Review Blog

Dec 17 2014

The Walled City by Ryan Graudin

cover image

Indigo, 2014. ISBN 9781780621999
Not suitable for younger readers. In the brutal, lawless Walled City, violent criminals are in control whilst broken, lost souls such as street children try to survive anyway they can, living in filthy squalor and being wary of everyone.
Most of the story centres upon a brothel owned by a vicious gang who press young girls into sexual slavery. Accordingly, the subject is grim with women being forcibly detained, savagely beaten, sexually assaulted and prostituted for the profit of the gang's leader.
The violence and competition for survival on the streets is such that to stay alive, children must run from ever present threats and be handy with a knife to defend themselves. Two characters have reason to gain entry to the brothel, Jin Ling seeks to rescue an enslaved sister, whilst Dai is under immense pressure to accomplish a task before a given date. Cooperating requires that the pair break the primary rule of survival, being 'Trust nobody'. This is no small matter given the hair raising exploits the pair become involved in, with each having the other's life in their hands on occasion. The mystery of Dai's race against time and his reason for being in the city took too long to reveal and became annoying and boring rather than captivating.
One of the many confronting aspects of this story is that it is based on the Kowloon Walled City, however it is set in contemporary time. A story such as this set in a futuristic, dystopian society or even a Medieval fantasy world enables escapism, however the setting of this tale firmly emphasises that many women do experience this barbarous mistreatment in our modern world. Given that lives of violence and sexual exploitation are a reality for too many women and children, it is valid for adults to be prompted to feel deeply about the misery and degradation experienced by the less fortunate. Whether this is fit and appropriate for adolescent readers is a complex question which many will have diverse, strong opinions about.
My own feeling is that the evil practices portrayed in this novel are not depicted gratuitously yet readers will be disturbed. Further, it would be concerning if readers were not disturbed by this issue but I don't consider that the novel has enough depth to make it compelling literature. For this reason I urge parents to read it carefully before giving it to their children and suggest that librarians and teachers exercise caution in regard to whether this is appropriate for their collection and if so, which age levels may borrow it.
Rob Welsh

Archived Blog Entries
Latest News
CILIP Carnegie and Kate Greenaway Medals 2018
National Book Award winners 2017
Teens' top 10
2017 Man Booker Prize

ReadPlus Features
Print similar authors bookmark
Read similar authors
How to find lesson plans
Sample theme animation

Promote Reading
Value of School Libraries
Library, Reading development and the Internet
Free Rights of the Reader Poster