Reviews

Rain before rainbow by Smriti Halls

cover image

Illus. by David Litchfield. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781406382358.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. A girl and her dog sit rather pensively on the front cover, looking forward, seeing a newly formed rainbow peeping through the trees. Light shines around them urging the reader to open the book to see how the story unfolds. The title is repeated on page one, followed by 'clouds before storm' alerting the reader to a rhyming pattern that will entreat them, encouraging them to read on. The dog looks forward, the girl hesitatingly looks behind, but over the page they have a light to guide them as the words tell the reader the 'old day is done'. By now readers will be in tune with the direction the book is taking, that of reminding all readers that there is darkness before morning, and that they must look forward to a brighter day rather than hesitate in the gloom.
With mental health such an issue for adults and children alike, more books are being published which encourage a positive attitude amongst younger readers. This one with its double pages of luminous colours will intrigue readers as they follow the girl's journey from darkness to light, night to morning. The words remind us that there are mountains to cross and journeys to take, decisions to make, and sometimes the dark will be upsetting, with dragons to fight and worries to overcome, there are ways to get over these fears. They can seek out friend and pathways, journeys, maps, ropes to hold on to, and finally a new day will dawn that is full of light and promise. And all of this is brightly reflected in the accompanying colour filled illustrations.
The rhyming pattern will enthral readers as they predict what the rhyming word might be, ready to call out a rhyming word at the end of each page, learn some of the lines to call out when the book is read again. Read out loud or in small groups, the whole will encourage positive attitudes, allowing children to discuss some of their fears, and give them pathways to help themselves maintain hope. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Courage, Hope, Mental health, Depression, Friendship.
Fran Knight

Ernie's journey by David Woodland

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9780648785149.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. The spotlight falls on the power of storytelling in this new book from Berbay which publishes 'clever books for curious kids'. Woodland, a debut author uses his considerable skills honed in the film and animation industries to produce a story which highlights the way in which the telling of stories can influence others. Eli loves listening to Uncle Ernie, especially his stories about his travels and adventures. He has been hang gliding over the Great Dismal Swamp, used a cactus mobile to cross the Gobi Desert, skated across Antarctica and now home, wearing his bed socks and glasses, tells his nephews and nieces about his adventures. Eli asks him about one particular adventure, that of helping the occyphants and so the story unfolds of how Uncle Ernie helped them stop floating in the air with a simple change to their diet. Eli then asks for a story he has not heard before, and Uncle Ernie tells him about the chameleon mice. Eli then responds telling his own story about his big adventure with a giant crab, and when the cousins question the truthfulness of the story, Uncle Ernie points out the two large crab claw scratches on Eli's shell.
Uncle Ernie then tells the children of the time he was in the cave with the snakes and spiders, where all you could do was run away.
Each story focusses on a different type of adventure: helping others, testing your endurance, being creative and knowing when to retreat.
Uncle Ernie gives Eli his golden compass with which to go on his own adventures, and so he does, following in Uncle Ernie's footsteps and seeing the stories for himself.
Children will envisage a future where he now rests in his bed socks and tells an appreciative audience of his adventures.
This delightful tale of the power of storytelling, of imagination and creativity will be a hit read aloud to younger children. They will delight in the unusual creatures and machines Uncle Ernie meets, the adventures he has, the problems he solves.
The curiously understated illustrations with whiffs of Shaun Tan, Steven Woolman and Paul O'Sullivan, are engrossing in their detail and array of creatures which kids will love finding. I loved the compass endpapers and the scary caves in which the snakes and spiders lived and so will the readers.
Find out more about David Woodland and his work on the author's site.
Themes: Courage, Storytelling, Adventure, Family.
Fran Knight

Jumbo the most famous elephant who ever lived by Alexandra Stewart

cover image

Illus. by Emily Sutton. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526608581.
Highly recommended. Many, many years ago, there was an elephant named Jumbo. His story is one that has been told thousands of times over the years, and has lead to major changes in the realm of animal welfare. In this book Alexandra Stewart tells us the most amazing story about Jumbo's life and trek from the Sahara all the way to this his final resting place in America's National History Museum.
I was really enthralled by this book and read it from front to back as soon as I got it. I have now read it to my children, family members and other staff at my school!
We learn about how, in the 1860s, an elephant was shipped, trained and shipped again across the world! How his life varied in the zoo and the circus and eventually how modern science has allowed us to learn many new things about the magnificent Jumbo. Alexandra Stewart also tell us about the people involved in Jumbo's life, especially Mr Scott an extra special keeper/handler in the elephant's life.
Woven in to the pages is also information about the London Zoo, the difference between Asian and African elephants, and the lasting effect of his legacy in today's animal welfare and conservation efforts.
Overall, this book is one of my favourites! The story is engaging and full of interest at every page turn. I loved learning about Jumbo and how he was looked after over 100 years ago.
I cannot leave this review without talking about the illustrations. Emily Sutton has really created something special. Every page is beautiful. Her use of watercolours with pencil outlines shows the animals' emotions and brings them to life! I particularly love the pages depicting the London Zoo and the final page of the elephants in the sanctuary.
5 out of 5 for this book, especially great for the animal lover in your life.
Lauren Fountain

Fox: A circle of life story by Isabel Thomas

cover image

Illus. by Daniel Egneus. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526600776.
(Age: 5+). Highly recommended. Fox is a thoughtfully written factual picture book. The story begins and ends with the reader being encouraged to look and listen closely. There is life stirring in the shadows. The journey of the fox searching for food to feed her young is written in short sharp sentences e.g. 'Rabbits nibble fresh green shoots. Then freeze. Ears stiffen. Noses twitch. Fox creeps, then leaps.' This simple text will appeal to younger readers but also encourage the reader to look carefully at the clever illustrations which further enhance the meaning of the story. It is evident that the author has studied foxes and knows their traits as she has described the movement of the adult fox and the way her cubs play beautifully. She has cleverly introduced the reader to the unfamiliar word of 'gekkering' which is to make a series of stuttering throaty vocalizations in the manner of foxes when encountering a rival. This story though is ultimately one about the circle of life. The adult fox dies on the road, the cubs find their way safely back to the den and the body of the fox decomposes in the way nature intends it to. The death of the fox is sensitively addressed and the author is quite honest in the description of what happens to the body. At the completion of the story are important facts about what happens when something dies. The illustrations by Daniel Egneus seamlessly complement the text.
Fox is perfect for reading aloud in the classroom or sharing at home. A welcome addition to both public and school libraries. Themes: Foxes, Life Cycle, Factual picture book
Kathryn Beilby

A time for mercy by John Grisham

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2020. ISBN: 9781529342338.
(Age: Senior secondary/adult) Recommended. Small town Mississippi lawyer Jake Brigance is given a case no one else wants. Popular Deputy Stuart Kofer has been shot and killed. It's Jake's duty to defend an immature 16 year boy who has admitted to pulling the trigger.
The town of Clanton in Ford County Mississippi is not large, but it does have a sheriff with a number of deputies as well as a city police force. Surprisingly its sheriff, Ossie Walls is black. He like other elected officials including the judge is up for reelection in the coming year. Mississippi in America's deep south is church going and conservative, they have the death penalty and many believe the gas chamber is not used often enough.
Twice divorced Kofer has been living with Josie and her two teenaged kids for a number of months. She has a history; pregnant at 15, a few unhappy and dysfunctional relationships, a couple of drug convictions, some time in prison, her kids in care and a life, at times, of living out of her car. Josie jumped at the chance of some stability, a roof over her head and food on the table. Kofer seemed like a great choice. But Stuart had a dark side especially when drunk, which was becoming more frequent.
Opinion in the town, from law enforcement, the Kofer family and the God fearing community was that who ever shot Stuart Kofer should go to the gas chamber. Jake Brigance has been leaned on by Judge Omar Noose to be the state appointed attorney for young Drew Gamble. He is about to become the most unpopular guy in town.
The facts of the case seem straight forward, an open and shut case. But as Jake gets to know Josie Gamble and her son Drew and daughter Kiera, the sympathy he has with the family grows as does his concern for the well being of Drew. Drew, though 16 has not yet hit puberty. He is small thin and looks 12. After his arrest he is withdrawn and hardly seems aware of what he has done. He is locked in the Clanton jail, a hostile environment with no facilities for a juvenile especially one with significant trauma. Kiera on the other hand, though 14, is physically mature and attractive, though timid and inhibited.
Jake Brigance has the support of the law firm and a few stalwart friends, but there has been a loss of business and threats to his family for his defence of Drew Gamble. He successfully gets Drew out of jail for psychological assessment and counselling and is able to arrange for Josie and Kiera to be cared for by one of the local churches.
When the trial begins Jake proves to be a consummate court room performer. He is able to use the few assets the Gamble family situation provides with skill like a chess player and keeps facts from the prosecution until the trial.
Grisham has written many books, many of them court room dramas, but A Time For Mercy seems fresh, riveting and eminently readable. Politics, the legal system, "the South", prejudice, religion and the human condition all blend to make this novel a joy to read.
Themes: Crime, Court room, Lawyers, Murder, Mississippi, Death penalty.
Mark Knight

Through the night sky by Anita Ganeri

cover image

Illus. by Charlotte Pepper. Dorling Kindersley, 2020. ISBN: 9780241355459.
(Age: 8+). Highly recommended. Through The Night Sky is a stunningly presented non-fiction book which captures many and varied aspects of what happens in the night sky. It is described as "A collection of amazing adventures under the stars." The striking contents page is presented in a whimsical horizontal format across a double page. The headings are:
1. Night flight
2. Lighting the dark
3. Seeing with stars
4. A night of flowers
5. Heavenly lights
6. The moon
7. Into darkness
8. Happy New Year
9. Signs in the stars
10. A journey to Earth
11. A visitor from above
12. Eyes to the sky
13. Our base in space
14. Seeing the Solar System
Each topic has a double page spread with simple yet informative text and further explanations and labels when required. The book contains a wide range of topics including historical information and relevant and recent facts about space, technology and nature. For example there is information on comets, the planets in our solar system, meteor showers, eclipses, the moon, flowers at night and nocturnal animals. The identification of the more noticeable constellations in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres are beautifully illustrated and will appeal to those young budding astronomers. There is a detailed index for a quick search of topics.
The illustrations by Charlotte Pepper seamlessly complement the text and are quite exquisite. Photographic images add to the enjoyment of the book.
Through The Night Sky
is perfect for sharing in the classroom or at home or browsing by an individual both young and old. It would make a very special gift. Themes: Nocturnal Animals, Planets, Moon, Stars, Time.
Kathryn Beilby

Dragon Mountain by Katie and Kevin Tsang

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2020. ISBN: 9781471193071.
(Age: 8-10) Dragon Mountain is a simple but imaginative tale that could be useful for introducing younger children to the fantasy genre. The setting is a mountain in rural China in contemporary times. The formula is that of young heroes who are sent on a camp by their parents in order to develop personal strengths and correct certain individual weaknesses. Each child bonds with a dragon that is matched to that child's particular self. As a team which relies on togetherness, they go on a quest to save both the world of humans and the world of dragons. The book concludes with a cliff hanger and if children are interested they must wait for the next book in the series.
The human characters represent different but complementary strengths. None are fully developed to the extent that children could strongly relate to them but that may come with the second book in the proposed series. The dragons who are matched to each child have their own distinctive capacities and personalities.
The authors have been sensitive about responding to current concern about gender and cultural representation. They have therefore ensured that there is gender balance and also mixed cultural representation including a bi-racial child in the cast of characters. Because of this some young readers who may not have seen themselves cast in a storybook role may enjoy an identification with the characters.
Many wonderful books have been written about quests and dragons including Carole Wilkinson's Dragon keeper series which takes readers back to the time of the Chinese Han Dynasty and the Wings of Fire series by Tui T. Sutherland which has attracted many eager fans.
Dragon Mountain is an action packed read with a plot that proceeds at a cracking pace.
Suitable for 8-10 year olds.
Wendy Jeffrey

The relentless moon by Mary Robinette Kowal

cover image

Lady Astronaut book 3. Tor Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781250236968.
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Highly recommended. Award winning Mary Robinette Kowal returns with another Lady Astronaut, Nicole Wargin, in her alternate history about flight to the Moon. Following The calculating stars and The fated sky, Earth is facing problems with the Space program, with sabotage and demonstrations arguing against it. With her husband, the Governor of Kansas, she uses her intelligence and skills to try to keep the program going and is thrilled when she is chosen to make another trip to the Moon colony. However, she faces danger as things begin to go wrong and it is clear that someone from the crew and colony on the Moon wants to disrupt life there. Will she be able to survive and help save the program?
The story is narrated in Nicole's voice, and the reader can easily relate to what she is feeling and thinking and get to know the other characters that surround her. It was different to have an older woman, in her fifties, with arthritis in her feet and a difficulty with eating when under stress as the main character. Despite her health difficulties her will power, skill with piloting, and sheer intelligence for working out complex problems came across clearly.
The setting of the Moon base, the personalities of the people who inhabit it, and the science around living on the Moon, all are described in a credible way. Each chapter has a news story about disasters that are happening on Earth and they add to the suspense as the reader finds out how badly the Earth is suffering.
With a mystery to solve, some heart-wrenching moments, an alternate history that is fascinating, codes and ciphers and a heart-warming marriage, as well as themes of racism and feminism, The relentless moon is a wonderful read. The conclusion was wonderful and unexpected. And for those who are wondering about Elma, the heroine from the first two stories, there are hints about what happens to her.
This is a really good science fiction series, with The calculating stars winning the Hugo Award, Nebula Award and Locus Award in 2019. The relentless moon is as well researched and finely written and could well be a contender for more awards for Kowal.
Pat Pledger

A deadly education by Naomi Novik

cover image

The Scholomance, book 1. Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9781529100860.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Easier to read than Uprooted and Spinning silver, which I loved, A deadly education is set in the Scholomance, a school for those with magic. El is a mouthy heroine whose magic is so strong that it could be disastrous for everyone. And Orion Lake is a young man whose whole purpose in life is saving people from the deadly creatures that haunt the school. When the two clash after Orion saves her life, secrets begin to show themselves, and El must find a way to stay alive and maybe save others at the school.
El is a grumpy, sarcastic heroine whose asides will have readers grinning, but at the same they will begin to relate to her as her life story gradually unfolds. Orion Lake too is a hero who is only appreciated for his magic powers and El is the first person who has seen him as lonely and needing real friends. El has always been aloof, but when the Scholomance is under threat she must find some allies and work with Orion to help defeat the monsters.
The descriptions of the life that the pupils must endure in the Scholomance are fascinating. Everyone needs mana (magic) to survive and there are unique ways of obtaining it, the dark magic is malia, and those who wield it to master spells pay for it later in life. Novik also explores the class system that operates in the school. There are privileged people who belong to enclaves, coming from rich and powerful families. Those who do not have these connections scurry around looking after them, in the hope that they will be accepted into an enclave after graduation.
Readers who enjoyed the Harry Potter books and the Magisterium series (Iron trial by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare) will be happy to move onto this series, as will those who liked Sorcery of thorns by Margaret Rogerson.
An eye-opening cliff-hanger conclusion will ensure that anyone who has read the first book will be eagerly waiting the next in the series.
Pat Pledger

We are all kind by P. Crumble and Jonathon Bentley

cover image

Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781760972363.
Highly recommended. "I really really really . . . LOVE this beautiful book!" writes Magda Szubanski on the front cover and I really really really . . . think the same thing. I read it to my co-reviewers, a year 5 class, just to see if I was on track and yes, they agree.
Jonathon Bentley's illustrations delight the reader on the front cover and throughout. The smiles on the faces of the animals are full of interest, concern and suggest a team approach.
Each double page contains a 4 line verse beginning with repetition of "We are All KIND" with the second and fourth line rhyming. As each page is turned the same pattern and rhythm are repeated with a comforting poetic effect - delightful for the reader and delightful for the child.
Softly sketched and coloured illustrations of different animals appear on each page. The scenarios include lending a hand, the healing power of love, mending hurts, strangers becoming friends, hospitality, steadfastness, healing loneliness, sharing, inclusion and forgiveness. Larger themes about mutually caring for the earth and doing what is right as an individual in order to look after the group are the culmination of the book.
This book is worthy of multiple re-readings. It's so full of love and joy. I can see it as a home staple bed time story, a favourite in the Junior School library and on every discerning grandparents' shopping list. With values like this, presented by such an engaging author, read by a loving adult, the lucky child will be cocooned in kindness and motivated to do what is kind.
Wendy Jeffrey

Wreck this picture book by Keri Smith

cover image

Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241449455.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Subtitled How to make a book come to life this irreverent, funny and instructive book will be adored by its readers, seeing such a range of different words, uses and applications attributed to a book. A book this author says, only comes to life when it is being used. It is not meant to live its life sitting on a shelf, but to be taken down and used.
And the uses to which this author puts the book are fanciful and exceedingly funny. The old rules assigned to a book involves not throwing them, not being rough, not folding the pages etc. have put the book under wraps as if it it were something very precious, needing to be kept under glass. But not so. A book needs to be woken up, shaken, stirred, dressed up, played with, touched and tasted.
The whole encourages children to do all of these things: to interact with the book, to feel it, smell it, taste it and fold it. Each double page shows a different use to be made of the book, encouraging imaginative play with the book, showing in the images just what can be done. You can wear the book, or read it upside down, throw a party for the book, hide a secret message within its pages, be the storm described in the book, and hug the book.
Designed to take kids out of their comfort zones regarding books, the text and images plays with the use they usually consign to books, encouraging them to see what else can be done, how they can interact with a book, and widen their use of them.Wonderful illustrations, alive with colour and imagination, different fonts and symbols, instructions and mandates, reading like a manual and guide book cover each page, ensuring the readers will be equally enthralled following the tutorial of how to wreck a book.
Themes: Books, Reading, Humour.
Fran Knight

Timeline Science and Technology: A Visual History of Our World by Peter Goes

cover image

Gecko Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781776573004.
(Age: 8+) The author of two previous non-fiction books, Timeline: A Visual History of our World and Rivers: A Visual History from River to Sea, Peter Goes, has continued his theme with his latest book Timeline Science and Technology. This new addition looks at the history of inventions, discoveries and technology that has shaped our world from the Stone Age to the present day. This book is presented as a large format read and has different coloured double pages marking the various periods of time discussed. There is a paragraph synopsis explaining the time under discussion and then a visual timeline that gives consideration to important discoveries, inventions and events. The written information curves around the clever and comical graphic images and while the text is rather small and confusing to follow at times, it presents many interesting and obscure facts. For example in the high middle ages a curfew bell rang in the evening as a signal to put out all hearths and fires, in order to avoid blazes in wooden buildings and in 1974 Art Fry created the first Post-It Note using the low-stick adhesive formulated six years earlier by his colleague.
This is a book to be shared between one or two readers or perused by an individual. There is so much information and knowledge to be discovered and those who love non-fiction facts throughout history will value this very different read. Themes: Timelines, Science, Technology, Entertainment, Medicine, Inventions, Discoveries.
Kathryn Beilby

Masquerade in Lodi by Lois McMaster Bujold

cover image

Penric and Desdemona (Publication order 9), Spectrum Literary Agency, 2020. ASIN: B08L88PCTP.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Another novella in the Penric and Desdemona series is always welcome and this time Bujold takes us back to an earlier time in Penric's life. Falling between Penric's Fox and Penric's Mission, the story takes place in Lodi on Bastard's Eve, a time of celebration for the people living in this canal city. Penric is hoping for time off but finds himself called to minister to a madman who appears to have been taken over by a wild demon. What follows is a wild chase to try and capture the runaway man, and when this doesn't happen easily Penric asks for the help of the saint in finding him and taking the demon out of him.
Bujold has added another city to the wonderful world that Penric and Desdemona inhabit, and it was fun to follow Penric's adventures as he travels across to islands, uses canals and searches the warehouses of this water bound place. The saint too, is unexpected, a young inexperienced girl, who is intelligent and has hidden talents. Other characters are fully fleshed out, and some plot twists will keep the reader wondering what will happen next.
Fans of the series will enjoy the warmth of this novella; Bujold always manages to write a feel-good story that leaves the reader satisfied. Those new to the series would probably enjoy them more by starting with the first one, and reading them in chronological order, rather than the publishing order.
Pat Pledger

Dog by Shaun Tan

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760526139.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Dog (2020) is a reissue of a story published in 2018 in Tales from the inner city, which explored many vistas of city life and the relationship between the city and its inhabitants. In this excerpt, Dog, Tan explores the relationship between humans and dogs, showing the continuous cycle of life and death, of rebirth and renewal, seen through the panoply of time and place.
'Every time I see people walking their dogs at my local park, I never cease to be heartened by the endurance and affection of this bond, its strangeness, its apparent naturalness' (Tan, included as an afterword in this book)
He goes on to tell stories of dogs mourning their owners' deaths, one waiting patiently at a railway station for nine years, underlining the bond that exists between people and their dogs.
Over millennia, dogs have been brave, loyal, trusted companions, and Tan shows this in his glorious images produced with thickly applied oil paint, covering each double page.
In the beginning a person and a dog see each other across the way and walk together side by side. Tan shows the pair walking across the yellow sun lit pages, a stunning contrast to the pages which follow: black, greys and dark blues showing a death, separation and a decline in the relationship between human and dog. Following, Tan's half dozen or so pages uncover the progress of history. In great luminous spreads of colour, Tan reveals a range of historical eras, fires, ice ages, the advent of agriculture, the industrial revolution, the rise of the railway and roads, the last unveiling a look passing between a dog and a woman on the other side of the road. They come together, appropriately on a zebra crossing, and walk on as if they have never been apart. In this way the pair seem destined to walk together for millennia to come, a natural place for both to be, a stunningly positive note on which to end.
Tan's images are stunning, with hints of Jeffrey Smart adding to their realistic portrayal of our surrounds. The swathes of colour across each page recall journeys, roads, destinations, pilgrimages, bridges, rail lines, as the person hunts, fishes, toils in the field, fights in a war.
Children will pore over the images, reading the sparse prose for greater elucidation, developing their understandings of how an exceptional artist works.
Themes: Understanding, Dogs, History.
Fran Knight

The Tower of Nero by Rick Riordan

cover image

The Trials of Apollo. Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9780141364087.
(Age: 11+) Recommended. In a return to Percy Jackson's world, Apollo - in his human form as teen, Lester Papadopoulos - must go into the final battle against the opposition of Nero and his extreme power, to enable Apollo to return to Mount Olympus. The fight is also against every awful and mythological enemy that has come under the power of the last emperor Nero. Meg is at his side and she is trying to overcome her history as Nero's adopted daughter while being Lester's 'Master' in the fight. The engagement of oracles, underground troglodytes and other demi-gods all work together to assist Lester (Apollo) to finally face the worst of the conflicts, but there is wounding, fear and the possibility that Apollo may lose his challenge and be trapped in human form without the opportunity to return to his godly form . . . and does he even want to give up his humanity?
In the world of Greek Mythology and the Percy Jackson series, this is a concluding story in the Trials of Apollo. Although it would best be read after the preceding four episodes of the trials, it is not impossible to read without prior knowledge. Fortunately, there is a glossary to explain all the mythology terminology and creatures. Rick Riordan has been able to introduce young readers to ancient mythology through his exciting quest and battle scenarios and they love the 'fantasy' elements and the adrenaline-charged action. With Haiku to foreshadow each chapter and fast-paced writing, there are no dull moments. Needing some maturity to deal with the aggressive combat within the myths of ancient worlds, this is best suited to readers aged 11+. But they will love the action! Themes: Mythology; Action/Adventure.
Carolyn Hull