Reviews

The Lion and the Bird by Marianne Dubic

cover image

Book Island, 2015. ISBN 9780994109873
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Originally published in French in Canada and now published in more than 15 countries around the world, this is a heart-warming tale of an unlikely friendship between an overall-wearing lion and a bird with a broken wing. There are 40 double pages here, but only around 20 with text. Furthermore, each contains only one sentence, often only one word. The limited text means that the illustrations have to do most of the work, and they do this so well. The artwork is spectacular. It is soft and textural with an earthy colour palette of browns, blues and greens. In a minimalist style, Dubic puts onto each page only those elements which help to tell the story and show the passing of time. There is a cinematic, silent film quality here; you could just as easily ignore the text altogether and the artwork would do the job just as well. High quality paper adds to the earthy feel of this book and the matte illustrations suit the solidity of the thick pages.
The story itself is about a lion who takes care of a bird with a broken wing when the rest of the flock fly away for the winter. Soon the pair is enjoying the winter together: reading in front of the fire, taking sleigh rides and keeping warm out of the snow. Blank pages help to show the all-encompassing whiteness of the snowy weather. Soon the warm weather is back and the bird must re-join his flock. The reader waits anxiously alongside the lion to find out whether his friend will join him for the winter again.
This is a gentle and emotive tale exploring themes of friendship, change and loneliness. It is perfect for working with children on inference and exploring how we can tell a story with pictures alone. It also lends itself to discussions around seasons and change as the changing landscape is an integral feature of the book. This is a wonderful title for one on one sharing as it allows for rich discussion and up-close appreciation of the illustrations.
Nicole Nelson

Trigger Mortis By Anthony Horowitz

cover image

Orion Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781409159537
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. This book was read in one sitting, as it just refused to be let go. The Ian Fleming Estate provided Anthony Horowitz with original, unpublished writing for this book. This book reacquaints the reader with M, Moneypenny, Pussy Galore and a range of dastardly villains guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat.
007 is in a deadly mission against the Soviet organisation SMERSH and Korean Jason Sin. He must enter a Grand Prix race and save the American Space Program. The stage is set for action at its most thrilling.
The story is fast paced and so well written the reader is almost pulled along from one heart stopping event to the next. Horowitz has spared no effort in providing authentic detail for Grand Prix racing and the massacre at No Gun Ri. He also relates the inner thoughts of 007 in such a natural way the reader almost feels the thoughts are their own.
An interesting inclusion in this story is the tension where 007 is deciding whether to dispatch a character. His 007 status explained, he makes a decision the reader is at first confronted by. The James Bond in this book is a man of Ian Fleming's times who is challenged by the sensibilities of the modern world. It makes great reading.
Linda Guthrie

The Mirror World of Melody Black by Gavin Extence

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2015. ISBN 9781444764628
(Age: Adult) Highly recommended. 'You have a choice about what you put into the public domain.'
This book is really difficult to put down. It tells Abby's story from her perspective as Abby spirals into a manic episode following finding her neighbour dead in the flat next door.
Abby is inspired in her mania - brilliant ideas and fashion choices emanate from the page as she describes her adventures. Is it possible for the reader to identify the point where Abby tips into madness? The writing is compelling and there is a very real sense that the writer has first-hand experience with this mental illness. The author's note at the end of the book put this in perspective and adds an authenticity to the writing.
Abby's very supportive psychiatrist plays a key role in rescuing Abby as she plummets into depression. It is while undergoing treatment in hospital that Abby meets Melody Black and the significance of the title of the book becomes clear.
Another key aspect of the book is the development of the relationships in Abby's life. The incredible resilience and caring of the family and loved ones standing by Abby throughout her episode and the mysteriously satisfying remote relationship with poet Miranda Frost are detailed with humour.
Linda Guthrie

Azizi and the Little Blue Bird by Laila Koubaa and Mattias De Leeuw

cover image

Book Island, 2015. ISBN 9780994109866
(Age: 5-12) Recommended. Picture book. Azizi lives in a country dominated by two greedy rulers. They feast and feast and expand with both food and power. They have captured all the blue birds in the land and have locked them up in their palace.
Azizi feels he and his people are shrinking while the rulers expand.
One night an escaped blue bird visits Azizi and together with a trail of threaded flowers they embark on a plan to free both the birds and people.
This story can be enjoyed both as a modern fairy tale, or as a symbol of people power overthrowing a cruel regime. According to the website  the events in this book are based on a true incident:  'in 2010/2011 when, during the Arab Spring the internet was censored and/or shut down during the uprisings, in an attempt to prevent protests from spreading over the region. The little blue birds - have you already guessed it?- refer to Twitter. '
The author is Dutch and the original text has been translated by David Colmer.
This is a large format picture book and the illustrations by Mattias De Leeuw fill each page with strong lines and bold colour.
I recommend this book for primary school libraries and children from 5 to 12 will enjoy this story at its many levels.
Jane Moore

Counting Stars by Keris Stainton

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471404634
(Age: Adult) Anna is eighteen and desperate to leave home and begin her life. Her passion is to work in the theatre. While on work experience she is offered a job in Liverpool and decides to take the plunge and move there.
She shares a flat with characters who are also finding their way as young adults. Each character has an intricate and moving story, told well. The characters are well drawn and have the reader at turns sympathising and cringing in embarrassment.
An underlying and important element of this story explores the ethics and dangers of chronicling your life (and the lives of others) using social media. Anna's very public diary is her way of making sense of her maturing world, and she soon comes to find there are consequences for her and those she reveals through her vlog.
This is a book about romantic relationships. It sensitively explores the tricky issues of sexual harassment, inappropriate relationships, abusive relationships and gay relationships. It is, however, the explicit descriptions of the more intimate scenes in these relationships that moves this book into the adult range. This is unfortunate as the story holds much for, and is well suited to, the young adult reader.
Linda Guthrie

Timmy Failure: Sanitized for your Protection Stephan Pastis

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781406363494
(Age: 9 yrs+) Recommended. Timmy Failure is back again, seeking greatness and world domination as the CEO of Failure Inc., formerly Total Failure Inc., detective agency. Whilst modesty is not part of Timmy's nature his natural tendency to take a simple situation and cause extraordinary havoc has not diminished. Sparkling comedic writing combined with quirky line drawings makes Timmy a winner not a failure.
This episode in the ever eventful life of our hero, revolves around a road trip to Chicago during spring vacation to relocate Doorman Dave, Timmy's mother's boyfriend. But this simple holiday is getting in the way of Failure Inc. solving a case. The funds raised by YIP YAP to buy books for poor Yergi Plimkin 'a boy from somewhere that is not here' have gone missing. Timmy is of course focussed on solving the case which takes up all his thinking and deductive powers.
Further complications include Total, the polar bear, leaving a path of destruction and bonbon papers behind him, The Moskin family who travel with them, and Timmy overhearing his mum and Dave talking about marriage.
Forced to go on the run with Mollie Moskin in an effort to finally solve the case and hopefully confront the culprit, leads to even more chaos and hotel staff on the verge of a breakdown. Finally Timmy is apprehended himself and returned to his mother whilst the case solves itself and Timmy makes someone's night 'because detectives are tough and decent men'.
This is a delightful romp, easy to read and funny enough to laugh out loud at. Some of the word plays and chapter headings like 'Suite dreams are made of this' and 'Grapes and Wrath' may not resonate with some students but certainly added to my enjoyment of the book.
Sue Keane

Guinness World Records 2016 by Guinness World Records

cover image

Guinness World Records 2016 by Guinness World Records
Guinness World Records, 2015. ISBN 9781910561010
(Age: All) Recommended. The Guinness World Records book needs no introduction. Chock full of incredible new records, strange trivia and interesting illustrations, it is a must for every library and a book full of appeal for the reluctant reader.
Some of the most eye catching entries include the tallest man (251 cm. tall) and a page of incredible extreme body modifications (tattoos and facial flesh tunnels). All are portrayed with colourful photos that grab the imagination. New entries include waterfalls, apps, manga, drones and pirates as well as other interesting topics.
For those who want their reading a bit more focused there is a Table of Contents which includes headings like Sports, Science and Engineering, Animals, Humans, Adventurers and Extreme Exploits to name a few. An index is also available and would be helpful for those who want to target particular records. Enthusiasts can also go to the website,  and get extra information and background stories by reading the book and finding the answers to questions.
Once again Guinness World Records 2016 will be sure to astound readers as they flick through amazing records and photos, or read in more depth about the staggering things that people can get up to and the incredible animals that can be found. This is a must for libraries and would make a great present for children with inquiring minds.
Pat Pledger

The River and the Book by Alison Croggon

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781925081725
(Ages 12+) Recommended. The River and The Book has been acknowledged by Amnesty International for addressing human rights abuse in cultural, and economic terms. Poetically written this book will be an asset to for its literary and thematic content. Simbala is the Keeper of the Book and as the women in her family before her is an important member of the village in which she lives. People come to consult the Book for many reasons but Sim is the only one who can touch it or read its messages. The book contains the history and soul of the village, and like the oracle has the answers to all the villager's questions.
The River is the life blood of the village bringing life and riches as well as providing transport. Droughts cause the river to fail but when developers upstream reduce the flow and begin polluting the River, neighbouring villages are turned against each other. When consulted the Book offers a one word answer to the problem, 'Change.' However change arrives in the unexpected form of Jane Watson, a foreigner intent on writing about the river people, who befriends Sim but betrays her trust, steals the Book and disappears.
Desperate to return the book to its rightful place Sim travels down the River in search of the thief, vowing to only to return when she has recovered the treasure. Along the way she meets a variety of companions, and eventually settles in the city, still searching for Jane. She finally discovers Jane is working at the University and has published a book highlighting the plight of the River and the people who rely on it for their living.
Why someone would assume they had the right to take a community's most precious property is foremost in Sim's mind and could be a stimulus for deep discussion between students in an exploration of human rights and ethics. The divide between cultures and the assumed rights of westerners is foremost but the book is also an introduction to discussions surrounding development, pollution and change.
Sue Keane

The girl on the train by Paula Hawkins

cover image

Doubleday, 2015. ISBN 9780857522320
(Age: young adult) Crime fiction, Alcoholism, Marital relationships. After reading some fabulous reviews I bought this at Dymocks last week and spent the rest of the week reading. It certainly grabbed me and I wanted to piece together the jigsaw puzzle of Rachel's life as she stumbled from one failed attempt at getting herself together after another. One night, drunk again, she finds herself near her ex husband's house. She sees something but is uncertain as to what it is and struggles to remember the next day, waking bruised and bleeding. But it is the same night that their neighbour Megan, disappears, and Rachel is drawn into the investigation. She is sure she knows something, but lies to get the attention of the missing woman's husband and becomes an intrusion in the police investigation.
She has seen this couple on the train every morning as she goes to work. Fired for being drunk some months before, she still travels into the city but when the train stops for a signal change she watches the house, a few doors from her old house, and its occupants, Megan and Scott, creating a romantic life for them. But now Megan has gone, Rachel still haunts her old house much to the anger of her replacement, and despite attempts by her ex husband and the police to keep her at bay she persists, trying to remember what she has forgotten.
The book is told through three women's voices, Rachel, Megan and Anna, the new wife, in varying chronological order, giving the reader the background while the story progresses. I was hooked as many people have been, and I enjoyed the character of Rachel, trying to overcome her alcoholism, trying to juggle aspects of her splintered life.
This is a little potboiler, it has many twists and turns, it certainly keeps you hooked, and the last chapter is very scary: it is enjoyable and will make an equally enjoyable but forgettable film. Borrow it from your library.
Fran Knight

Robin's Winter Song by Suzanne Barton

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408859148
Picture book. Themes: Seasons - Winter. A beautifully illustrated story of young Robin as he discovers the true meaning of 'Winter' in the Northern hemisphere. As some animals make plans and preparations to avoid or escape or to prepare for the privations that lie ahead, Robin considers what he might need to do. Eventually he discovers the joy and beauty of the winter season. Colour is used carefully in this book, and muted tones in contrast to the Robin's red breast make this book a visually appealing exploration of the season from Robin's perspective. This does not contain any unusual plot twists or unique understanding of Winter, and the hibernating bear definitely places this story in a non-Australian setting, so it is not a picture book that would be a 'must-have' on Australian shelves. But it is a gentle and joyful exploration of Winter and the changes in seasons.
Carolyn Hull

Penguin's big adventure by Salina Yoon

cover image

Penguin series. Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408868713
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Friendship, Adventure, North Pole. When Penguin decides to visit the North Pole, he says goodbye to several animals who are his friends. He consults his map and loads his backpack with things he will need. He says goodbye to Emily, busy sewing a quilt, then Pumpkin who is busy building a basket, and finally Bootsy, braiding a rope. On the way north he meets other friends he has met in previous adventures. Reaching the North Pole he is ecstatic, and turns cartwheels, throws confetti and erects a sign. But there is no one there. Eventually a polar bear wanders by and each is a little uncertain of the other. But becoming friends, they explore the pole together, until Penguin's friends fly in from further south to take him back home. After all the best part of having an adventure is coming home.
This is a charming book in the series about Penguin. For younger readers it will introduce them to the idea of north and south poles and what animals live in each place; it will teach them about the environment of the North pole, and perhaps introduce the idea of explorers who went there. Younger readers will know that Penguin has some very good friends, some who will do anything for him, even traveling from one end of the world to the other, and that he has met another friend, one who is left a map. Younger readers may be able to predict what might happen in the next book, and sympathise with Penguin making friends in this book. The black outlined illustrations are clear and colour filled, making some aspects of the North Pole easily identified for younger readers.
Fran Knight

The Story of the Lost Child by Elena Ferrante

cover image

Neapolitan series. Text, 2015. ISBN 9781925240511
(Age: Adult - senior secondary) This is the concluding volume in Elena Ferrante's Neapolitan series. The first three books show Lenu and Lila growing up in a slum in Naples. Though Lila has an audacious intelligence she leaves school early, marries a brute and works at a demeaning job in a sausage factory while Lenu forces herself on through university and becomes a writer about feminist politics when she marries into a northern family with influence. In this final volume the action returns to Naples which is as turbulent and corrupt as ever. Lenu, now a successful writer and having an affair with Nino, her childhood friend who is now a brilliant and radical academic, returns to the slum district where they grew up. She continues to have a tempestuous relationship with Lila, who now is mastering the new technology of computing. Lenu's family and friends initially reject her but eventually accept her new situation and enjoy her success although they show no interest in her writing as such. Lila is now a respected business woman, while the Fascist gangsters the Solaro brothers are still her declared enemies. When Lenu realizes that Nino has always been and always will be unfaithful she rejects him and grows closer to Lila, particularly as they are both pregnant. The babies, girls, seem destined to relive the friendship of their mothers, especially as Tina, Lila's child, is precocious and beautiful, as Lila always was, while Imma is more insecure as Lenu has always been. However, Tina, aged four, disappears from the street and is never found. The Solaro brothers have clashed with Lila and her partner and are suspected but seem to be determined to help. Lila's behaviour becomes more erratic while Lenu's career continues to flourish. Lila becomes more nihilistic and questions the value of life; she examines the history of Naples and finds endless examples of cruelty being replaced with kindness which is then swamped by more cruelty.
In the background of the novel the politics of Naples and Italy repeat this pattern. The 1950's and '60's struggle between the Communists and the Fascists is replaced by different political allegiances but the one point of consistency is corruption which reaches into even the most respected levels of academia as well as politics and business. Lenu's mother-in-law, an aristocrat from an 'old' family, blames those with intelligence but with no traditions. Lenu realizes that she herself is still an outsider in some cultural circles, but also that all in the community condone corruption by turning a blind eye to it. Lila, however, believes that there are no options as the law is ineffectual. Lenu's daughters leave Italy and she herself leaves Naples. She has her greatest success when she writes the story of her friendship with Lila and the loss of Lila's child, which parallels the story of the two dolls the girls lost in childhood.
The writing is powerful and fierce in its portrayals of love, loyalty, friendships, family relationships and politics. The themes are most particularly female friendship, the relationships between mothers and daughters and the influence of place. The coarse language and attitudes of the local Neapolitans is vividly captured as is the hypocrisy of the cultured classes. Ferrante juxtaposes the crudeness of the local dialect with the purity of Italian to emphasize class distinctions but while social position and morality are not necessarily linked leaving the slums of Naples tends to be regarded as a victory.
The novel can be read as a stand alone and is recommended for competent readers. It powerfully deals with the issues of women's friendships and family lives, and with the political and social issues in Italy in the second half of the twentieth century.
Jenny Hamilton

One thing by Lauren Child

cover image

Orchard books, 2015. ISBN 9781408339008
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Numbers, Family. Making numbers funny is quite a task, and Child achieves it with ease as her two protagonists Charlie and Lola get ready to go to the shops with Mum. She gives them ten minutes to get ready, but when Charlie works out all the things she must do in those ten minutes and how long each will take, she is nine minutes short. On the way to the shops, Lola asks how many ducks are following them, and the birds are counted, then the leaves in the tree. From single digits, one, two or three trucks, to tens of things to millions and squillions, each number is given a thing to be, ensuring the reader understands how big that number is in what it represents. A wonderful way to reinforce numbers and counting.
After their one hundred and fifty six steps to the shops, the girls debate what they are able to buy: is it one thing or two things. Mum gives them the choice of no thing, so one is settled. They then take eleven minutes to make up their minds, and when home, after Lola has used up all her stickers sticking them on a variety of numbered things in the street, debate whether Lola will have one of three badges from Charlie, and after being offered no thing, happily takes one thing, the title of the book.
This is a delight, I loved the way Child shows the number in numerical and written form, with the sequences of numbers one each page, the smallest to the largest being represented in a way younger readers will understand. It will be an infectious read, one children will want to hear read out loud to them over and over again. I laughed each time I read it, finding more things to look at, picking out more and more detail in the enticing illustrations.
Fran Knight

Counting lions by Katie Cotton

cover image

Ill. by Stephan Walton. Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2015. ISBN 9781847807212
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Animals, Endangered animals, Illustrative technique. A seemingly simple counting book with the most engaging illustrations of animals so close hairs can be counted, the very fact that these animals can be counted points to many being endangered or having reduced numbers as Virginia McKenna makes clear in her informative introduction.
Each of the animals represented reflects a different environment and way of life, and the almost poetic text points out some of their features which younger children will delight in, but sometimes a question at the end of each piece of text will increase their sensitivity to the plight of these animals.
So one lion stares at the reader, sitting in its place in the savannah, watching his rough and tumble pride, content to watch and wait. Then two gorillas, three giraffes, four tigers and five elephants, followed by six Ethiopian wolves, seven penguins, eight turtles, nine macaws and ten zebras invite the curious reader to read the text and look more closely at the glorious pencil illustrations. At the end of the book is a fact file about each animal's place in the world and here the endangered or threatened position of each is given.
What a wonderful counting book, introducing young children to the numbers one to ten and encouraging them to count the animals on each page. What a beautiful book to discuss illustration, but what an informative book for the curious, the questioning, those who wonder why these beautiful animals are threatened and question what can be done. One child will use this as a tool to learning to count, small groups of readers will love looking at this together, classes will use this as an introduction to their work about endangered animals.
Fran Knight

The singing bones by Shaun Tan

cover image

Foreword by Philip Pullman. Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760111038
(Age: 8 to adult) Highly recommended, Grimm's fairytales, Sculpture. A foreword by Philip Pullman sets the scene. He would rather see the stories of the Grimm Brothers presented without illustrations, than repeat the soft and pretty images of books in the past. But seeing Tan's sculptures of the grotesque and weird creatures, he is satisfied that here is someone who is able to reveal these tales for what they are.
With that forward in mind, opening this beautifully presented book of Tan's sculptures set alongside excerpts from each of seventy five tales, is quite mesmerising.
Dipping in I found some favourites: Brier Rose, Six Swans, Snow White, The Juniper Tree and so on, while I came across some I have not heard of: The Three Snake Leaves, The Bearskin, The Lettuce Donkey to name a few.
Each story is presented in a few paragraphs, and the facing page has a stunning photograph of Tan's sculpture about that story.
Amongst the many which stand out for me is Rapunzel. The brief outline tells us of this beautiful young girl having to let her hair down for the sorceress to enter the high tower. The long slim piece of clay stretches skyward, and only the small round face on top shows us that this is Rapunzel, her hair falling straight down to the ground. What sorrow and imprisonment is shown in this tiny image. No Disneyfied young woman with luxuriating tresses leaning out of her window for the handsome prince below, only a girl detained without hope of escape. Bearskin was a story I had not heard before, so I read a complete version in my Maurice Sendak copy of Grimm's Tales (The Juniper Tree, 1973) to find out about a soldier who while good at fighting has no way of supporting himself during peace. Someone offers to support him for seven years but he must not cut his hair or change his clothes nor pray. The soldier eventually realises the devil is waiting for him to slip up and take his soul. An amazing story of courage and resilience, of temptation and honouring one's parents, Tan's sculpture looks like a piece of carved wood, with the soldier's face peering out from the enveloping bearskin. Readers will have lots to think about when looking at the little piece, wondering why it is presented in this way.
Grimm's Tales, so much a part of Western literature, exemplify the basic tenets underlying life, be they sins like greed or envy, or virtues like looking past appearance or honouring promises. These stories are given a different aura through Tan's work: his curious creatures will make readers think, setting aside illustrators of the past who have seen fit to gentrify them.
An introduction by scholar, Jack Zipes, gives a potted history of the Grimm Brothers and their work, and is followed by an extensive bibliography with summaries of the stories and words by Shaun Tan outlining the influences on his enigmatic work. A book to be savoured: one that will add a difference to any study of Grimm's Tales in the classroom.
Fran Knight