged from 9 to 14 years.
Jane Moore

A stone for Sascha by Aaron Becker

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2018. ISBN 9780763665968
(Age: 6+) Themes: Grief. Death. Dogs. Imagination. History. Caldecott Award winning author illustrator, Aaron Becker has produced a magical story of the cycle of life. With the most amazing digitally painted illustrations, detailed and encompassing, Becker does not need words to show us a saddened young girl burying her pet dog. Going on the family camping holiday is simply not the same without him and she holds back when other children play happily in the water. But she finds a smooth stone and hurling it up into the sky, the stone reveals the history of the world through its journey from being a piece of extruded rock, to a large monolith hauled onto the hill top by a group of men, to the hand sized stone she now finds in the water.
Over millennia we see the stone first thrust out of the earth, then being used, first as a large standing stone, next as a smaller piece in an Egyptian temple, then smaller still, a building block in a statue of Buddha, then as the keystone in a bridge in China and smaller still it is sculpted and sent to the Americas, where what is left now lies near to the water's edge, a much smaller version of itself.
The endpapers show a map of the world and trace the journey of the stone through its various incarnations from large to small, through Ethiopia and Mesopotamia, India, Burma, China then across the Pacific Ocean to Honolulu to its final resting place where the girl finds it on the western seaboard of North America. The maps show an overview of the world's history sure to intrigue and delight younger readers who will search out more information about the empires that have risen only to fall and be replaced by another.
This is a surprise of a book, worth delving into, capturing readers' imaginations as they put their own words to the pictures, build their own timelines around the stone, and ponder the circle of life as the stone keeps going on in one shape or other. There are so many layers to this book, that it is hard to dwell on any one. But I love the different forms of travel shown through the illustrations, and the differing work done by the individuals shown, as well as their costumes, and the few animals that pop up in the pages, quietly watching the activities of the people and the stone, while the story comes full circle, the stone finally at rest on the dog's grave.
Fran Knight

The buildings that made London by David Long

cover image

Ill. by Josie Shenoy. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408883648
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Themes: London. Cities. History. I thoroughly enjoyed poring over each of the double page spreads in this book, recalling the British history taught to me as a school student in the 1950's and 60's, admiring the illustrations of a large number of British institutions, seen as a tourist in recent years, and for many of today's Australian younger students, this will be a new and delightful experience.
Amongst the many pages, I loved the Houses of Parliament, St Paul's Cathedral, Somerset House, Westminster Abbey, Tower Bridge and the Tower of London, all known and visited, all part of the rich heritage explicitly taught to Australian students in the past.
Today's students would certainly know of some of the places and many would be interested in places like Westminster Abbey and places seen on television, or through the Royal Weddings of late, and I hope that many would pick up this most attractive book to read and enjoy and add to their knowledge of major cities around the world.
Each double page has a detailed drawing of the place, taken from archival documents, and the text around the pages delineates some of the history of that building and its place in the London of today. It is all fascinating to me and its presentation by a teacher as part of a unit on cities would woo an audience, but to pick it up to ponder over the heritage of one of the world's most beautiful cities would be enough for many readers.
The double page spread about the Victoria and Albert Museum, for example, has a drawing which covers both pages, illustrated around the edges with some of the exhibits housed within. The people in the front represent those who have visited the museum over the decades, and reading the text at the top of the pages, reveals some of the history of the building as well as some of the most wellknown pieces to be found inside. I was surprised to find that it was built in 1890 to replace an ugly building already there and that the guide was published in French during World War Two to assist the French refugees residing in London at the time.
This like other pages is detailed and evocative, but the highlight of the book are the central pages devoted to Buckingham Palace. Here the publication has flaps which show the palace as it was and how it is today. Eager readers will devour each piece of information and take in the fabulously detailed illustrations.
Fran Knight

Stone Girl by Eleni Hale

cover image

Penguin, 2018. ISBN 9780143785613
(Age: Young Adult) Themes: Homelessness, Institutional Care, substance dependence, abusive relationships, death. When Sophie's mum got drunk or took drugs 12 year old Sophie cleaned up the mess and kept them fed. She learned never to trust authority figures who wanted to interfere. Sophie liked to do well at school and have friends with 'normal' families so when her mum's new boyfriend came over to party Sophie went out to her friend's place. When she got back her mum was alone and dead. Sophie not only blamed herself for the death but was so scared of authority that she stayed three days with the body until the police broke down the door. The story opens at the police station waiting for a social worker to come to take Sophie into emergency housing. Sophie's father who lives in Greece can't be contacted so she becomes a ward of the State. Naomi, her caseworker is kind and compassionate, Sophie wants to go home with her and feel safe but instead she is left to negotiate a share house along with her grief, guilt and questions about her mother. She is hopeful that her father will come and rescue her but when they get in touch he won't accept responsibility. When she goes back to school she is treated as a freak, the newspapers have sensationalised the finding of the three day old dead body with Sophie by her side so she stops going to school.
The rest of the confronting story is the spiralling downhill trajectory of Sophie's life over the next few years in multiple state care facilities each with new and unpredictable inmates. Overworked caseworkers and Sophie's innate distrust of authority leave her without emotional support. No one seems to care if she goes to school or not, or what she is doing outside the facility but she is a quick learner and soon fits in with the other "problem" kids, stealing, risking death, contemplating suicide, entering an abusive relationship, and we begin to understand how they can reach a place where there are no constraints. "If no one owes us kids anything why would we owe anything back?' p102. This is not an easy story to read, dealing with death, poverty, substance and sexual abuse; an insight into the lives of vulnerable children whose needs are not met by the institutions set up to look after them. Told in the first person the author has to negotiate the development of the voice of the main character from deprived 12 to a street wise 16 year old and it can be difficult to relate to Sophie's voice. After years of struggle Sophie does make the choice to turn her life around but we are so shell shocked by the dark and dangerous places she has been that she seems just a shadow. This book has been called "important" and it shines a light into some hidden lives but it is a harrowing and morally confusing story which needs some maturity from its readers. Young adults seem to love it but some caution is needed before putting it on the shelves.
Sue Speck

The Unicorn Quest by Kamilla Benko

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781681192451
(Age: 8-12) Themes: Fantasy, Adventure, Unicorns, Courage. Kamilla Benko's debut novel is an enchanting fantasy, filled with magic, adventure and tests of courage. Set in Arden, a delightfully captivating world where the last unicorn has disappeared, where secrets abound and tensions run high between the four guilds of magic who have lost trust in each other.
The Martinson family inherit mysterious Windermere Manor and move in for the summer. Sisters Sophie and Claire love exploring the vast rooms filled with antiques and art collected on their Great-Aunt Diana's travels. They discover a ladder in a fireplace leading to another world and their adventure begins. Sophie is a collector of experiences who is recovering from a mystery illness, she loves to explore. Her younger sister Claire an artist, is more hesitant, she carries her pencil everywhere to capture what she sees. The portal leads them into a fractured world, where four guilds protect their own lands and guard them fiercely.
When Sophie disappears, Claire must overcome her fears and search for her lost sister. With the help of Nett a Tiller and Sena a Forger, Claire must bravely embark on a quest across treacherous lands to find Sophie. Her sister has been accused of stealing a magical unicorn artefact that has kept the peace amongst the Arden guilds. Each relies on magical elements for survival, the Tillers use the special powers of plants, whilst the Forgers rely on the qualities of metal objects. Their journey to Fyrton is dangerous: wraiths haunt the forests at night, the adventurers travel hidden in a merchant Spinner's boat, they escape from captivity using aqua masks and sneakily search the Forger's school library for clues. Along the way, Claire grows in courage, learns to overcome her self-doubt, learns resilience and surprises herself with the tasks she undertakes.
'The Unicorn Quest' by Kamilla Benko is a classic fantasy quest, with a plot that follows the traditional format. Interwoven historic tales, hidden clues and engaging characters add interest for the middle grade reader.
Rhyllis Bignell

Teacher's dead by Benjamin Zephaniah

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408895016
(Age: 13+) Students in a poorly performing school are shocked and traumatised when a teacher is stabbed by two boys and dies in front of them.
Jackson, one of the students who witnessed the incident attempts to understand exactly what occurred and begins to investigate. When the bereaved Mrs. Joseph visits the school to speak to the students regarding her late husband's passion for teaching, Jackson approaches her and asks to meet.
A friendship develops between the pair and Jackson invites her home to meet his mother. I found Jackson's 'mission' slightly odd, especially when he makes himself known to Ms. Ferrier, the mother of one of murderers and introduces her to the bereaved woman. The awkwardness and discomfort of the various parties is presented very well, and whilst I initially found the situation improbable, some issues worthy of consideration are examined.
Mrs. Joseph shows incredible grace and intelligence in dealing magnanimously with Ms. Ferrier, when outsiders think she should be shunned and reviled. We learn that sins committed by the son do not necessarily reflect his upbringing or the values of the parent. Whilst Mrs. Joseph suffers greatly from the death of her loved one, her rational way of reconciling the positions of those involved helps alleviate the collective pain, a more desirable outcome than the perpetuation of grief and torment.
There are some clever features in this novel. Whilst readers may create their own mental image, perhaps influenced by stereotypical assumptions, Jackson's voice could be that of any boy. The same may be said for the other major characters as little reference is made to racial identity.
The issue of bullying and gang violence is an important feature of this story and the utter mindlessness of group victimisation is portrayed brilliantly. The attitudes and utterances of those who attack weaker victims was depicted so realistically that I actually felt some sense of despair. This was partly because I was acknowledging the realistic portrayal of moronic philosophy but also because it was clear that the author was recounting personal experience on some level.
Rob Welsh

Where is Little Fish? by Lucy Cousins

cover image

Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406374186
(Age: 1-3) This is a Little Fish Book, featuring the same fish from Count with Little Fish and Hooray for Fish. It is tactile and visually appealing, using the same illustrative style as Lucy Cousins' other books, such as Maisy. Everything is patterned with spots and stripes of varying vibrant design. Both the colours and the tone of the book are bold and cheerful. Playful illustrations encourage discussion about shape, colour, pattern, and things you find in the sea (crab, pearl, coral etc.). Little Fish is playing hide and seek with friends. Is Little Fish behind the yellow coral? No, it's stripy fish! In the end we find Little Fish and Mummy Fish too. Kiss, kiss, kiss! There are flaps on each page to keep toddlers engaged and interacting with the board book and they will have fun finding Little Fish at the end of the book.
This is a happy under-the-sea world to share with little ones, especially those who love the other Little Fish books.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Ghost Boys by Jewell Parker Rhodes

cover image

Orion Children's Books, 2018. ISBN 9781510104396
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Twelve-year-old Jerome is shot by a police officer who mistakes his toy gun for a real threat. As a ghost, he observes the devastation that's been unleashed on his family and community in the wake of what they see as an unjust and brutal killing.
Soon Jerome meets another ghost: Emmett Till, a boy from a very different time but similar circumstances. Emmett helps Jerome process what has happened, on a journey towards recognizing how historical racism may have led to the events that ended his life. Jerome also meets Sarah, the daughter of the police officer, who grapples with her father's actions.
Wow! Wow! Wow! This is possibly the best book I have read this year. Rhodes has done a fantastic job of evoking emotions of hate, compassion, love and empathy all rolled into one. She has tackled the issues of race discrimination in the USA towards African-American youth, particularly boys in an unusual way - changing the perspectives the book is written from. Throughout the book it interchanges between Jerome telling his story while he was alive and also his viewpoint when he is a ghost. With such strong themes including racism and violence, I would recommend this book for children aged 12 and up. This would make a fantastic read aloud and create a mountain of discussion. A must have for the collection!
Kathryn Schumacher

I have lost my way by Gayle Forman

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2018. ISBN 9781471173721
(Ages: 14+) Recommended. Themes: Friendship, love, acceptance, loss. Around the time that Freya loses her voice while recording her debut album, Harun is making plans to run away from everyone he has ever loved, and Nathaniel is arriving in New York City with a backpack, a desperate plan, and nothing left to lose. When a fateful accident draws these three strangers together, their secrets start to unravel as they begin to understand that the way out of their own loss might just lie in helping the others out of theirs.
I have lost my way by Gayle Forman is a book about friendship, love and finding yourself when you feel like all is lost. The story is told over one life changing day and is told from alternating perspectives. One of the main themes in this book is loss. The three main characters, Freya, Harun and Nathaniel, have all lost something important to them. Freya has lost her voice during the recording of her debut album, which she has spent the last few years of her life working towards. Harun has lost the love of his life, the only person that truly understood him. Nathaniel has lost everything and now, he has nothing left to lose.
At the start of the book, not much is known about each of the characters, but as the story progresses, we learn more about their lives and what lead them to become who they are today through flashbacks. I absolutely loved how mysterious they all were and the fact that they all had different backgrounds, religions and sexual orientations just made them seem all the more real. The diversity in this book was amazing and it was represented really well.
A definite downside of this book is that it took me quite a while to get into. In my opinion, it was difficult to figure out which character's perspective it was being told from and the fact that it would jump from third person to first person during the flashbacks made it slightly confusing and hard to follow at times. It was also very fast paced and since it was told over a single day, I found it less believable than if it had been told over the course of a week.
Overall, I have lost my way is a really nice story about love, loss and acceptance that teenagers everywhere would enjoy, especially if they feel like they have lost their way too.
Grace Austin (Student)

When the mountains roared by Jess Butterworth

cover image

Hachette, 2018. ISBN 9781510102118
(Ages 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Grief. Fear. Wildlife conservation. India - Family life.
Jess Butterworth drew inspiration for When the mountains roared from her own family stories, her grandparents' travels to India in the 1960s and her own childhood experiences living with them at the foot of the Himalayas. She descriptively captures the sensory experiences, the diverse sights and sounds, cityscapes and countryside and wildlife encounters. Her understandings of the Indian way of life resonate here. The imprint of the leopard, from the roaring white silhouette and the rich yellow and brown markings of the covers that continue as bold chapter headings, set the scene for her message of wildlife conservation.
Coping with the death of her mother, Ruby is overcome by her fears, afraid of the dark, of travelling by car, going to sleep and not waking up in the morning. She lives with her father and grandmother in Western Australia in a rural hotel which has fallen into disrepair and her father has borrowed money from loan sharks to save the property. Desperate to escape from their problems they abandon their home, take only a few possessions, their collie dog Polly, and drive through the night to Perth. Along the way they collect a baby joey which Nan hides in her luggage.
Nan's afraid of flying so they board a cruise ship bound for India. Their tiring journey finally brings them to the bottom of the Himachal Pradesh and a haunted mountain. Life for the family is confronting, their new hotel needs a large amount of work, with the owners involved in wildlife poaching. Ruby captures photos of the beautiful world around the hotel; she is an observer, listening to secret conversations and trailing her father's employers. There are moments of fun and laughter, the colourful Holi festival, caring for Joey, watching Bollywood films, making friends with Praveen and dancing to Bollywood music with Dad and Nan.
Ruby's bravery in tracking the poachers, searching for the elusive leopard, attests to her strength of character, overcoming her fears and grief. With her Grandma and loyal friend Praveen they embark on a treacherous journey into the mountains, each show courage in the face of danger. The resolution brings both closure and hope for the future, the author concluding with a heartfelt message about the need to conserve and protect native wildlife and the risk of invasive species taking over the natural environment.
When the mountains roared is a beautifully crafted story, where each of the main characters comes to terms with the loss of a loved one, and is an emotive journey amongst the beauty and splendour of the Himalayan foothills. Share this with a middle primary class, explore the detailed and descriptive narrative, the insightful poignant journey Ruby undertakes, then research the endangered wildlife and the impact of the poaching trade.
Rhyllis Bignell

The price guide to the occult by Leslye Walton

cover image

Candlewick Press 2018. ISBN 9780763691103
(Age: 14+) Recommended for people with an interest in mental health and magic. TW: This novel contains self-harm. This is certainly a novel that would be difficult to walk past, The price guide to the occult is both loud and distracting with neon yellow on black surrounded by red-edged pages.
The novel follows a cursed family of Blackburn women, all of whom are destined to have a three-day romance in which a child is conceived and denied by a man descended from the original eight of Anathema Island. Together with the curse of heartbreak, each daughter is 'gifted' with a burden of magical talent, some stronger than others. Fern Blackburn, the eighth daughter, received the gift of always getting what she wanted. However, the one loophole in her gift was never being able to have Quinn Sweeny, the love of her life and the father of her daughter, Nor. Fern's obsession with possessing Quinn is all encompassing, and she will stop at nothing to secure his love - even if that means sacrificing their daughter.
Nor is only a teenager. Her only worries should be grades and boys. But she is also a Blackburn woman... with a secret. Fear of her mother has made her tame and afraid of her own powers, for indeed she is the first since the matriarch, Rona, to possess more than one. When Fern returns, Nor's fear only grows until she is unable to keep her power in check. A storm is brewing, and only one Blackburn woman will prevail.
The price guide to the occult was engrossing. Despite the many references to self-harm and the gruesome murders Fern commits, it was an enlightening exploration of the relationship between a neglectful mother and her child. Similar in ways to Practical magic and Little shop of horrors, it was certainly an enjoyable read. Recommended for ages fourteen and up with an interest in mental health and magic.
Kayla Gaskell, 22

Spot goes to the swimming pool by Eric Hill

cover image

Puffin Books, 2018. ISBN 9780241327074
(Age 1-4) Highly recommended. Board book. Themes: Swimming. Fear. A delightful way to introduce the idea of swimming at a swimming pool to very young children, this board book is sure to be a hit with its intended audience. Spot is a bit nervous about the water, thinking that it could be cold but Mum encourages him to try it out and with her help and encouragement is soon letting go of the side of the pool and splashing around in his safe rubber ring.
The bright colours bring to life the poolside, water and swimming accessories. The wonderful expressions on the faces of Spot, his mother and friend Steve are delightful and leave the reader appreciating the joys of a mother who is patient and loving and helpful friends. The pages are sturdy and should stand up for heavy use by little hands, as this is sure to become a firm favourite.
Spot has been a favourite of children for many years and Spot goes to the swimming pool will be a lovely way to introduce a new generation to this lovely little dog and then perhaps follow up with some of the many books that Eric Hill has written about him.
Pat Pledger

Best buds under frogs by Leslie Patricelli

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2018. ISBN 9780763651046
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Friendship. School. Moving from the city to Pine Lake where she must catch a bus to school, Lily is apprehensive, and barfing on the first day does not endear her to the group of friends who had assembled around her. But Darby takes her on, and soon the two are best of friends, with sleepovers and catching the bus together.
So begins this amusing story of fitting in, of starting a new school in year four, of finding someone who will be your best friend. Darby and Lily set up a club, the Rizzlerunk Club, named after the sea captain who ran aground in the lake, his head mysteriously becoming attached to a giant octopus and climbing into the old boat shed on the shore near Darby's home. Fun and mayhem follows the girls, as they contend with the remarks from the others in their class and are somewhat baffled when they take on the club the two have created for themselves.
Darby's stories are all about ghosts and ghouls and Lily is even more apprehensive the first time she goes to her house and meets her family, a large group of people who all look like Darby, even down to the glasses they all wear. They are all pleased that Lily is Darby's new friend, who they think is much better that Darby's former fiend, Jill, who has moved away. But alarm bells ring when she unexpectedly moves back to the lake, bringing with her her own sense of the funny and dramatic which embroiled Darby in many mishaps in the previous year.
Patricelli's first novel for mid-primary people is most successful, pitched at their concerns, fitting in, finding friends and coping with family issues. She has included funny little illustrations, many of which can be found through the text.
Fran Knight

The disturbed girl's dictionary by Nonieqa Ramos

cover image

Lerner Publishing Group, 2018. ISBN 9781512439762
(Age: 14+) Recommended.
Macy Cashmere is a teenager living in the ghetto trying to survive life the best she can. Her father is in prison, her mother entertains a constant stream of male 'guests' and her little brother has been taken away by Child Protection Services. She battles constant hunger, poverty and the need for her family to be together again like it was before her father went to prison.
At school she has only two friends (Alma and George) who she is fiercely protective of and is constantly in trouble for not conforming and thus considered a 'disturbed' student. Despite this, school is really her constant in life. Her way of keeping track of her life is by her entries in her dictionary which is not really a diary as we know it but more of a memory keeper.
Macy's only true constant in her life and the one she holds onto dearly is her friendship with Alma. Alma is a shining star, kind to her peers, a good student and a loving sister to her young siblings. When Alma starts to drift away, Macy tries to find out why she isn't talking to her and what has happened in Alma's life to make her drift away from the friendship.
This story is raw, full of language and themes not suited to a younger audience. It is exactly how you would imagine life in the ghetto to be and the daily struggles of those who live there and those who try to help those who live there. Don't expect happy endings but rather an insight into who Macy is, why she does what she does and how she copes with the actions of those who mean something to her.
Themes in this book are: poverty, neglect, hardship, friendship and sexual promiscuity. I would recommend this book to students 14+.
Gerri Mills