Reviews

Star! Stable! Saviour! The Christmas Story in S by Cameron Semmens

cover image

Ill. by Rod Allen. Wombat Books, 2015. ISBN 9781925139600
(Age: Pre-school - Yr 2) If you like to start the festive season with a story about the story behind the celebrations, then Star! Stable! Saviour! could be a great choice. Drawing on the traditional elements of the Wise Men (scientists) and the shepherds seeing a star and following it to the stable where they find Baby Jesus the story is told using as many words as possible starting with the sound of 's'.
'See - a star!' stated a slightly stunned, smart, snazzy scientist to several similar smart, snazzy scientists.
These scientists from The South Saudi Sands, Sudan (or somewhere similar) searched the stars for signs.
This strange star was certainly a sign.
See it shine!'
With bright, clear illustrations which capture so much movement and expression, the story is told in alliterative format which brings new life to it so even those who have heard it every year about this time will get a fresh perspective and enjoy it again and again. Originally published under the title The Star, The Stable and The Saviour it's been repackaged and republished by Wombat Books in time to bring a new version to the traditional Christmas literature fare in a quirky but respectful way.
This will be read on Day 2 of the Christmas Countdown at my school, following The First Christmas in which Jan Pienkowski has illustrated the original text from the New Testament so those children who may be encountering the story for the first time can consolidate what they learned from that experience. Told without a religious editorial, it gives those students for whom Christmas is not a religious or traditional festival an understanding of what it is we celebrate at this time of the year, the meaning behind many of the symbols they see and why it is so important to so many.
Barbara Braxton

The light that gets lost by Natasha Carthew

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408835869
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Trey is no Harry Potter, even though his English parents were murdered in front of him as a small child. This story is set 8 years later and there's no sugar coating the events that shaped the orphaned teenager in foster homes, which bring him finally to a reformatory. Trey's hard luck story has led him to arson and finally to incarceration with other young offenders, at Camp Kernow, which is managed by the infamous preacher. Some of it has been deliberate - Trey's plan to exact revenge on his parents' murderer if not society in general.
Among the jailers and inmates, Trey finds both bullies and comrades but he confides in no one. Lamby, his unlikely side-kick, deliberately takes a beating requiring medical attention, in order to blow the whistle on the illegal activities of the cult running the camp. When the preacher and his cronies flee, the camp becomes almost dystopian under the thug, Wilder, Preacher's illegitimate son.
Trey and his band, united by their inner strength to do what's right despite their circumstances, must escape when it becomes clear that the outside world, itself in decay, is not coming to their rescue.
The geeky Lamby and Trey's love interest, the very level-headed Kay, prove calming influences. Through affecting imagery, Carthew captures the inner turmoil that besieges a protagonist conflicted by hatred and intent on reprisal. With few rays of hope in this dark narrative, young adults will appreciate how events and characters can influence us in negative ways unless we fulfil our destiny in service of others.
Deborah Robins

Wordburger by David Astle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2015
ISBN 9781760113575
(Age:9+) Highly recommended. Wordburger is an engaging look at the world of words. Children will become word acrobats as they reorganise letters to make new words. They can read chapter 7 to find word origins and investigate words with double meanings. Wordburger will engage any reader who enjoys words and it will be a good book for parents and children to read and talk about together. It is a good book to keep in the car for long road trips or to add to the collection on the toilet windowsill. I have a friend with an eclectic collection of books on her toilet windowsill who would love this one for her collection! It would also be a good book to read to students due to the variety of different chapters and topics. This is highly recommended for anyone who loves finding out about words. Readers aged 9+ will be able to negotiate the different topics easily as it is clearly set out with titles and subtitles, images, captions and little challenges for the readers to complete.
Kylie Kempster

Pivot and win by B. Hellard and L. Gibbs

cover image

Netball Gems series. Ill. by Cat Macinnes. Random House Australia Children's, 2015. ISBN: 9780857987686
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Netball, Teamwork, Family Life. Netball Gems is a junior fiction series written in collaboration with Netball Australia. Authors and sisters Lisa Gibbs and Bernadette Hellard are experienced A-grade level netball players and supported the sport as coaches and umpires. Each of the books introduces one Marrang Gems player and focuses on her family life and skill development. Hot tips, drills and a player profile are included at the end of the novel.
Twelve year-old Lily Scott's family is passionate about netball, she dreams of playing for the Diamonds in the future. One problem she faces is her height; will she ever be tall enough for a professional team? Her mother Janet coaches their team and she provides great support for all the players, her daughter as well. Lilly and her team mates practice the pivot and super-pivot move, while passing the ball smoothly down the court. 'Catch, spin, pass,' the girls repeat as they work on their game plan.
At home, Steven, a typical thirteen-year-old brother, is up to his usual tricks, playing pranks on Lily and hiding her things. Lily and her friend Phoebe work out a plan to settle the score that involves frozen tennis shorts!
This fun series is just right for netball fans, who are keen to learn more about the sport. Black and white graphic drawings by Cat Macinnes display Lily's netball moves.
Rhyllis Bignell

Glenn Maxwell: State Showdown and World Domination by Patrick Loughlin

cover image

Random House, 2015. ISBN 9780857988881
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Glenn Maxwell: State Showdown and World Domination is two books in one and both books are about cricket. In State Showdown, the main character is Will, an up and coming Victorian cricket star who has made it to the Youth Team. He is very skilled and very confident. He is very supportive of all his team mates but his constant reminding of how to play better cricket is not going down well with his team. Will his confidence be his downfall? Can Will learn from his team instead of trying to tell them how to play? In World Domination, Will makes it to the Australian Youth team and is off to compete in England. The team is made up of players Will has played against before so relationships aren't great and when he is made captain of the team these issues become more real. Can the players all learn to get along and become a winning team or will their rivalry turn them into enemies instead?
Glenn Maxwell: State Showdown and World Domination is highly recommended to cricket fans aged 9+. They will love the cricket talk and the cricket action. The stories move quickly though short chapters and the books themselves are approximately 100 pages long with a good sized font supporting them as an easy read. It is a great book for readers who are just starting to read novels.
Kylie Kempster

Ugly by Robert Hoge

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2015. ISBN 9780733634338
(Age: 10+) It has taken me a while to get to review this Younger Readers' version of Robert Hoge's successful memoir. My Year 8 students have been working on an English task which was to research and write a feature article about an inspirational hero and one of my young ladies had chosen Robert because she had started reading his memoir. I had just received this review copy so handed it to her in case she might find it helpful as well. Not only does the book come with her recommendation, she was so delighted that Robert responded to her email to him and she has been able to ask him questions directly. What a generous human! Thank you Robert - you provided this wonderful young girl with an amazing learning experience!
Today I spent a very pleasant hour or so reading this funny and moving, honest and courageous recollection of growing up as the 'ugly' kid. Robert's story is by now pretty well known to many adults who have either learned about his life via the book or the media but this new edition will bring his inspirational story to a whole new readership.
When Robert was born with severe physical problems including a large facial tumour, his family's life changed in many respects but not in the most important aspect. They were still a loving, supportive unit who when faced with a challenge rose to it with an admirable and enviable ease.
But let's not make light of this. This is an incredible story - of not only a wonderful human being but an exceptional family.
Do yourself a favour and read it. Better still put this on your shelves! The Younger Reader version is eminently suitable for readers of around 10 and up.
Check out Robert's website here  and teaching notes here.
Sue Warren

Itty Bitty Kitty by Joan Holub

cover image

Ill. by James Birks. HarperCollins, 2015. ISBN 9780062322197
(Age: Pre-school - Yr 2) Like many little people, Ava's greatest wish is to have a pet of her own but her parents believe she is too small. Besides, with a new baby and her dad's work her parents are busy enough already. However, Ava is not deterred and when she finds a "furry purry, snuggly huggly, cutie patootie itty bitty kitty" abandoned in a box near the seat at the end of her street she thinks her dreams have come true. Even though she wants her parents' permission, they're too busy to listen and so she decides to keep Itty Bitty a secret. He was just what she wanted but sadly he didn't stay itty-bitty for long - he was a very hungry kitty - and the damage bills kept mounting. Disaster strikes when he escapes from her room and he 'scared the fish, broke a dish, chased a bug, clawed the rug, leaped from a cupboard and got DISCOVERED!" Ava is devastated and it seems that Itty Bitty Kitty is to be abandoned yet again until.
This is a story that will appeal to young readers, particularly those who empathise with Ava in their own quest for a pet, but also because of the internal rhyme structures in places that give the text a lyrical rhythm. There is no repetitive phrase for them to anticipate and shout out but the story moves along at a fast clip and the ending, while predictable, is satisfying. The illustrations are big and bright and bold, almost cartoon-like, and right from the front cover it is clear that this is anything but an itty bitty kitty setting up the reader for a story of contradiction!
While Joan Holub as an author is new to me, she is cited as being the " New York Times bestselling author of Mighty Dads. She is also author and/or illustrator of over 130 books for children, including author of the picture books Little Red Writing and Zero the Hero, and co-author of the bestselling Goddess Girls and Grimmtastic Girls chapter book series." There is a new Itty Bitty Kitty adventure due early next year.
Barbara Braxton

Symphony for the City of the Dead by M. T. Anderson

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2015. ISBN 9780763668181
(Ages 14+) Highly Recommended. Biography. It is the 1920s, and Dmitri Shostakovich is a young and gifted musician. His appearance, however, is not inspiring: he's thin, weak; with glasses and a nerdiness which sets him apart. He is polite to a fault, won't stand up for himself, and meekly accepts every criticism. But Shostakovich can do something no one else can: he can compose music that is bold and innovative; that speaks to people. He is part of a colourful rebellion in art that has swept through Bolshevik Russia. But Shostakovich's music is under threat from a force of evil that controls every aspect of Russian life - the rule of 'Comrade' Stalin. Yet Stalin is not Shostakovich's only threat, because Hitler has his eyes set on Shostakovich's home city of Leningrad.
The city is crippled when the Nazis cut off supply lines and the harsh Russian winter sets in. People are trapped in Leningrad, Shostakovich included, - but Shostakovich comes up with an unusual way to support the war effort: he composes a symphony. He toils on amid the bombs, deaths and rationing to describe all the pain and suffering, the hardship and the comradery of the citizens in his music. This is his masterwork in the making, but one thing weighs on Shostakovich's mind: its premiere will either be a morale-boosting triumph for Leningrad, or a life-jeopardising tragedy.
M. T. Anderson's witty and easy-to-read biography of the great composer is a stunning work. Constructed from the limited information available about Shostakovich, this biography is a unique blend of music and history. It is the emotional story of kindness, humility, love and suffering - both of one man, and a whole nation. The story jumps wildly from humorous success, to deep personal tragedy. I found it at times gripping, and at others entertaining. Anderson's careful mixture of fact and narrative makes Symphony for the City of the Dead an enjoyable and engaging read.
Thomas B. (Student)

The Doldrums by Nicholas Gannon

cover image

Greenwillow Books, 2015. ISBN 9780062320940
(Age: 10-12) Recommended. The Doldrums is not only the name of the local newspaper in the novel but also the state of Archer's mind.
Archer is a Helmsley and his grandparents are famous world adventurers. He lives in their home with his parents. The house is full of stuffed animals (who Archer communicates with) and collections and curios from around the world.
It is The Doldrums Press that announces that his grandparents have gone missing on an iceberg. Archer's mother recognizes the dreamer/ adventurer in him too and fearing the worst, forbids him to leave the house except for school.
Trapped in his own home Archer reaches out to Oliver his not so adventurous next-door neighbour and Adelaide a French girl with a story of her own. Together they plan to escape on their own expedition.
This is a gentle, whimsical story. The back-stories of the main characters and their developing friendship are central to the novel. Between them, the children have to deal with bullying, parental over-protection or neglect and being different.
The final chapters have a 'chase' ending with a mixture of excitement and humour.
The binding, jacket and illustrations give the novel a 'just right' old world feel, very like the Helmsley's own home.
The use of creams, burgundies and dark green used by the author in colour plates interspersed throughout the book, give a richness to the illustrations.
This is Nicolas Gannon's first book and I feel it will appeal to children in their middle primary years about 10 to 12 years old.
Nicolas Gannon has a beautiful website to go with his novel and has made a book trailer about The Doldrums.
I recommend this book for purchase.
Jane Moore

Death and Co: Fault Lines by D. J McCune

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781471402715
(Age: Teens) Fault lines is the final book in the Death and Co trilogy written by D.J McCune. Adam Mortson is part of Britain's leading Luman family. The Lumans are charged with leading the dead to the afterlife. Adam's brothers easily slip in to their role as guides to the light; however Adam struggles to comprehend his own role. He is torn between two very different worlds, one where he wants to go to school, hang out with his friends and struggle to pass tests and get his very first girlfriend; however his life as a Luman is slowly beginning to overpower any other option. Adam Mortson is a sandy haired, blue eyed, fifteen year old, with an extra-ordinary gift. He is able to see a person's death before it actually happens, and on a school trip to Japan this gift allows Adam to pre-empt a tsunami that will kill thousands of people. This one event will change his life and that of his friends . . . But only if they survive.
This enthralling novel is told from the perspective of Adam as he goes through many life changing decisions. The major themes that present themselves throughout the novel are death, friendship, and family. I would recommend this novel to teenagers who enjoy reading fantasy or mythology novels.
Emily Madden

The secret chord by Geraldine Brooks

cover image

Hachette, 2015. ISBN 9780733632174
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. Historical. King David. Biblical times. Violence. Pulitzer Prize winner author, Geraldine Brooks has brought to life the story of the biblical King David in this compelling tale bridging his life as a young boy, as a fighter, a hero, a stately king and finally an old man who has been corrupted by power. It is told in the words of the prophet Natan, who was close to David from the time when David took him from the village where everyone else had been slaughtered to the time of his death.
Brooks tells a violent and cruel story as the reader is taken on a compelling and enthralling voyage through the Second Iron Age. David was a neglected and abused shepherd boy when he faced down the giant Goliath and won. From then he becomes a leader and soldier and ultimately king. Brooks doesn't flinch from descriptions of the violence of the times. Battles and murders are described in detail and the reader is sometimes left reeling from the slaughter and cruelty that occurred. The power that David wielded as a king was enormous, and gradually he began to abuse it, taking what he wanted without regard to his loyal friends or the feelings of those around him. David is not only seen through the eyes of Natan, but through the eyes of his wives Mikhal, Avigail, and Batsheva and their stories leave an emotional impact.
The often beautiful and lyrical language made it a stand out read for me. David's strengths and flaws are brought to life, by writing of an author at the top of her game.  Right from the first page the descriptions are so vivid and graphic that even though many of David's actions are indescribably painful, it is impossible not to continue reading.
Brooks' has a fascinating afterword where she describes how her son's decision to learn the harp lead to her decision to research and write about David, and indeed she lists many scholarly works as her inspiration as well as the Bible.
This is not always an easy read, due to the corruption, violence and bloodshed, but ultimately it is a rewarding and unforgettable one.
Pat Pledger

The big Book of Mr Badger by Leigh Hobbs

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760112431
(Age: 6-10) Highly recommended. Four of the Mr Badger stories can be found in this one big volume that is sure to delight readers new to Mr Badger as well as those who already love his adventures. The stories are: Mr Badger and the big surprise, Mr. Badger and the difficult Duchess, Mr Badger and the missing ape and Mr Badger and the magic mirror.
Mr Badger is the highly organised and capable manager of special events at the Boubles Grand Hotel and he has some amazing adventures, saving a special birthday party, finding a missing ape, looking after a difficult duchess and going through a magic mirror. All the characters are well rounded and Mr Badger is delightful, a wonderful father who never misses reading his children their bedtime story even though he has had an exhausting and adventurous day at the hotel.
This collection of stories is ideal for the newly independent reader who is ready to tackle chapter books and the size will give these children a thrill as they read each story and finally get to page 294! The humour and quirky illustrations are a delight and an adult reading these aloud will also have a very enjoyable time imagining the hotel and London surrounds.
Pat Pledger

These shallow graves by Jennifer Donnelly

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBBN 9781471405150
(Age 13+) Recommended. New York City. 1890. Jo Montfort is used to a life of ease - rich and pretty, she is expected to marry a young man from her class and become a society hostess. But this is not what Jo wants - she loves to write and dearly wishes to become a reporter like Nellie Bly, who spent 10 days in a mad house and described what happened to her. When Jo's father is found dead in his study shot with his own pistol, it is ruled a suicide, but some things just don't match up and Jo, with the help of handsome Eddie, a reporter at her father's newspaper, decides to investigate. Secrets are uncovered, seedy neighbourhoods are visited and deadly danger is faced while the dirty truth is uncovered.
The stand out aspect of this novel for me was the in-depth research that had gone into the life and times of New York in 1890. Donnelly brings the period to life, describing the rich and idle young women who are desperate for wealthy husbands, the rules constricting women of all classes from reaching their potential, the contrasts between the rich and the poor, the desperate children who are forced into crime and the shipping empires of the times. The new science of forensics is also explored and will thrill readers who like those details in their crime novels. The author has used real historical characters like Nellie Bly and this is sure to engage the reader's interest and could provide an incentive to do some follow-up research.
Although it is 487 pages long, each chapter is quite short and easy to read, and the narrative flow along very smoothly, building up suspense as the reader is dragged into the dangerous world that Jo and Eddie are investigating. Jo is a very engaging heroine and the reader becomes emotionally involved with her struggle to become something more than a wife and to overcome the prejudices of the times. Eddie is a heroic figure as well and the growing feelings between the two highlight the problems that people from different classes have if they fall in love.
This is certainly a book that readers of historical crime will devour as well as fans of Donnelly's other books: the award winning Gathering light, Revolution and the Waterfire saga.
Pat Pledger

Space Dumplins by Craig Thompson

cover image

Faber & Faber, 2015. ISBN 9780571303083
Recommended. Nothing is left to the imagination in Space Dumplins. This book is a vibrant, glossy pictorial, written and illustrated with a passion that will enthral the reader to the last page. It's totally gripping, mesmerising fun.
Would you like to visit Shell-Tarr? It's the ultimate in astral comfort and security, top of the line in luxury and modern tech.
Or perhaps you'd like to take a wild ride in one of the out-of-this-world space machines, the zooming Burger Bus, or Muskellunge Trike, each of audacious design with exciting, gadgetry that no intrepid space kid could resist. Could you deal with the challenges of the Lumpkins or Jirglebytes, something that looks like an enormous crayfish, or the ghastly Spill - a flood of green, slimy whale diarrhea! Ugh!
Violet lives with her mum and dad in a futuristic space environment that author, Craig Thompson, has dazzlingly conjured up from his fertile imagination. Violet's mum works in the zany fashion industry and her dad, Big G, harvests whale 'timber' for energy nuggets. The guardian robot, Chaperdrone, looks suspiciously female and tries, mostly in vain, to keep Violet and her new friend, Elliot, the bright little chicken button-runner, in check. Zacchaeus, another tough little character, joins in as the three rocket from one adventure to the next as the trio face peculiarly earth-related problems.
Then Gar (Big G) goes missing and the three find themselves on a very dangerous mission through the somewhat decrepit environment of smashed-up earth junk and debris, as they try to find and rescue Violet's missing dad. Tension causes emotions to boil over as the likeable trio try desperately to escape from the Mucky Way? After all, it's the largest garbage deposit in the galaxy.
You'll find the text easy-to-read, and when you've finished share it with your little brother or sister. Guaranteed to keep them quiet longer than usual, but don't read it to them just before bedtime!
J Kerr-Smith

Dork Diaries: Puppy Love by Rachel Renee Russell

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2015. ISBN 9781471144578
(Age: 7-9) Recommended. This is the 10th book in the series of Dork Diaries. The series that follows the life of Nikki Maxwell.
It was a week ago since Mackenzie, Nikki's arch enemy, moved to the very fancy North Hampton Hills International Academy. Nikki's dream had come true.
Nikki loves every second without Mackenzie until she meets her at the Cupcakery and starts to make trouble with her new friends. Nikki and Brandon have another problem. Fuzzy Friends Animal Rescue Center can't take any more animals. What should Nikki and Brandon do?
Brandon and Nikki hide some dogs from 2 strict parents, 1 crazy little sister and an entire middle school.
What will happen when Mackenzie and Nikki meet again?
I enjoyed this book. I recommend this book for ages 7-11. There are interesting cartoons which add humor and gives you a picture of what is happening. I rate this book: 9 stars out of ten
Amelia W. (year 5)