Reviews

Horizon by Scott Westerfeld

cover image

Scholastic, 2017. ISBN 9781743817605
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Science fiction, Survival, STEM. On a flight from the USA to Tokyo, eight teens on the plane are the only survivors when it crashes. But where they expect snow and ice, is jungle, with strange birds and even stranger noises. The eight must work together to work out what is happening to them, but this is difficult when the oldest in the group, Caleb, sees himself as the leader, and hates being questioned by the four from Brooklyn Science and Tech, en route to present their robots at the Robot Soccer World Championship in Tokyo. In particular Molly and he do not see eye to eye.
Yoshi goes off in search of water, while Molly experiments with the device she has found on the plane, something which appears to lift them off the ground. But once in the air they are attacked by shredder bird which tear into their clothing and skin, so they need to plan their journeys.
A wonderful story of methods used by the group to develop an hypothesis then work out a solution, this story is brimful of scientific argument and logic, as well as honing in on relationships and survival.
When some of the group leave to try and find out what its over the stone wall, the gravity machine comes in very handy to make their ascent easier. But hiding in a cave they are besieged by tiny robots, intent on stealing their mechanical objects. All is most curious until they find themselves inside a set of office like laboratories and they begin to work out where they are and what has happened, leading to an idea of how to get out.
This is a heart in the mouth story, Westerfeld cleverly leading the reader on making them try and work out what is happening, collecting evidence, using their reason to make deductions and hypotheses. But as they do not reach their destination at the end of this story, another story is in the pipeline. Westerfeld tells us that this is the first of seven books in the series, and is a mixture of Lost, Lord of the flies and Hatchet. This is easily accessible science fiction with the themes of survival and relationships uppermost putting the readers into the skin of the protagonists, drawing them into the lives on the page. I look forward to the next in the series.
Fran Knight

Beyond the wild river by Sarah Maine

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2017. ISBN 9781473639683
(Age: Senior secondary-adult) Recommended. This is a terrifically well researched novel, and the story, and indeed the plot, are finely wrought. I was captivated by the settings, described in rich detail, from the new city of Chicago to the wild lands and rivers of northern Ontario. Responding with violence to a burglar, one dark night on a Scottish estate, a man is killed, a story is constructed, and a very young Evelyn Ballantyre learns one version of events that she accepts but with both a sense of having been told what was best for her to know and a feeling that this version was not the true story.
From a Scottish estate to the wilds of Ontario, Maine captures a world of change, taking us from Scotland, on a sea voyage to the United States in 1893, where the characters visit the Columbian Exposition in Chicago, described in rich and fascinating detail, and then go into the wilds of Canada to inspect, we deduce, an investment of Evelyn's father. This is a fine section, introducing us to a little known area and history for most readers outside of Canada or the USA.
The story that ensues is a sequel, in a sense, to that terrible night on Evelyn's father's estate in Scotland. Strangely, and indeed oddly, it seems that the characters who were at the estate on the night of the murder have come together for a journey up the Nipigon River, in Northern Ontario, 13 years later. We realize that Ballantyne has controlled all of this, with the characters of the past all in close proximity for a trip that will be challenging.
Whilst it is not clear to us just what will happen, we are given plenty of clues so that we are aware that some kind of dramatic event will take place as the tension builds up day by day on that journey. The terrain is described in wonderful detail, the atmosphere of the Nipigon River and the campsites particularly featuring as places of wonder for the European visitors. We read about the way that campsites were positioned near the river, how the fish were caught, and we learn something of the indigenous people of that region. All of this is absolutely captivating.
That the conflict would be resolved is expected, but somehow the resolution is just a little tawdry, and the characters involved in it demeaned by the decisions. Yet in a sense the decisions and actions are consistent with the characterization. Just as we readers might have liked a happy ending, her resolution is consistent with her characterization. Her strengths are in this narrative consistency, in her richly detailed settings, and in her capacity to create a story that is reminiscent of its time, its place and the characters that she has created. This is a fine adult and older adolescent romantic and historical novel.
Elizabeth Bondar

Margherita's recipes for love by Elisabetta Flumeri and Gabriella Giacometti

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2017. ISBN 9781471162695
(Age: 15+) Well, this is a delicious read, a feast for the senses. The writers almost dare us to not relish or enjoy the food, the convoluted love stories, the solving of issues of love, loyalty and friendship all set in the delightful towns and countryside of Italy. Flumeri and Giacometti have previously written radio programs, novels and a number of screenplays. In this novel, they focus on food and love that are depicted as inextricably linked, choosing an ideal setting that is a feast for all the senses, the adventures mostly taking place in the enticing, glorious green hills, vineyards, old homes of the small towns of Tuscany.
The story has a complexity that is used to build up the requisite tension, and the outcome, while perhaps predictable, is a satisfying one. However, it is not the characters who dominate this food-lovers' novel, but the food itself. Described in richly evocative phrases, food, in its powerful effect on the emotions and behaviour of the characters, is really the star of this story. Food dominates, and is used to create tension, to solve issues, to bring people together, be it for friendship, family issues, business or love. Descriptions of meals are passionately described, and we are persuaded to see how the particularly powerful, sexually arousing effects of dishes that persuade people to like, love, or indeed to disdain, others. Melodramatic it may be, but it is a happy, well-written and quite simply enjoyable book that brings a smile to the face and enjoyment not dissimilar to watching a good cookery program on television.
Elizabeth Bondar

The curious case of the missing mammoth by Ellie Hattie

cover image

Ill. by Karl James Mountford. Little Tiger Press, 2017. ISBN 9781848694484
Bong! Oscar is woken by the town clock striking midnight and strange noises in the street. As he looks out his window he sees a huge, hairy woolly mammoth. Instead of being scared, he is dressed and outside in a flash where Timothy the mammoth explains he is searching for his little brother. Together they continue the search which leads them to the town museum where the door opens a crack to reveal the inhabitants have come alive and are having a party. Continued through the interactivity of gatefolds, lift-the-flaps and speech bubbles the search progresses through the various sections of the museum until... It is certainly the most extraordinary hour of Oscar's life.
Apart from kids' universal curiosity about the mysterious creatures of the past, this is a book that will delight young children as they explore it over and over as it combines so much information as the quest continues. There is so much detail included that there will be something new to explore and learn with every reading. It is certainly an intriguing way to help them discover their world and enjoy having to be part of the action to move the story along.
Barbara Braxton

Bring me the head of Ivy Pocket by Caleb Krisp

cover image

Ill. by John Kelly. Ivy Pocket series; book 3. Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781408858721
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Themes: Orphans and orphanages; Jewellery; Ghosts; Supernatural stories; Mystery and suspense stories; Ghosts; England - Social life and customs - 19th century. This is a fabulous conclusion to the Ivy Pocket series, here ghosts are laid to rest, answers to mysteries revealed and lost friends rescued. This feisty protagonist faces dangers head on, relying on her quick thinking, fighting skills, acerbic dialogue and fun disguises to rapidly race through across the country and into an alternate kingdom.
Ivy's final missions are difficult ones; she needs to rescue Anastasia Radcliff and young Rebecca Butterfield from dreadful circumstances. Of course, the evil henchwoman Miss Always and the creepy little Locks are chasing her across country, causing her trouble at every turn.
As Esmeralda Cabbage, Ivy returns to Butterfield Park, scene of a previously disastrous birthday party ready to confront Lady Butterfield, Countess Carbunkle and Estelle Dumbleby. Hidden beneath a secret passage in the ballroom is Anastasia's prison and Ivy is there to assist with her friend's escape. With the concerns about the Clock Diamond not working and her enemies closing in, Ivy's bold antics and her willingness to overstep the boundaries are fun to read. Ivy's exploits in the fantastical world of Prospa are intense as she confronts her nemesis, delves into the mystery of the Shadow and races against time to find the portal back into the real world.
John Kelly's comical drawings display some of Ivy's most intense scenes; the Countess and her headdress of peacock feathers in flames and Ivy's triumphant tea party are highlights.
Calvin Krisp's Bring me the head of Ivy Pocket will delight those readers who have enjoyed the exploits, adventures and quirky character of this fun female protagonist. This series is perfect for a Middle Primary class novel, as the author's humorous narrative is engagingly alliterative, deliciously descriptive and certainly attention grabbing.
Rhyllis Bignell

The Mysterious Mr Jacob : Diamond Merchant, Magician and Spy by John Zubrzycki

cover image

Transit Lounge Publishing, 2017. ISBN 9780995359437
(Age: 16+) This story, claimed by William Dalrymple to be 'one of the most exciting narrative histories to come out of India', is indeed utterly fascinating. Set in the late 1800s and early 1900s, the story is centred on Alexander Malcolm Jacob, who arrived in Bombay in 1865. His parentage is unknown, seemingly because he mostly tended to claim different stories at different stages of his life. It is not a light narrative, its stories often complex and their 'truth' quite often questionable, yet it is, at times, so mysteriously fantastic that it seems as if he could have been a character in a fictional fantasy.
Jacob became well-known in his own world of commerce, in the Indian world of the time, particularly through his diamond-dealing, the stones he sourced often being worth millions. However, he was also known as a great magician, his complex tricks often being challenged as impossible, therefore judged to be real magic, and therefore unacceptable. As there appeared to be many for whom the tricks were too difficult to comprehend, he was ironically criticized for this very complexity, judged to be too close to real magic for the audience, who ranged from the wider European community of expatriates and those from the world of the Middle East, as it was known at the time.
Keeping to the narrative genre, Zubrycki creates a believable and indeed mysterious character whose fabulous wealth and control of his world seem to have been impossible, given his background. Indeed, it is this aspect that was so referred to so often in the work by his critics. His capacity to create apparent magic, the strength of his personality, his persuasive powers, his ability to buy and sell works of art, particularly fabulous jewels, made him renowned across British India, and abroad. He is said to have bought diamonds from Australia, to have had friends in many countries, to have worked impossible sleights of hand that could not be analysed, which added to his mystery, and yet, before he lost his wealth, status and friends, he appears to have been charismatic, mysterious and to have been a consummate magician. He was interviewed by pragmatic journalists, and even these non-believers wrote that there was something unreal about this man's powers.
It would be a suitable book for older adolescents, as an informative and challenging account of an unusual man. However, I would suggest that this is not a book for younger readers because of its subject, its complexity, its literary/historical nature, its references to the real world of the Raj, and India in this historical period (comprehensible with an understanding of India's complex history), and because of the unresolved, and indeed mysterious aspects that are part of its complexity.
Elizabeth Bondar

Julius Zebra: Bundle with the Britons by Gary Northfield

cover image

Julius Zebra series. Walker Books, 2017. ISBN 9781406373721
(Age: 8+) Ancient Rome. Animal stories. Gladiators. Humorous stories. Champion gladiator Julius Zebra returns in another crazy adventure accompanied by his zany animal friends. Life for the People's Champion should be exciting; everybody loves this zebra, he even signs hoof print autographs in the muddy streets of Rome. Emperor Hadrian has promised Julius his freedom after one last fight at the Colosseum, but the ruler has an alternate plan. Unfortunately, they have one more task to complete, a tournament in distant Britannia. Julius is disappointed as he was set to enjoy his upcoming holibobs, while Felix the warthog wanted to add to his extensive rock collection and Rufus the giraffe planned a relaxing fishing holiday. Instead, they must travel on a stinky sailing ship, far across the seas to an unknown place to fight in another tournament.
Septimus the gladiators' trainer is a hard taskmaster on board; he forces the animals to scrub the decks daily and sleep in hammocks inside the stinky hold. An attempt to dress in chainmail and escape the confines of the ship leads to a hilarious incident that requires the rescue of the crocodile, warthog, giraffe, lion and antelope.
Life in Roman Britain proves fraught with danger, the smelly streets of Londinium treacherous, and their holiday home a hovel near the small amphitheatre. The animals are quirky character drawn together in difficult circumstances, unaware that their opponents are mean fighting machines.
Gary Northfield's hilarious cartoons highlight how Julius and his friends struggle with life in an unknown land, as they prepare to face new combatants in the arena. The animals' irreverent dialogue is sharp, witty and sarcastic. This is another laugh out loud story, with plenty of jokes, gags and puns. These stories combine facts about Ancient Rome life with humorous scenes and silly animal antics.
Rhyllis Bignell

Under the same sky by Mojgan Shamsalipoor, Milad Jafari and James Knight

cover image

Hachette, 2017. ISBN 9780733637827
(Age: 15+) At a time when more than 20 million refugees seek shelter in countries which wrestle with questions regarding asylum, this story simply tells of the lives and experience of Mojgan Shamsalipoor and Milad Jafari, two young people from Iran.
Mojgan's background was one of financial hardship, with her single mother struggling to provide for the family and often having to depend upon the charity of relatives to access accommodation. It would appear that desperation drove her to remarry, hoping to create a more stable life and home for Mojgan, her sister and brothers. Sadly, the situation became nightmarish for Mojgan and her mother when her brutal and violent stepfather commenced beatings and sexual assault before arranging a marriage to a man old enough to be her grandfather. Trapped by oppressive Sharia law which offered no escape and administrative corruption which enabled and supported the stepfather, Mojgan and her brother Hossein undertook the perilous journey to escape Iran.
Also growing up in Iran, Milad experienced a more secure life in a family provided for by his father who worked hard and enjoyed financial success. Life became dangerous for this family however as Milad came under police scrutiny for producing forbidden Hip Hop music and other family members became imperilled from simply knowing people who had been arrested and subsequently murdered for political reasons.
The tension and fear experienced by these young people fleeing an oppressive regime, risking their lives to the hands of people smugglers and enduring a frightening, arduous journey by boat is difficult to adequately express. Similarly the anxiety produced by protracted detention, the seemingly endless asylum application process and fear of terrible consequences if rejected and returned to Iran is impossible to summarise.
Meeting in Australia, Milad and Mojgan fall in love and marry, however their newfound joy turns to stress and fear when asylum is refused for Mojgan and she is pressured to return to Iran.
Recent events have prompted renewed consideration of Australia's asylum policy in relation to Moslem refugees by politicians, media commentators and the general public. Evident in this book was the fact that life for asylum seekers fleeing oppression is miserable and this is removed from any ideological debate concerning whether Australia ought or ought not accept Moslem refugees.
What affected me most powerfully was a sense of fury and despair that the world's refugee problem is principally caused by political and / or religious lunacy which foments oppression and violence. Whilst this continues, millions of innocents will continue to be driven from their homes where they might otherwise have stayed to live productive and happy lives.
Rob Welsh

Double take! a new look at opposites by Susan Hood

cover image

Ill. by Jay Fleck. Walker Studio, 2015. ISBN 9781406377293
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Opposites. Perspective. Points of view. More than a look at opposites, this interesting picture book is also a challenge for the reader to ponder and delve into what an opposite really means and to think about different points of view. Hood has written an engaging, thought provoking text in rhyme, looking not just at what a simple opposite can mean but how it relates to who wants to know and the perspective of the person asking:
Who knows what's BIG
    unless there's SMALL?
Does SHORT mean a thing
    except next to TALL?

The illustrations done in a retro style by Jay Fleck are evocative and add much to the text. The one on the back of the book with the blurb was particularly engaging showing a tall flower in a small pot with a bird looking at it and a short flower in a big pot with a mouse looking at it. Another that caught my eye was the elephant lifting a large weight that contrasted with the boy trying to lift a small one:
Who's STRONG
    and who's WEAK
is hardly perplexing

Then the reader turns the page to see a double page spread with a giant whale and the text:
But STRONG can look WEAK
    when a new champ is flexing.

The use of different styles of print to highlight the point being made also adds to the fun of the book and would lead to easy emphasis when reading aloud.
This would be a very useful book to have in the classroom, and its easy rhythm and fun illustrations will engage both readers and listeners.
Pat Pledger

The girl guide by Marawa Ibrahim

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2017. ISBN 9781847809483
(Age: 10-15) Highly recommended. Star rating: 5/5. This is the book I wish my mum put on my bedside table instead of 'Where did I come from?'!!
Growing up is a tough gig, especially in a society where advertisement and media plays a huge role (unconsciously or not) in providing education to women around our bodies, growing up and the portrayal of what is normal. What Marawa Ibrahim has done with this book has taken ALL the things that happen to girls growing up and written down what really happens. From periods, hormones and bras to embarrassing moments, friendships and just being yourself, it is all in there.
One of the things I really enjoyed about this guide is that each of the 50 lessons are shown in a very light-hearted easy to read way, however you also get the sense that these experiences really were her own and that made me feel more comfortable in my own personal experience. I feel that this will transfer well to the younger female reader who reads this book either at the start of or throughout their journey with their changing body.
Marawa tells us about her inner most embarrassing moments, and then how she got over them. You get the pros and cons of the various types of hair removal and the benefit of stretching and meditation - there really is something for everyone.
The blurb states that The girl guide is "packed with practical advice, this book is a stylish agony Aunt for any 10 year old girl" and I feel that this is 100% true. It answers all the questions you want to ask your mum or friends but are too shy or embarrassed to, and does so in a way that any 10-15 year old girl would completely understand.
Lauren Fountain

Goodly and Grave: in a bad case of kidnap by Justine Windsor

cover image

HarperCollins, 2017. ISBN 9780008183530
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. Magicians. Kidnapping. London. Nineteenth century. The Penny Dreadful is full of the stories of missing children in London, with dire predictions of what has happened to them. Lucy Goodly meets her match at the card table at one of London's seamier gambling establishments, when she is beaten by someone with better skills at cheating. So convinced that she would win, she set herself against the dastardly Lord Grave, and in losing must return with him to Grave Hall and be his boot boy. Here she finds strange things happening, the cook is a bearded man dressed in women's clothing, she overhears people speaking of the missing children, she goes into a room where she meets a talking raven. Lucy must use her wits if she is to help solve the puzzle of Grave Hall, rescue the children, release those entrapped by magic, and get back to her own family.
Her suspicions of Lord Grave and all the others in his employ cause Lucy to take the magic route offered by the raven and she lands in the castle of Amethyst, Grave's enemy. But here too, she comes to disbelieve what she is being told, and seeing the woman collect the tears of the children, realises that something is very wrong.
A heart thumping thriller of a story, Lucy lurches from one grave situation to another, often accompanied by other children, all trying to deflect the lies they are being told. But who can be trusted? Twists occur on every page, but Lucy's tenacity shines through. Readers will love the humour as well as the plethora of strange beings, working with Lucy to try and find out what is really happening to the children kidnapped from the streets of London. And for those completely enraptured with the situation Windsor presents, the second in the series will follow soon.
Fran Knight

The Diamond Horse by Stacy Gregg

cover image

HarperCollins Children's Books, 2017. ISBN 9780008124403
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. This book has two main characters, each with their own unique story to tell, each with a challenge that they need to overcome to be able to move on. These two characters are connected in a way even they are not aware of.
Being a princess is not all it is cracked up to be. Anna lives in a beautiful palace with a number of animals around her, some living in the palace and others in cages in the grounds of the palace. Anna has a special way with the animals that everyone around her is not happy with. The main animal she has to be wary of is her older brother, who is determined to make Anna's life unbearable.
Anna is faced with a number of challenges that she has to endure, some things no princess should have to deal with.
Valentina is a circus performer with a love of animals, she does all she can to protect the animals from the mean ring master. Valentina is looking to her future and trying to do what she can to make her life better.
I highly recommend this book. Once you start reading it is hard to put it down.
Karen Colliver

13 reasons why by Jay Asher

cover image

Penguin Random House, 2017. ISBN 9780141387772
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Suicide. A gripping story that you can't put down, you need to know what comes next. The way the story is written helps to keep you intrigued and wanting more, needing to know how the various characters are intertwined and how their stories impact upon each other.
The two main characters are telling their stories intertwined together, the more you read the more you see how each character has an impact on others sometimes on purpose and other times without even realising it.
This book discussed a number of controversial topics that can be life changing. Hopefully this book will spark conversations about these topics that are not normally talked about.
This book reminds us that we never really know what someone else is thinking or feeling or how what we say or do impacts on another person.
This story could be set in any town with a park and a diner.
Hopefully after reading this book it will start some discussions around the topics that are discussed, it may encourage people to talk to their friends about things that are happening in their lives.
What you do can have an effect on others that you may not be aware of or intending.
Sometimes we don't even know what we are thinking or really feeling.
This book also highlights the impact that suicide has on the people left behind and hopefully that will again spark discussion around this topic.
Karen Colliver

A true story: Ballerina dreams by Michaela and Elaine DePrince

cover image

Faber and Faber, 2017. ISBN 9780571329731
(Age: 7-10) Recommended. At first, with its pink background and cute dancer on the cover I thought this was another ballerina story for young girls but Ballerina dreams is a lot more than that. Written by Michaela DePrince and her adoptive mother Elaine, this story reveals Michaela's amazing journey from being an abandoned orphan in Sierra Leone, West Africa, to an international ballet dancer.
Michaela describes how she felt alone and valueless because as well as loosing her parents she had a skin complaint called vitiligo. Vitiligo made her skin loose some of its colour and she had noticeable white spots on her chest and neck. This made her even more of an outsider.
By chance, Michaela finds a torn page showing a picture of a ballerina, blowing in the wind. Immediately she decides that is what she wants to be. An amazing dream for an orphan with only one friend but this is exactly what happens. She is sent to America and meets her new mother, Elaine DePrince who supports her goals.
The book is aimed for year 2-4 students and the story has been adapted for that age group but I listened to Michaela on a TED talk describe the horrors she saw and experienced before arriving in the USA. Yet her message is clear,
'It doesn't matter if you dream of being a doctor, a teacher, a writer, or a ballerina. Every dream begins with one step. After that, you must work hard and practise every day. If you never give up, your dream will come true.'
The book fits easily into a young hand and has simple but effective illustrations on most pages. It will appeal to young aspiring ballerinas and they will learn a lot about the power of love and conviction.
Watch Michaela dance on YouTube.
Jane Moore

Stargazing for beginners by Jenny McLachlan

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781408879757
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended, Stars, Family, Competition, Space, Responsibility. The first line of her speech says it all. 'Space to me is about being free'.
When Meg goes to school she can leave her messy life behind: her mother who still lives like she is a teenager, her grandfather who is forgetful and as a result, sometimes dangerous, and the council flat she lives in with mum and her eighteen month old sister, Elsa. She is practising her speech for the competition which will win her a seat at Mission Control at NASA for the launch of the next space ship, but with no time to rehearse and a major hurdle to overcome, it does not look likely that she will win. She is obsessed with space, so much so that she identifies a football drawn on Ed's book to be an asteroid, one coming close to earth in the next few weeks. Without trying, she makes her group laugh uproariously at her geeky slip and again eats her lunch by the wall near the girls' toilets, alone. She has a strong aversion to speaking out loud, and giving a speech in front of an audience fills her with dread.
But then Mum goes to Myanmar. Ostensibly taking a friend to the airport, she rings Meg from the plane, leaving the girl with the responsibility of her young daughter, telling her to go and live with her grandfather. Meg is overawed. Her grandfather needs looking after and cannot possibly look after them. How can she look after the toddler, go to school, rehearse for the competition speech, navigate the daily slights at school, avoid the authorities who may take the baby away and deal with her eccentric grandfather.
This funny look at one girl's life made me applaud her tenacity, daring and strength. With her mother away she needs to draw on all her reserves to help them cope with the reality of being alone. And she finds that she develops more love for her sibling, a bond she was unable to share with her mother.
This is a wonderful story, beautifully written and full of underlying humour. The insights into family and peer relationships captivated me from the start and the continuous reference to space and its part in her life, was wholly engrossing.
Fran Knight