Reviews

Beck by Mal Peet with Meg Rosoff

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406331127
(Age: Adults - senior secondary). Highly recommended. Warning: Violent sex scene. Reading this novel is like being plunged deep into a maelstrom. The writers take us back in time to the devastatingly poor world of the early 1900s. Here a woman and a man come together briefly, she using her body simply to make enough money to feed her child and herself, he a lonely sailor in a foreign port. This is unflinchingly told - as we learn that she is not a prostitute, but her body was the only means left to enable her survival.
This is a bald tale, as the writers establish from the start. After his mothers death and his horrifyingly harsh early years, Beck is put on a boat that will take him to Canada, for what reason he is utterly unaware. The Catholic brothers, who take in the orphans, are apparently generous and kind, feeding and clothing the boys in readiness for their going out into the world to find work. At this point it seems to be a world of some degree of decency. However, the one scene, so vividly described it feels like one is watching it on stage, and indeed plays back in the mind like one - reverberated in the days following my reading. The child Beck, with little knowledge of anything in the world, is treated so horrifyingly that it stayed vivid, coloured by deep emotions, disgust and anger.
The scene is left as a dread noose that colours Becks life. Yet, bravely told, this tale, of the potential for immense human cruelty and indeed of disdain for others, is a new genre of a literary story that leaps away from the heart-warming story genre into the reality genre. The writers lift the story up from this point, and draw vividly, the dark world of early European settlement in the wilds of Canada, where the struggle to survive is hard enough, while to do more, to thrive, seems an impossibility, especially for a young black boy who is utterly alone in the world.
This novel is a tale of a harsh world, offering almost no hope for the protagonist, but somehow the writers manage to keep us entranced, desperate as we might be to find a glow of goodness that is not fake, and indeed keep us reading with hope through to the end. Our hero's life begins, towards the end, to be turn, and indeed the end is a balm for the bruised spirit.
I could not recommend it for young readers. It is far too brutal, too shocking in its revelations of our human capacity for evil, for young readers. It took me days to stop replaying some of the scenes, and I ached for days afterwards in thinking about the characters and the world of this text, its absolutely grueling severity and the harsh struggle to survive. As I write I notice that Canada and the northern US states are plunged into another polar vortex, with temperatures of up to minus 20C. I have been in that part of the world in minus 45C - in the modern world this is bearable, but back in the days of this novel, it would have been almost impossible to survive. It is a book one lives through and it is worthwhile, perhaps transformative, in the end.
Liz Bondar

Sachiko: A Nagasaki bomb survivor's story by Caren Stelson

cover image

Carolrhoda Books, 2016. ISBN 9781467789035
(Aged 12+) Highly recommended. Themes: War; Conflict; Resilience; Peace; Nagasaki. If war was only about winning and losing, we would not know this story. Sachiko's story is the story of loss, of finding a voice in the face of incredible difficulty, of survival despite the overwhelming weight of the impossible cloud of despair and it is a story of resilience. Sachiko is one of the few who survived the Nuclear holocaust that resulted when the nuclear bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. Why she survived is a mystery considering how close she was to its epicentre, but the opportunity we have is to hear her words and wisdom, and to grow in our understanding of the personal cost at the individual level when war is waged against nations. Sachiko's tale is a painful yet uplifting story of her personal growth in the face of adversity, of the consolation and wisdom she gained from her family and the words of Gandhi, Dr Martin Luther-King and even of Helen Keller. These influences infiltrated her own response to the tragedies that did not just touch her, but swamped her life in ways that defy our ability to understand. It is our responsibility as we hear her story to consider our own response to world issues and to ponder how we can protect other children from the devastation that conflict brings. Sachiko took a long time to find her voice after the events of 1945 . . . it is a story that is worth hearing. It is also a testament to those that did not survive.
Caren Stelson has written this book as a narrative non-fiction, with Sachiko's story told with historical excerpts and analysis scattered alongside the personal accounts. These non-fiction accounts are well-referenced, and written with simple clarity to make this history accessible for a younger reader, as well as interested adults. Stelson has used transcripts from Sachiko's memories and added her own research to confirm details of the events of this time. Sachiko (through Caren Stelson) is an honourable contributor to the history of World War II and its conclusion, and her accounts are worthy of our respect. Current younger readers and students could read this book alongside the well-known story of Sadako and the Thousand Paper Cranes by Eleanor Coerr. This book contains excellent photographs including some from Sachiko's own personal history.
Carolyn Hull

Owl Bat Bat Owl by Marie-Louise Fitzpatrick

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406364392
Themes: Wordless Picture Book; Differences. A family of owls (is that a small 'parliament'?) settles for the day in a tree. Their rest is interrupted by the arrival of a family of bats. There is room for them all as one group is up, and the other down, but owl mother creates some distance by moving her family away from the intruders. The smallest of each animal species seems to connect to one another to the distress of the parents. A wild wind disturbs their rest and both parents realise that they are alike in being concerned for their family's safety. Over a series of pages, the two family groups connect again, with the two youngest forging the way to a nocturnal friendship.
All of this action happens through simple illustrations involving the wide eyed owls and inverted bats (or are they the right way up, and the owls are inverted?) As with many wordless picture books, this book is one where a pre-reader could tell the story to an adult listener; which makes this a great book to encourage conversation and observation. (Speech therapists might like to add this book to their collection.) On a more mature level, this could be used to begin a discussion about migration and what keeps us apart and draws us together in human society.
Carolyn Hull

Chronologica compiled by the Whittaker's Almanack Team

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472932945
(Age: 10+) Recommended, History, Non fiction. Subtitled The incredible years that defined history, this massive tome is a fascinating book to dip into and read about an event which readers may not know a lot about. Beginning with 753 BC, and travelling through the execution of Joan of Arc in 1431, shipwreck of the Batavia in 1629, the first hot air balloon in 1783, to the Fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, each year covered, and there are a hundred of them, has several pages devoted to it. The topics covered are as varied as they are different, as interesting as they are entertaining, and they all point to the importance of that year.
Each page offers an illustration pertinent to the text, and a page of text for kids to read, giving a potted overview of the topic. Each of the one hundred dates chosen represents an incredible year in world history, be it the Cornish Rebellion of 1497, 1796 and the first vaccinations, 1895 seeing the first Nobel Peace Prizes being awarded, or 1846 when the first saxophone is patented. The list of things recounted is so varied, it is hard to put a finger on why each is included, or what may follow. But always interesting, intriguing and informative, this book will be read by those kids who hang out looking for facts to read and entertain themselves and others. There was always a bunch of them looking at the almanacks and Guinness books of Records and so on in my library, and this will be eagerly included.
Fran Knight

The nutcracker by E.T.A. Hoffman

cover image

Ill. by Robert Ingpen. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781922244550
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Christmas, Classic tale, The Nutcracker, Friendship. This wonderful edition of the well known story, the basis for Tchaikovsky's loved Christmas ballet, The Nutcracker, is given in its entirety, translated from Hoffman's original German story by Anthea Bell and given a brilliantly enticing new set of illustrations by the marvelous Robert Ingpen, to celebrate its bicentenary. Children and adults alike will thrill to the complete story offered here, set alongside seventy glorious illustrations, reminding them of Christmases long past, of half remembered stories of the nutcracker.
When her parents' good friend, Mr Drosselmeier gives Marie and her brother a nutcracker for Christmas, Marie loves the little figure. Her impatient brother throws it in the corner when one of his big teeth is cracked, but Marie cradles him and puts him in the special place with her other toys.
Unbeknownst to her, Mr Drosselmeier has given the figure to Marie for a reason, one he cannot tell anyone. He once built a mousetrap so well that all the mice in the town had been trapped and removed from the place. The mice then cursed his nephew and only he knows what can take away that curse.
When Marie is about to go to bed, mice invade the room with her toys, demanding she feed them or they will eat up her nutcracker. She complies but when she runs out of food, she turns to see the nutcracker and the other toys lined up to defeat the mice. She wakes the next morning, confused and upset to see that her nutcracker has gone. But Mr Drosselmeier returns that day with his nephew and Marie realises who he is and takes him as her friend.
This beautiful story of friendship is complemented with Ingpen's sumptuous illustrations, soft edged and glowingly detailed.
This is a beautiful story to read at Christmas, reminding children that love and friendship are precious and will outlive all the toys they are given. This edition includes a biography of Hoffman and celebrates his influence on fantasy writing, while the tale written in 1816, includes a story rarely seen, The story of the hard nut, which tells the reader how the nutcracker came to be.
This is a magical production and deserves to be shared.
Fran Knight

The anti-Boredom Christmas book by Andy Seed

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing Place, 2016. ISBN 9781408870105
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. The Anti-Boredom Christmas Book is full of activities to make sure readers do not get bored over Christmas. It has some hilarious activities and is full of jokes, facts, quizzes and other stuff. Each chapter is themed and readers can learn how to make some simple Christmas crafts, challenge their sister to a Christmas quiz or make dad laugh with some Christmas jokes. There are plenty of discussion pages as well which will make for some fun conversations. They include asking questions of family members and getting them to choose Christmas things they prefer. Readers can learn some new games like 'Table Tinker' where someone makes changes to the Christmas table and the other guests have to guess what is different. Try a game of Fangman (a take on the traditional Hangman) where players draw a vampire face to 'hang' the players as they guess the wrong letters. Highly recommended for all readers aged 8+. This book would make a great stocking filler and could also be used in the classroom. Students or teachers could choose an activity to do each day in the lead up to the end of the school year and Christmas.
Kylie Kempster

Crooked Kingdom by Leigh Bardugo

cover image

Six of Crows bk 2. Indigo, 2016. ISBN 9781780622309
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction (2016). The stunning sequel to Six of crows, see Kaz Brekker and his crew fighting for their lives. They have been double-crossed and Kaz is determined to have his revenge. In a series of daring heists, they are fighting for their lives and Kaz needs every bit of his cunning and intelligence to find out about the deadly drug known as jurda parem and to bring some peace to his team.
Once again the world building in Crooked Kingdom is outstanding. The city of Ketterdam is brought to life, with its canals, warehouses, merchants and people making a fabulous background to the adventures of the six young people.
The daring exploits of the crew keep the reader totally engrossed as they break into houses, fool dangerous people and fight off their foes. The action is breathtaking but so is the characterisation. Each chapter is told by one of the six characters and it is done so well that the reader has no problem following such a large group of main characters as well as a plethora of minor ones.
The characteristics of each person are richly elaborated, with details of each person's background and reason for being in Ketterdam gradually evolving as their story is told. Kaz of course is central to the story and Bardugo leaves us very satisfied with how he evolves. Of course with such a large cast and with so much danger to contend with, there are some casualties on the way and lots of surprising twists as well.
This is an excellent sequel to Six of crows and I look forward to reading anything else that Leigh Bardugo writes in the future.
Pat Pledger

Dog on a digger: The tricky incident by Kate Prendergast

cover image

Old Barn Books, 2016. ISBN 9781910646144
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Kate Prendergast draws from her transport industry background creating detailed images of machinery set against an urban landscape filled with heavy machinery. This wordless picture book with detailed black and white pencil drawings with highlights of yellow and blue is a story of friendship, loyalty and thoughtfulness.
Dog lives with his owner in a caravan surrounded by trucks, heavy equipment and building supplies. The panoramic front spread highlights the urban landscape at night; an owl flies by watched by a city fox. Morning comes and dog wakes his master up with licks to the face, time to start the day; meanwhile the food truck's owner and her little white dog open up ready to sell hearty meals to the workers. Dog joins his master in the cab of the big yellow digger ready to move all the building rubble into the truck. Both of them wear yellow safety vests. The digger's scoop is humanised - bolts become eyes and the large mouth opens and closes eating up the rubble and scrap wood.
At morning teatime, Dog plays with the small white dog sharing a bowl of food, while their owners chat over a cup of tea. In an instant, the little canine disappears and Dog sets off in a hurried search climbing the stairs of the building next door to see where his friend has gone. With the aid of Dog's owner, he guides him to rescue the lost animal stuck in a grate beside the canal.
Dog on a digger is an enjoyable picture book, when shared with a class; students can add their own narrative, writing text in sticky notes on each page, developing a class book. Pet ownership and being responsible are topics for discussion as well. For Art, explore pencil sketching, highlighting one element in colour; introduce expressive drawing and humanising inanimate objects like Thomas the Tank Engine and the yellow digger.
Rhyllis Bignell

Girl in pieces by Kathleen Glasgow

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9781460751053
(Age: 15+) Recommended for mature readers. Charlie is really messed up. But so is everyone at Creeley, the health facility for girls who self-harm. Part One of Girl in Pieces chronicles their despair fuelled by anxiety or abuse of one kind or another. Charlotte (Charlie) is dealing with loss of her father in childhood and more recently, her best friend.
In Part Two, Charlie is thrust back into the tenuous reality of the outside world. She is not ready but both she and her counsellor, Casper, have prepared some strategies to avoid self-harm. Mickey, her childhood sweetheart, reaches out to her with a bus ticket and a new start interstate. Inevitably, Charlie's attraction to Riley, a musician and addict working with her in a coffee shop, can only lead to one thing.
The author, who has a history of self-harm, takes us on a journey of gradual understanding. Glasgow's insights into the thoughts of those who self-harm are palpable and full of wisdom. We come to know Charlie's own triggers for cutting and the horrific physiological consequences of cyclical self-loathing. The use of flashbacks confirm that she blames herself for attracting catastrophe.
Life keeps disappointing Charlie but in Part Three, the inclusion of her sketches in a local art show gives us hope that she can ultimately find peace in a world in which she has never felt welcome. The abiding message of this confronting First Person tome, is that you are not alone. You can choose self-annihilation of one kind or another and there'll be no shortage of company - or you can keep trying. Girl in Pieces provides insightful explanations for addiction of any kind, but the sub-text is the importance of mentors, artfully achieved from very well fleshed out and equally flawed but resilient characters.
Deb Robins

The song from somewhere else by A.F. Harrold

cover image

Ill. by Levi Pinfold. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408879337
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Fantasy. Bullying. Acceptance. Fear. Friendship. This is an amazing story of bullying and friendship, yet it also enters into the fantasy world that lives in parallel to our own world. Frank (or Francesca) is alone while her friend is away on holidays and her pet cat has gone missing. The story begins with an encounter with the local Junior School bully and his two goons while she is out putting up Missing Cat posters. Her fear rises and overtakes her until Nick, the big ostracised kid from her class, rescues her from another incident of humiliation. Unfortunately he is not a 'Prince Charming', but rather is the lumpish and large kid who is also the butt of everyone's jokes, and the one that everyone in class avoids because he smells. Without realising it, Frank becomes Nick's friend, and the connection between the two lonely kids is tightened by the mystical and magical music that floats from within Nick's house and which has a restorative influence on Frank, but is also part of the intrigue of the unusual Nick. This music entices Frank's curiosity, and she becomes acquainted with Nick's fantastic family secret. The tangles that this weaves are like shadows that creep around in the middle of the night, with the capacity to trip you over in the uncertainty of each step forward. Frank's encounters with the fantasy world raise her uncertainties about how to act; the moral dilemmas she has to face confront her with her selfishness and her struggles to be friends with the boy she formerly shunned. But the story ends well, despite her mistakes.
The black and white illustrations in this book are atmospheric and ethereal in some places, which adds a hint of mystery to the story. Although we have a fantasy tale at the heart of the story, it is also a 'real-life' tale of friendship, acceptance and the impact of fear. Frank's quirky family adds an element of humour to the otherwise dark mystery. There is nothing in here that would cause nightmares, but it is a moving tale of overcoming dark influences.
Carolyn Hull

The mountain who wanted to live in a house by Maurice Shadbolt

cover image

Ill. by Renee Haggo. Starfish Bay Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781760360030
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Humour. Mountains. Environment. Problem solving. As the mountain stares down at the people in the town, he is envious. People come to him to ski or have picnics, to climb and watch the birds in the trees, but he wants to be just like them and live in his own house where he would be protected from the cold and wind and ice and snow, and not be lonely. So one day with a yell, he begins to walk to the town. People become very anxious and drive away, or walk or paddle down the river. One boy, Thomas stands in front of the mountain to ask what he is doing, and finding that the mountain wants to live in a house, begins to discuss the problem with him.
He tells him about his mother sometimes washing his jumper only to find that it shrinks, so he heads off home for soap and water, but this doesn't work at all. Next he fetches a hammer and begins to chop bits off the mountain, but the mountain doesn't like this idea. At last the boy has a clever idea, and races back home to fetch his father to paint the mountain. In that way the mountain would fit into a house and be seen by everyone. So the mountain can stay where he is but also be in the house.
I really like this story of working together to find a solution to a problem. Readers could begin to discuss why things in the environment are where they are, and how we can protect them. They will enjoy the illustrations of the mountain's face peering out at the readers and could talk about how to go about painting a mountain scene. First published in New Zealand by Deep Creek Press in 2015.
Fran Knight

A dog like that! by Janene Cooper

cover image

Ill. by Evie Kemp. Starfish Bay Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781760360047
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Dogs. Pets. Comparisons. In this enticing book, each group of pages introduces a different dog and its owner and what it does best. Uncle's dog, a labrador, is clever and does what he is told, but the girl who owns the scruffy dog on the cover tells us that her dog is not like that. He does what he likes. Her Grandpa's dog is a watch dog, and keeps guard at night, but the scruffy dog sleeps. The neighbour's dog is fearsome, barking at all the other cats and dogs, but the girl's dog likes everyone and licks them all. Each dog is shown for something it does best, and the girl is told that all dogs should be like that. But as we read on we find that her dog is nothing like the other dogs: it sleeps with the girl, is happy to see everyone, is scruffy and rumpled, and unlike other dogs that leap and jump, her dog sits at the gate and waits for her.
Her dog knows when she is sad and licks her face, and stays in her room with her when she has done something wrong. And that is what dogs should be.
The bold illustrations have the reader looking straight into the face of the scruffy dog, comparing its behaviour with the other dogs and knowing which dog is the best. Each page uses one main colour with the dog prominently positioned by the words in a large font. It is a delight to read and look at the illustrations and I can imagine children reading it aloud, repeating the refrain, 'Dogs should be like that' with growing knowledge that the best dog is not like that at all. First published in New Zealand by Deep Creek Press in 2015.
Fran Knight

Why do cats have tails? by David Ling

cover image

Ill. by Stephanie Thatcher. Starfish Bay Children's Books, 2016 ISBN 9781760360085
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Cats. Pets. Problem solving. Surrounded by their family's cats the little girls ask their Grandpa why the cats have tails. Grandpa thinks up some wonderful reasons which will bring gales of laughter to the listening crowd. He suggests that they might use them to swing through the trees, but the girls tell him that this is the reason monkeys have tails. He then suggests that they could use them to swish away the flies, but the girls tell him that cows use their tails in this way. Perhaps the tail helps them swim faster, he says, but no, cats don't like to swim. Suppose the cat uses his tail as a warning, but no say the girls, rattlesnakes do that. Grandpa then asks the girls to offer a suggestion and this is one the readers will discuss as they finish the book. The pastel illustrations add warmth to the story, but are a little washed out in my review copy. I do like the cat's paw endpapers. First published in New Zealand by Deep Creek Press in 2015.
Fran Knight

Animasaurus: Incredible animals that roamed the Earth by Tracey Turner

cover image

Ill. by Harriet Russell. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408884850
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Animasaurus is a prehistoric compendium filled with fascinating facts about the plant-eaters, sea creatures, predators and creepy crawlies that once inhabited the Earth. Discover amazing information, their statistics, habitats, diet, size and weight and compare these with photos of modern day relatives.
Unusual dinosaurs not commonly known such as the Therizinosaurus lived on the Mongolian Plains 75 million years ago scared predators away with its metre long claws. The fossils of Gigantopithecus or giant ape were discovered in India and Southeast Asia. They grew to three metres in height, had big teeth just right for their vegetarian diet. Deep under the sea Cameroceras, nine-metre long shellfish with metre long tentacles and sharp beaks used a jet-propulsion swimming style to stalk their prey. Animals that are more familiar are included as well -Giant Kangaroos, Woolly Mammoths and Megaladons great white sharks.
Each double-page spread includes an introduction, exploration of the animal's features, a map, timeline and size comparison to a human. Centred on bold backgrounds of earth, sea and sky tones are Harriet Russell's simplistic creature drawings.
As part of the Earth and Space Science strand of the Australian Science curriculum, Animasaurus links to geological processes and history, the fossil record and past environmental conditions and changes over time. This non-fiction volume provides information suited to student research projects and enquiry-based learning. Fans of scientific encyclopaedias and budding palaeontologists will also enjoy this book.
Rhyllis Bignell

The last beginning by Lauren James

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406358063
(Age: 13+) Recommended. Clove Sutcliffe is determined to solve the mystery of Katherine and Matthew who vanished 16 years ago only to be reincarnated at every key point in history. As Clove follows her quarry from life to life, historical era to historical era, it seems that she too is being stalked. Ella is as enigmatic as the mysteries Clove must solve to unravel the past and secure her future.
The sequel to The Next Together, Lauren James's debut novel, The Last Beginning, is a fitting follow on. The characters are believable and the literary devices used at the beginning of each chapter add credibility and interest. The book also provides satisfying links with its prequel allowing for a truly satisfying conclusion.
Ros Lange