Review Blog

Feb 18 2011

The Messenger by Yannick Haenel

cover image

Translated by Ian Monk. Text Publishing, 2011. ISBN 9781921758003.
(Age17+ years) The Polish ghettos and the death camps established by the Nazis during World War 2 for the elimination of the Jews were hidden from the eyes of the world. This book tells the story of one man, Jan Karski, who, although not a Jew, did visit both the Warsaw ghetto and one of the death camps so that he could take first hand knowledge to the allies about the fate of those incarcerated. As a young Polish officer at the start of the war Jan Karski escaped both the invading Germans and Soviets to become a runner for the Polish underground. In 1942 he was smuggled into the Warsaw ghetto by two Jewish leaders and asked to inform the 'civilized' world about what he saw, to carry a message to open the eyes of the allies to what was happening to the Jewish people. It is an understatement to write that he was shocked by the suffering, there in the ghetto and in the camp he succeeded in visiting. Through contacts in the Polish government in exile he took his terrible message to England and the United States. His appeals to the allies were met with disbelief and even, he suspected, boredom. His message rejected, he had to live with both the horror of what was happening and the belief that the allies were compliant. The book is tripartite; the first section describes Karski's appearance in the Claude Lanzmann movie Shoah, the second is a summary of Karski's own book Story of a secret state (1944), and the third is a fictionalized version of Karski's attitudes/philosophy many years later. In the first section we see on camera how Karski resisted his memories, and then the horror of the images that he gradually offers. The second section describes his life as an agent, his difficulties, being captured and tortured, and finally reaching the 'land of the free'. The final section is an imaginative reconstruction of Karski's life in New York, his sleeplessness, his attempts to escape the past by suppressing memories, and his final embracing of the need to bear witness. This is the story of a man who still believes that his message has not been heard, and that he therefore still carries the message. So disgusted by the camp, he believes that he died afterwards, but came back to life to carry a pinpoint of light that he continues to try to shine on those terrible events. The story is compelling, horrifying and challenging, and could make an illuminating comparison with the movies The Pianist or Schindler's List, or with the Jacobson novel The Finkler question. It is recommended for capable senior students.
Jenny Hamilton

Archived Blog Entries
Latest News
2019 CILIP Carnegie and Kate Greenaway Medals
2019 Boston Globe-Horn Book Award winners
Vale Judith Kerr
Nebula Awards 2019
2019 Locus Awards Finalists
Branford Boase Award 2019 shortlist
Little Rebels Award 2019 shortlist
2019 Teens' Top Ten shortlist
UKLA 2019 shortlists

ReadPlus Features
Print similar authors bookmark
Read similar authors
How to find lesson plans
Sample theme animation

Promote Reading
Free Rights of the Reader Poster
Value of School Libraries